Can a Bishop cancel masses?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jamz
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Jamz

Guest
We recently returned from an excellent vacation to St Augustine. We left a
day early due to the severe weather possibilities regarding hurricane
Frances. On the night before our departure, I noticed that, among other
civic and religious cancellations, “all masses in the St Augustine diocese
were cancelled.” I spoke with a few church friends who were equally stunned
that something like this was possible. While I would encourage a person to
be realistic regarding their ability to fulfill their Sunday obligation
based on external influences such as weather, I would never have thought the
bishop could take my right to attend Mass away from me. Could you please
shed some light on whether I should expect my bishop to one day cancel
Masses in all of western NC due to a potential snowstorm?
 
40.png
Jamz:
We recently returned from an excellent vacation to St Augustine. We left a
day early due to the severe weather possibilities regarding hurricane
Frances. On the night before our departure, I noticed that, among other
civic and religious cancellations, “all masses in the St Augustine diocese
were cancelled.” I spoke with a few church friends who were equally stunned
that something like this was possible. While I would encourage a person to
be realistic regarding their ability to fulfill their Sunday obligation
based on external influences such as weather, I would never have thought the
bishop could take my right to attend Mass away from me. Could you please
shed some light on whether I should expect my bishop to one day cancel
Masses in all of western NC due to a potential snowstorm?
Click to expand...
Yes the Bishop could offer a dispensation from their Sunday Obligation to all persons in his diocese because of the serious situation. That does not take away your ability to attend if you wish. Many places where Mass was suspended because of snow or Ice, the Mass actually took place and there were a few people there.
 
The diocese belongs to the bishop, it is his call.

He would not undertake such a decision frivolously.

I am not sure what “right” we have to a Divine Liturgy, or Mass. It is the bishop’s reponsibility to open and close parishes, provide priests (the community cannot provide the priest) and has ultimate responsibility for the spiritual welfare of his flock.

There are now parishes that must do without priests for some scheduled masses, it is the bishop who decides which parish has a priest and which will do without. The bishop will open missions and close old poorly attended parishes. It is an awesome responsibility.

I should hope that the faithful of the diocese were not just treating it like a day off, they could still pray (and probably did, considering the conditions at the time).

I am going to assume that the bishop knew very well what the ramifications were for that decision, and made a prudent choice. 🙂
 
Every public Mass done in a Diocese is done under the Authority of the Bishop of that diocese.

He does have the right to suspend all Masses within his diocese if he feels it is in the best interest of his flock.

All those affected by such closures are dispensed from their Sunday obligation for the duration.
 
When there are civil emergencies and the local authorities call for curfews and evacuations, the bishop is absolutely right to cancel masses. It’s not just about the mass itself, it’s about the safety of the roads, the ability of emergency workers to get to the scene of various things safely…and if there are 40,000 Catholics trying to make it to mass at the same time, the roads have 40,000 too many people on them and the possibility of many, many accidents that don’t need to happen.

FYI, it’s not only hurricanes that can call off masses. In my area, we had masses cancelled twice last winter because of severe snowstorms and once for mass power outages. In the winter of 2000, much of the Midwest was shut down for 3 days over New Years and all masses were cancelled then, too. There was dispensation given for everyone in the dioceses involved because the bishop obviously can’t pick and choose who’s in a better position to make it to mass and who isn’t. I’m also sure no bishop wants anyone’s death to occur in the name of Sunday worship, either.
 
The bishop is not trying to take away your rights, he’s trying to save the lives of the overly-scrupulous, who would venture out into a dangerous environment, driving on roads that may not be passable.

Even in Philadelphia we’ve had Snow Emergencies during which Sunday Masses were cancelled.
 
Not just the bishop, but the pastor can cancel the masses at his parish do to emergency situations. Where I live, the priest do not always live right next to the church and can not always safetly get to the church for mass, to offer it for those who wish to brave the weather. Also, many churches with their big exposed stained glass windows, are not the safests places to be durring severe windstorms and huracaines. When a bishop or priest makes this decision, they do so with much prior thought and prayer.

WE take it for granted that we can go to mass every Sunday and even every day; but there are still many parishes, IN THE USA, that only have mass once a month or less, when the priest makes his rounds to that parish.
 
40.png
DJJG:
Not just the bishop, but the pastor can cancel the masses at his parish do to emergency situations. Where I live, the priest do not always live right next to the church and can not always safetly get to the church for mass, to offer it for those who wish to brave the weather. Also, many churches with their big exposed stained glass windows, are not the safests places to be durring severe windstorms and huracaines. When a bishop or priest makes this decision, they do so with much prior thought and prayer.

WE take it for granted that we can go to mass every Sunday and even every day; but there are still many parishes, IN THE USA, that only have mass once a month or less, when the priest makes his rounds to that parish.
Click to expand...

Everyday Masses as such are not required by Church law anyway 🙂 - the pastor does have a duty to offer Mass on certain days, such as Sundays and certain feasts. And the faithful have a duty to attend on certain days.​

But there is no right, as such, to attend Mass on lesser days (such as weekdays on which there is no feast being celebrated). A lot of thinking about how Catholics act is based on law and obligation - not so much on rights. The 1917 Code gave the laity no rights at all - just obligations 🙂 It’s as well to be aware of this, when questions like the present one arise. ##
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top