Calvinism for my Catholic siblings

  • Thread starter Thread starter 2nd_Adam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I believe if Augustine lived 500 years ago, he would be a leader in the Protestant Reformation.

monergism.com/directory/search.php?action=search_links_simple&search_kind=and&phrase=augustine
You re-stated your premise and gave me a search of select quotes from your site but still didn’t answer the question…sigh

Why would Augustine, a leader of the Church and defender against those whom strayed from the Church teaching, then leave the Church and join the Reformation with those whom strayed from Church teaching?
 
You re-stated your premise and gave me a search of select quotes from your site but still didn’t answer the question…sigh

Why would Augustine, a leader of the Church and defender against those whom strayed from the Church teaching, then leave the Church and join the Reformation with those whom strayed from Church teaching?
There not quotes of Augustine. Please try to click the links again.

monergism.com/directory/search.php?action=search_links_simple&search_kind=and&phrase=augustine
 
:hug1: Here is a Calvinism thread for my Catholic siblings. On the “Sufficiency of Christ” thread, the conversation of Calvinism kept coming up.

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=396054

Therefore, this is a Calvinism thread created for my Catholic siblings to discuss with gentleness and respect within the family of God. :hug1:
The grace of Jesus is sufficient to lead us to heaven if we choose to accept it.
 
The grace of Jesus is sufficient to lead us to heaven if we choose to accept it.
LOL… I love my Arminian Protestant brothers too. You remind me so much of them.

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)

Free willy Christians are my siblings in Christ too!
 
In your site, I did a search of “Catholicism” and found some charming articles by the likes of *The Roman Catholic Controversy *author James White and The Gospel According to Rome by James MacArthur, Jr.

See here
 
CHESTERTONRULES;5948295:
Of course, Calvinists believe that we freely choose Christ like you. We know people go to Hell by refusing to come to Christ for life.
That is not what Calvinists believe.

Calvinists believe in unconditional election and irresistible grace.
 
CHESTERTONRULES;5948295:
Of course, Calvinists believe that we freely choose Christ like you. We know people go to Hell by refusing to come to Christ for life.
So Calvinist believe in a free will—that the elect can turn their backs to God if they do choose?
 
In your site, I did a search of “Catholicism” and found some charming articles by the likes of *The Roman Catholic Controversy *author James White and The Gospel According to Rome by James MacArthur, Jr.

See here
It’s Reformed Theology based on the Protestant Reformation. Some Reformed Theologians can embrace Catholics as Chrsitian siblings just like JI Packer (ECT 1 and ECT II). Some are not able to reconcile the two. Even John MacArthur and James Whitle believe and understand that there are converted Catholic Christians in the Catholic Church who are their true Christian siblings. The Magestrium does the same juggling act too in regards to seperated brothers and theology. :juggle:
 
It’s Reformed Theology based on the Protestant Reformation. Some Reformed Theologians can embrace Catholics as Chrsitian siblings just like JI Packer (ECT 1 and ECT II). Some are not able to reconcile the two. Even John MacArthur and James Whitle believe and understand that there are converted Catholic Christians in the Catholic Church who are there true Christian siblings.
Catholics that are the elect in spite of but not because of the Church in other words?
2nd Adam, what is a “true Christian sibling”?
 
Catholics that are the elect in spite of but not because of the Church in other words?
2nd Adam, what is a “true Christian sibling”?
I think each Reformed Christian would have to explain their own view. But the Magestrium does the exact same thing with Protestants and official documents like the Council of Trent and the Catholic Catechism. I think we all know we are joined to the hip somehow… as being in Christ together.
 
I spent the early formative years of my Christian life under the teaching of John MacArthur. I then spent several more years in a church that only hired pastors that graduated from The Master’s Seminary, run by John MacArthur.

I will guarantee you that there is no acceptance of Catholic doctrine or Catholics within that world of Protestantism. The hostility and belief that those associated with the Catholic Church are going to hell is very evident. There may be a rare Catholic who “get’s it” but the church itself is heretical and leading it’s followers to hell. Anybody that has spent time under these “teachers” cannot and would not preach acceptance of Catholic beliefs. To portray him, or his followers, as tolerant is a gross misrepresentation of the truth.
 
I think each Reformed Christian would have to explain their own view. But the Magestrium does the exact same thing with Protestants and official documents like the Council of Trent and the Catholic Catechism. I think we all know we are joined to the hip somehow… as being in Christ together.
What are your beliefs? Yes, you say that you are an ECT Christian but use this site which has numerous examples of anti-Catholicism.

I ask you to answer my questions in my previous post in a more direct way.
 
What are your beliefs? Yes, you say that you are an ECT Christian but use this site which has numerous examples of anti-Catholicism.

I ask you to answer my questions in my previous post in a more direct way.
It’s just the roots of Reformed Theology. A brother pm me about the Westminster West Seminary who has hired professors who graduated from Catholic seminaries to teach OT classes. I would say that Westminster West seminary is a good representation of my beliefs. I believe in remnant theology, in which there is a remnant saved by grace in all Christian communities.
 
I spent the early formative years of my Christian life under the teaching of John MacArthur. I then spent several more years in a church that only hired pastors that graduated from The Master’s Seminary, run by John MacArthur.

I will guarantee you that there is no acceptance of Catholic doctrine or Catholics within that world of Protestantism. The hostility and belief that those associated with the Catholic Church are going to hell is very evident. There may be a rare Catholic who “get’s it” but the church itself is heretical and leading it’s followers to hell. Anybody that has spent time under these “teachers” cannot and would not preach acceptance of Catholic beliefs. To portray him, or his followers, as tolerant is a gross misrepresentation of the truth.
That’s not a true statement all. Here’s an article for you to read. It was written in 2009.

christianitytoday.com/ct/2009/januaryweb-only/103-51.0.html
 
Calvinism is based upon five tenants, known as the five points of Calvinism. The acronym TULIP is often used to illustrate these tenants.

T–Total Depravity—Man can do NO good on his own. Because of Adam’s sin all mankind is totally depraved. He CANNOT please God or make any decisions for God.

U–Unconditional Election—God chooses who will be saved. This decision is completely in God and man has NO bearing in that decision. There is no free will, it is ALL God.

L–Limited Atonement—Christ died only for the elect. His death was not for everyone, only for the elect.

I–Irresistible Grace—If you are chosen, you cannot resist your position as a chosen one. You are saved whether you would choose God or not.

P–Perseverance of the Saints- Man cannot loose his salvation, once saved, always saved.

These doctrines are at the very heart of what ALL true calvinists believe. Some will try to tell you that they are 3 or 4 point Calvinists but they are then not truly Calvinist. My experience with Calvinism is that it is one of the most hostile belief systems to those that believe differently than they do. Many will even tell you that those who hold the Arminian view are heretics and condemned to hell for misrepresenting the truth of scripture.
 
It’s just the roots of Reformed Theology. A brother pm me about the Westminster West Seminary who have hired professors who graduated from Catholic seminaries to teach OT classes. I believe in remnant theology, in which there is a remnant saved by grace in all Christian communities.
Did they graduate from seminaries and then become Calvinist protestants and then teach?

Define: a remnant saved by grace.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top