Can a Catholic attend a United Methodist service?

  • Thread starter Thread starter kariled
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

kariled

Guest
Hello,

I don’t have a catholic church close home, wondering if I can attend a united methodist service, during services they are speaking about how cultivate marriages that last a lifetime which interests me. Both of us are catholic.

Wondering if I can attend their services.

Best Regards
Kari
 
Attending Methodist church will not meet your Sunday Obligation.

What does close by mean…I drive 20 sometimes 30 minutes to attend Mass. I consider this close.
 
Hello,

I don’t have a catholic church close home, wondering if I can attend a united methodist service, during services they are speaking about how cultivate marriages that last a lifetime which interests me. Both of us are catholic.

Wondering if I can attend their services.

Best Regards
Kari
You may attend their service as a guest, but you still must go to Catholic Church. The Methodists are not in communion with Rome, and so their service may be visited, but not take the place of a Mass
 
Hello,

I don’t have a catholic church close home, wondering if I can attend a united methodist service, during services they are speaking about how cultivate marriages that last a lifetime which interests me. Both of us are catholic.

Wondering if I can attend their services.

Best Regards
Kari
Yes you may but only as an observer. It also cannot replace your obligation to attend Catholic Liturgy on a Sunday or Day of Obligation. How close to home do you need a Catholic parish to be for you to attend? Many people in small towns would drive and hour or so one-way to Mass.
 
As others have said, you can attend, but it does not fulfill your Sunday obligation so you would need to attend a Catholic Mass as well.

I would also caution you that the UMC officially believes, according to their social principles and the Book of Discipline, that marriage is a lifelong commitment between a man and woman (see here)…and yet, despite this, recognizes divorce and does not prohibit remarriage (see here). That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t go, but you should bear in mind that the UMC conception of marriage does not always align that closely with the teaching of the Church, backed by Scripture and Tradition.

Also, there is little concern in the UMC for doctrinal consistency. I can point you to the UMC social principles which are, mostly, pretty much morally correct minus a few glaring errors…yet, you will find individual UMC pastors and leaders calling from the pulpit for homosexual ‘marriage’ and otherwise contradicting the official doctrines…so you can’t even be sure that what you get will be in alignment with the UMC doctrines, let alone with Catholic doctrine. Maybe it will a wonderful, helpful discussion of marriage that aligns with the teaching from Scripture and Tradition…then again, maybe it won’t.

I’m not meaning to condemn the UMC. I speak as one who was Baptized and Married as a United Methodist, and spent more than fifteen years as an active member of the church. I even served on leadership committees (Staff/Parish Relations and the Administrative Council, for any other Methodists and former Methodists out there) and I was a Lay Delegate to my home Annual Conference for several years, where I lent my vote and recommendations (to be passed up to the General Conference) on doctrinal statements, among other things.

My wife and I entered into full communion with the Catholic Church a bit over two years ago, in no small part because of the doctrinal wishy-washiness on marriage and other social issues that, in my opinion, were defined very clearly by Scripture and yet defined differently (or not at all) by UMC denominational policy.

God bless you 🙂
 
I would say if you would like to go, then go. Church is church, God is everywhere and prayer and worship is good no matter where it is offered. 😉 And the Methodists tend to be lovely. When I lived with my parents there lived a little old Methodist couple next door and they were like an auntie and uncle to me (and still are lol). But I will say this, I always feel better spiritually after having gone to Catholic mass than I do anywhere else because its where I feel most at home. Also I make life difficult for myself lol. I live a 5 minute walk away from a Catholic church but on sundays I take a 30 minute bus journey into town so I can attend the sung mass at 6.30. Sounds silly I know :rolleyes: but its worth it because I know and love the priests at the church in town and the atmosphere and the mass is most fullfilling to my relationship with Jesus as someone who is more spiritually inclined towards Catholicism. However, as I said before, God is everywhere. 😉 Lots of love, me darlin.
 
God is everywhere but to say “Church is Church” is to equate non-Catholic worship with the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass and the celebration of the sacred mysteries which it contains. This simply is not so.

Christ is present sacramentally only in the ciboriums and tabernacles of the Holy Catholic Church which He established. The Holy Catholic Church is the Body of Christ and we are incorporated into that Body through the reception of the sacramental presence of Christ which comes to us in the Eucharist only through priests of that very same Church.

Many non-Catholic denominations have lovely worship, worship that is doctrinally correct, spiritually reverent, and emotionally moving, but that worship is not the Mass. Christ is made present on the altar only by the hands of the Catholic priest and only at the Mass. Christ’s sacrifice is re-presented to God the Father only at the Mass. Only at the Mass is Christ’s sacrifice is made present in space and time - here and now for us - so that it is as efficacious now as it was it actually happened. With this re-presentation of Christ’s sacrifice, we are transported into heaven (Lift up your hearts!) where we join with the chiors of angelsand we worship in God’s actual presence as we sing “Holy, Holy, Holy Lord…” exactly as is described in Revelation 4:8. All of this takes place every hour of every day across the whole earth only in the Catholic Church. All of this happens only at the Mass.

I have been to Evangelical candlelight prayer services which made me cry but it is not the Mass. You can go to Methodist Church if you want - my mother is Methodist, a Methodist pastor stood at my Father’s bedside when he died and my best friend is a Methodist pastor. But please always remember…

It’s not the Mass.

-Tim-
 
I would say if you would like to go, then go. Church is church, God is everywhere and prayer and worship is good no matter where it is offered. 😉 And the Methodists tend to be lovely. When I lived with my parents there lived a little old Methodist couple next door and they were like an auntie and uncle to me (and still are lol). But I will say this, I always feel better spiritually after having gone to Catholic mass than I do anywhere else because its where I feel most at home. Also I make life difficult for myself lol. I live a 5 minute walk away from a Catholic church but on sundays I take a 30 minute bus journey into town so I can attend the sung mass at 6.30. Sounds silly I know :rolleyes: but its worth it because I know and love the priests at the church in town and the atmosphere and the mass is most fullfilling to my relationship with Jesus as someone who is more spiritually inclined towards Catholicism. However, as I said before, God is everywhere. 😉 Lots of love, me darlin.
Rachel, I want to address this comment directly.

Many followers of new-age spirituality feel that it is their right to move into and out of various Churches in a fluid manner, that one form of spiritual worship is as good as any other and there is really no distrinction. New-age religions which teach that one spirit is a good as the next are as likely to worship the spriit-God Yaweh as they are to worship the spirt-gods of the rocks and forests. One will sometimes meet new-age spiritualists in Catholic Churches saying things similar to your comments, things such as “All worship is good, but I get a special feeling at such-and-such Church”.

This is very dangerous. As stated in my previous post, there are some very moving and reverent forms of worship which give priase, honor and glory to God but we must never confuse that with the facts…

Only the trinitarian God of Christianity is God and all other gods are false - worshiping any other god than the trinitarian God of Christianity is worship of that which is created instead of the Creator. The only way to God the Creator is through Jesus and that Jesus established one Church to which he revealed the fullness of truth, to which he gave authority to teach based on that truth, and to which he gave the authority and mission to bring men to salvation. That Church is the Catholic Church.

Please be very careful when you start to equate all forms of spirituality with Catholicism. It is a very dangerous form of new-age religion and can lead your soul straight to Hell.

-Tim-
 
Nope and they might even allow one to partake in their Communion service. Although I think the Catholic Church says not to OP.
That is my understanding as well. Here is what Michelle Arnold, a staff apologist for Catholic Answers, wrote:
It is indeed objectively wrong to receive Protestant communion. If done with full knowledge and full and free consent, it could be a grave sin. The reasons are because Protestant communion is invalid and because reception of communion in a Protestant church implies a sacramental unity with that church that does not exist. Whether or not a Catholic also meets his Sunday obligation to attend Mass makes no difference as to whether he can receive Protestant communion. Missing Mass would be an additional offense but having gone to Mass does not wipe out the offense of deliberately receiving Protestant communion.
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=89372
 
Hello,

Thank you to all of you who explained well, I understand that UMC service does not replace Mass. I never intend to replace my Sunday obligation, questions was just If I can attend their services as they are doing a series of seminars about marriage.

Have a great day!
-Kari
 
God is everywhere but to say “Church is Church” is to equate non-Catholic worship with the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass and the celebration of the sacred mysteries which it contains. This simply is not so.
By ‘Church’ I meant the body of Christ, as in the people who love Christ. If a Catholic attended a Methodist service they’d still be with those who are Christian and would be in the presence of The Lord. I know what you mean though, I do love a good Mass.🙂
 
A couple points

** The Methodists are a fine group. They come in many different varieties**. People like McGovern and Mondale are/were Methodists, and so is George W. and Laura Bush. Years ago there was an article in LIFE magazine entitled “The American Church” and it was about the Methodists. The theme of the piece is that Methodists at that time best represented a cross-section of America, speaking politically, educationally, economically, etc. I’m not sure that this is still true, but they are a great church.

** Unlike Catholicism, Methodism allows for a wide difference of theological opinion.** There are very liberal Methodists (Unitarianish) and then there are fundamentalist Methodists, too. Most of them are somewhere in between. It has never been heavy on theology, emphasizing simple faith and Christian living. When John Wesley was attacked for his views, he replied to the effect: “If you love God as I love God, let us join hands and walk together.” He also advocated: “Think and let think.” This means that Methodism doesn’t insist on conformity when it comes to specific items of dogma.

** Yes, they use grapejuice in communion.** This is in part because of the temperance movement back when saloons were so notorious and destructive. Even today, what, 30,000,000 alcoholics give or take? Maybe it would be good if millions of us drank grapejuice instead of alcohol, and think of all we would save when we go out to eat! More important, Methodism has open communion, and this includes the idea that anyone should be able to take communion. If wine is used some alcoholics can be in danger. Catholicism, of course, traditionally has used only the host. But I have heard that an unusually high percentage of priests eventually have a problem with alcohol. I knew one AA group where we used to live. Two priests attended. I assumed they were chaplains of the groups. I discovered that no, they were alcoholics. One later left the priesthood - probably related to his addiction???

** Methodists, like most mainline Protestants, are very open-minded when it comes to other faiths**. They do not agree with Catholicism, but they are ready to work with other groups - Catholics, Jews, Muslims, etc. - to make a better society. They have been strong in the field of social justice, sometimes causing controversy within the body.
Code:
 **One hot issue, of course, is gay marriage**. The Discipline forbids clergy to officiate at a gay/lesbian ceremony, whether marriage or civil union. This issue comes up every four years at General Conference. Since the church is so strong in the South and the Midwest the vote has been about 2-1 to keep that prohibition. Many pastors, especially in the Northeast and along the Pacific coast would like to see that policy rescinded.

 **Yes, Methodist ministers may marry divorced couples. **This is left up to the individual pastor and some won't. Others will, depending upon conditions surrounding the divorce. In the case of Catholicism, of course, you have to go through a 'church-sanctioned divorce' called an annulment, which costs money, makes a couple wait, and pretends that there was something wrong with the original marriage that made it invalid from the start. Sophistry! A marriage often is okay today, but people and conditions change. Yes, Christ spoke against divorce, but he did not cite it as an unforgiveable sin. Besides, sometimes it's best for a variety of reasons, such as physical abuse, extreme alcoholism and desertion. The Methodists are far more realistic than Catholicism on this point.
** Frankly, I watch EWTN regularly, and the continual sniping at Protestantism makes me ill.** The Church pretends to promote love, humility and peace, but some of those EWTN programs seem to further bigotry, arrogance and hostility. I’ve come to the conclusion that God isn’t interested in our church affiliation or even our theology. The Lord looks at our hearts instead!

** God bless Catholics, Methodists, and people of every creed, **color, culture and country. We should spend our time making religion a bridge rather than a barrier.
 
A couple points

** The Methodists are a fine group. They come in many different varieties**. People like McGovern and Mondale are/were Methodists, and so is George W. and Laura Bush. Years ago there was an article in LIFE magazine entitled “The American Church” and it was about the Methodists. The theme of the piece is that Methodists at that time best represented a cross-section of America, speaking politically, educationally, economically, etc. I’m not sure that this is still true, but they are a great church.

** Unlike Catholicism, Methodism allows for a wide difference of theological opinion.** There are very liberal Methodists (Unitarianish) and then there are fundamentalist Methodists, too. Most of them are somewhere in between. It has never been heavy on theology, emphasizing simple faith and Christian living. When John Wesley was attacked for his views, he replied to the effect: “If you love God as I love God, let us join hands and walk together.” He also advocated: “Think and let think.” This means that Methodism doesn’t insist on conformity when it comes to specific items of dogma.

** Yes, they use grapejuice in communion.** This is in part because of the temperance movement back when saloons were so notorious and destructive. Even today, what, 30,000,000 alcoholics give or take? Maybe it would be good if millions of us drank grapejuice instead of alcohol, and think of all we would save when we go out to eat! More important, Methodism has open communion, and this includes the idea that anyone should be able to take communion. If wine is used some alcoholics can be in danger. Catholicism, of course, traditionally has used only the host. But I have heard that an unusually high percentage of priests eventually have a problem with alcohol. I knew one AA group where we used to live. Two priests attended. I assumed they were chaplains of the groups. I discovered that no, they were alcoholics. One later left the priesthood - probably related to his addiction???

** Methodists, like most mainline Protestants, are very open-minded when it comes to other faiths**. They do not agree with Catholicism, but they are ready to work with other groups - Catholics, Jews, Muslims, etc. - to make a better society. They have been strong in the field of social justice, sometimes causing controversy within the body.
Code:
 **One hot issue, of course, is gay marriage**. The Discipline forbids clergy to officiate at a gay/lesbian ceremony, whether marriage or civil union. This issue comes up every four years at General Conference. Since the church is so strong in the South and the Midwest the vote has been about 2-1 to keep that prohibition. Many pastors, especially in the Northeast and along the Pacific coast would like to see that policy rescinded.

 **Yes, Methodist ministers may marry divorced couples. **This is left up to the individual pastor and some won't. Others will, depending upon conditions surrounding the divorce. In the case of Catholicism, of course, you have to go through a 'church-sanctioned divorce' called an annulment, which costs money, makes a couple wait, and pretends that there was something wrong with the original marriage that made it invalid from the start. Sophistry! A marriage often is okay today, but people and conditions change. Yes, Christ spoke against divorce, but he did not cite it as an unforgiveable sin. Besides, sometimes it's best for a variety of reasons, such as physical abuse, extreme alcoholism and desertion. The Methodists are far more realistic than Catholicism on this point.
** Frankly, I watch EWTN regularly, and the continual sniping at Protestantism makes me ill.** The Church pretends to promote love, humility and peace, but some of those EWTN programs seem to further bigotry, arrogance and hostility. I’ve come to the conclusion that God isn’t interested in our church affiliation or even our theology. The Lord looks at our hearts instead!

** God bless Catholics, Methodists, and people of every creed, **color, culture and country. We should spend our time making religion a bridge rather than a barrier.
Thank you sir that was an excellent post!

Yes, Methodist tend to be very friendly and we welcome pretty much anyone into our church. Catholics are more than welcome to attend church service and communion is open to all who come through our front doors.
 
A couple points

** The Methodists are a fine group. They come in many different varieties**. People like McGovern and Mondale are/were Methodists, and so is George W. and Laura Bush. Years ago there was an article in LIFE magazine entitled “The American Church” and it was about the Methodists. The theme of the piece is that Methodists at that time best represented a cross-section of America, speaking politically, educationally, economically, etc. I’m not sure that this is still true, but they are a great church.

** Unlike Catholicism, Methodism allows for a wide difference of theological opinion.** There are very liberal Methodists (Unitarianish) and then there are fundamentalist Methodists, too. Most of them are somewhere in between. It has never been heavy on theology, emphasizing simple faith and Christian living. When John Wesley was attacked for his views, he replied to the effect: “If you love God as I love God, let us join hands and walk together.” He also advocated: “Think and let think.” This means that Methodism doesn’t insist on conformity when it comes to specific items of dogma.

** Yes, they use grapejuice in communion.** This is in part because of the temperance movement back when saloons were so notorious and destructive. Even today, what, 30,000,000 alcoholics give or take? Maybe it would be good if millions of us drank grapejuice instead of alcohol, and think of all we would save when we go out to eat! More important, Methodism has open communion, and this includes the idea that anyone should be able to take communion. If wine is used some alcoholics can be in danger. Catholicism, of course, traditionally has used only the host. But I have heard that an unusually high percentage of priests eventually have a problem with alcohol. I knew one AA group where we used to live. Two priests attended. I assumed they were chaplains of the groups. I discovered that no, they were alcoholics. One later left the priesthood - probably related to his addiction???

** Methodists, like most mainline Protestants, are very open-minded when it comes to other faiths**. They do not agree with Catholicism, but they are ready to work with other groups - Catholics, Jews, Muslims, etc. - to make a better society. They have been strong in the field of social justice, sometimes causing controversy within the body.
Code:
 **One hot issue, of course, is gay marriage**. The Discipline forbids clergy to officiate at a gay/lesbian ceremony, whether marriage or civil union. This issue comes up every four years at General Conference. Since the church is so strong in the South and the Midwest the vote has been about 2-1 to keep that prohibition. Many pastors, especially in the Northeast and along the Pacific coast would like to see that policy rescinded.

 **Yes, Methodist ministers may marry divorced couples. **This is left up to the individual pastor and some won't. Others will, depending upon conditions surrounding the divorce. In the case of Catholicism, of course, you have to go through a 'church-sanctioned divorce' called an annulment, which costs money, makes a couple wait, and pretends that there was something wrong with the original marriage that made it invalid from the start. Sophistry! A marriage often is okay today, but people and conditions change. Yes, Christ spoke against divorce, but he did not cite it as an unforgiveable sin. Besides, sometimes it's best for a variety of reasons, such as physical abuse, extreme alcoholism and desertion. The Methodists are far more realistic than Catholicism on this point.
** Frankly, I watch EWTN regularly, and the continual sniping at Protestantism makes me ill.** The Church pretends to promote love, humility and peace, but some of those EWTN programs seem to further bigotry, arrogance and hostility. I’ve come to the conclusion that God isn’t interested in our church affiliation or even our theology. The Lord looks at our hearts instead!

** God bless Catholics, Methodists, and people of every creed, **color, culture and country. We should spend our time making religion a bridge rather than a barrier.
Roy, a lot in your posts I often agree with as is the case with this one. And Wesley’s quote about how if you love God, let us walk together is I believe what Christ was saying when He preached love.
 
By ‘Church’ I meant the body of Christ, as in the people who love Christ. If a Catholic attended a Methodist service they’d still be with those who are Christian and would be in the presence of The Lord. I know what you mean though, I do love a good Mass.🙂
From Mean?*Catholic *
Jesus used the word church twice in the Gospels, both in Matthew. He said, “I will build my Church” (Matt. 16:18). He didn’t say “churches” as though he were building subdivisions, nor did he imply that it would be an invisible church made up of competing groups. He was going to build a visible, recognizable Church, as shown by the fact that he appointed Peter to lead it in his absence. And in Matthew 18:17, Jesus said that if one brother offends another they were to take it to “the Church.” Notice the article “the” referring to a specific entity. Not “churches” but one visible, recognizable Church that can be expected to have a recognizable leadership with universal authority.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top