Can a catholic visit an astrologer?

  • Thread starter Thread starter darkangel123
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I live in India and my parents visit this vedic astrologer often to ask about the future. Vedic astrology works on the premise that each person is ruled by a planet, and the planet is assigned based on the date and place of birth. I have never been comfortable with this and I always refuse to accompany my parents. Recently, I visited a catholic priest who told me that astrology is a science and it is ok for me to visit the astrologer. He even encouraged me to go meet one and get to know about my future because according to him, 70% of their predictions come true and this could help me with some doubts I have in my personal life.

But something tells me that I should place my trust in God and not in man and seeing the astrologer would mean that I place my trust in him. Is this correct?
Please know that a priest can teach and advice wrong/evil. Our Lady showed St. Lucia priests, bishops and Popes burning in hell. Do not play with the devil by going or believing in such things. My prayers to you and your family. 🙂
 
Jesuit court astrologers were once quite famous, my how times change.
 
That is a bit of over exageration. Vedic religion in India has been around for about 3,500 - 4,000 years (I’m assuming this is Vedic Astrology). Even assuming it was earlier it would likely be perhaps 5,000 years at the earliest.

As for Christianity it has been in India since the Apostolic Age. Saint Thomas is reported to have landed in India around 52 AD. Now Roman Catholicism is much more recent (16th century). The growth of Christianity is much more recent so some of the Vedic cultural traditions have likely “leaked in”.

(My apologies to darkangle123 or others from India if any of this is grossly inaccurate. It is mainly from conversations with a coworker from Kerala after I stuck my foot in my mouth asking why he went by Joseph [it never crossed my mind that might be his actual name :o])
I was referring loosely to the existence of humans in that region.

Good grief. Just see her other posts to understand what kind of an uphill battle this is culturally.
 
I was referring loosely to the existence of humans in that region.

Good grief. Just see her other posts to understand what kind of an uphill battle this is culturally.
I am the only person of European descent in a group of 30 people at work where every other person is from India so I am well aware of the cultural impacts. I also know that there is not a single Indian culture. The culture of Punjab is different from say Tamil Nadu. They might share similarities, but they are not part of a single unified culture.

I was correcting the fact that the current culture is not 30,000 years old. There were people in France 45,000 years ago, but we don’t consider that to be the begining of French culture. Even at that, modern humans have likely existed in india for between 50 - 75,000 years. The change to a civilization as opposed to disconnected tribal communities is generally tied to the Vedic period following the Indo-Aryan migrations.

Again, I’m not discounting the cultural influences, but rather providing historical context.
 
No, there is no confusion, Jesuit astronomers were also quite successful.
There is a difference between an astronomer and an astrologer, and there is also a difference between academics who study astrological mythology as a window into past cultures and past insights into the human psyche and those who think someone can look at a star chart and tell them the future.

Divination in any form is strictly forbidden, and while it is of course possible that some Jesuits somewhere practiced divination or advocated in favor of divination, the Jesuit order as a whole has been one of the most world’s most tireless and adamant enemies of astrology as a means of divination.
 
But something tells me that I should place my trust in God and not in man and seeing the astrologer would mean that I place my trust in him. Is this correct?
I applaud you for heeding your instincts to place your trust in God alone. As the Catechism states,“a sound Christian attitude consists in putting oneself confidently into the hands of Providence for whatever concerns the future, and giving up all unhealthy curiosity about it.” (para. 2115)

Likewise as previous posters have stated, “[a]ll forms of divination are to be rejected: recourse to Satan or demons, conjuring up the dead or other practices falsely supposed to ‘unveil’ the future. Consulting horoscopes, astrology, palm reading, interpretation of omens and lots, the phenomena of clairvoyance, and recourse to mediums all conceal a desire for power over time, history, and, in the last analysis, other human beings, as well as a wish to conciliate hidden powers. They contradict the honor, respect, and loving fear that we owe to God alone.” (para. 2116)

Furthermore, “[a]ll practices of magic or sorcery, by which one attempts to tame occult powers, so as to place them at one’s service and have a supernatural power over others –even if this were for the sake of restoring their health – are gravely contrary to the virtue of religion. These practices are even more to be condemned when accompanied by the intention of harming someone, or when they have recourse to the intervention of demons. …].” (para. 2117) I should add that engaging in these practices is the sin of *idolatry *and a violation of the First Commandment.

This reminds me of the Old Testament story of King Saul and the medium (1 Sam. 28). After Samuel’s death, Saul expelled all mediums and wizards from the land. Thereafter the Philistines warred against Saul and he became fearful. He inquired of the Lord and the Lord did not answer him. So Saul turned away from God and sought out superhuman guidance – a medium – to conjure up Samuel for guidance (this is called necromancy - conjuring up the dead). **Samuel reproached Saul for his infidelity **and announced his impeding fate at the hands of the Philistines. The Lord fulfills Samuel’s predictions and Saul and his men are overtaken by the Philistines. Jonathan and his brothers are slain in the battle, and Saul takes his own life by falling on his sword (1 Sam 31).

Also, you may want to check out the testimony of Gloria Polo who had a near death experience, was judged, and was allowed to come back to give her testimony about her judgment. You are not bound to believe, but there is one portion of her testimony that came to mind in this regard. Gloria says, "[m]any Catholics, believers and practicing, go to Mass and to the magician at the same time. Because the evil one makes to believe that there is nothing evil here, and that we go to Heaven all the same, because we certainly do not use magic to do evil to someone! The devil guides, uses and directs all of this with a very well prepared strategy. You know therefore that, when we have recourse to magic, it does not matter for whatever, the beast imprints his seal. When we go to some enchanter, or diviner, or fortune-teller, or astrologer, or to one who invokes the spirits, in all of these places the devil places his seal, his stamp.

I found myself in one of these places when I went with a friend, who brought me to an enchanter to consult her, to predict my future: there I was marked by the beast. The evil one put on me his seal. The worst thing was that, beginning from that day, in which by way of that lady I received the stamp of evil, I began to have disturbances: nocturnal agitation, nightmares, anxieties, fears, and even a profound desire to suicide! I did not understand the why of these desires! I cried, I felt unhappy, and never again did I feel in peace. I prayed, but I felt the Lord far from me: never again did I sense that nearness with Him, that instead I had when I was little. Of course! I had opened the doors to the beast, and the evil one had entered with force into my life."

So yes, please place your trust in God alone. If you need guidance pray to the Holy Spirit, spend time with Jesus in Adoration, frequent the Sacraments especially Confession and the Eucharist, seek out a holy spiritual director. You can also ask God to send you signs. Pray, pray, pray, and if all else fails … continue to pray and trust. 🙂

One more thing, please share the truth with your parents. If they refuse to listen, please pray and make sacrifices for them. Appeal to the Blessed Mother: have a couple Miraculous Medals blessed and give them to your parents to wear, pray the rosary for their protection and for their liberation from such practices.

May God Bless you,

Josie
 
That is a bit of over exageration. Vedic religion in India has been around for about 3,500 - 4,000 years (I’m assuming this is Vedic Astrology). Even assuming it was earlier it would likely be perhaps 5,000 years at the earliest.

As for Christianity it has been in India since the Apostolic Age. Saint Thomas is reported to have landed in India around 52 AD. Now Roman Catholicism is much more recent (16th century). The growth of Christianity is much more recent so some of the Vedic cultural traditions have likely “leaked in”.

(My apologies to darkangle123 or others from India if any of this is grossly inaccurate. It is mainly from conversations with a coworker from Kerala after I stuck my foot in my mouth asking why he went by Joseph [it never crossed my mind that might be his actual name :o])
What you say is true. A lot of “Hindu” practices continue to exist among Indian Christians, particularly Catholics. Seeing “auspicious time” for beginning any function is very prevalent. Almost everyone does that. Also, the caste system is strictly adhered to even though it is anti-christian. My grand parents are very superstitious and they see this “auspicious time” to begin anything good. There are a hoard of other things that they follow. My parents are not as deep rooted in this as my grand parents and I am definitely not into any of this. People are slowly changing but this is restricted only to the cities.
 
Seeing “auspicious time” for beginning any function is very prevalent. Almost everyone does that.
I remember the first time an Indian coworker invited me to their wedding and thinking the time looked odd as it was something like 14:08. At first I thought it was to accommodate people like me that are perpetually running late. 😉 It was only later that I learned it was an auspicious time based on the astrologer.
Also, the caste system is strictly adhered to even though it is anti-christian.
I’ve noticed that too. Almost every person I know in the US that is from India will tell me the caste system isn’t really used anymore. This is generally right before they explain what caste they are from. It doesn’t matter if they are Hindu, Sikh, or Christian; they all seem to know the caste that they just told me doesn’t get used anymore. 😃
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top