R
Rime2257
Guest
My brother was just attacked by a demon and we are states away. So does anyone know if a demon can actually take a life or does God demand that he can’t?
NoMy brother was just attacked by a demon and we are states away. So does anyone know if a demon can actually take a life or does God demand that he can’t?
what kind of attack was it?My brother was just attacked by a demon and we are states away. So does anyone know if a demon can actually take a life or does God demand that he can’t?
In what way would the demon take the life?Yes but only if it is permitted by God.
Agreed. Read Job.Yes but only if it is permitted by God.
No demon can take a life???Are people forgeting the story of Job or of Tobit???I’m praying for you and your brother.
I know you’re not Catholic, but perhaps you could contact your diocesian office (the office of your local Catholic Bishop) and ask if they know a priest you could talk to about these matters? He may know of a fellow priest near your brother who could help him.
No demon could take your brother’s life. St Anthony, an early monk, went into the desert, to some tombs near his home to confront the demons. At that time it was believed that the desert and especially the tombs were the Devil’s stronghold. He was attacked by a horde of demons, they beat him and he was found by a friend who rescued him and took him back to the village. Anthony insisted his friend take him back to the tombs. The demons were furious and appeared to him as wild animals. Anthony wasn’t fooled, he told them that if they had any power over him, it would only need one of them to kill him.
God bless
I guess they are. What about the true story Exorcism of Emily Rose though that was not her name? There is precedent in history where this was permitted.No demon can take a life???Are people forgeting the story of Job or of Tobit???
Ditto, I would like to see a counter…perhaps in Summa Theologica or something… It is quite evident in scripture not to fear those that can destroy the body, but those that destroy the soul, be it human or other…I guess they are. What about the true story Exorcism of Emily Rose though that was not her name. There is precedent in history where this was permitted.
I guess most people are uncomfortable with the idea or notion or reality that demons can take human lives if and IF God permits it.
I am glad to see you agreeing with this.
If anywhere in the Magisterial Teachings of the Church says anything different, please by all means cite your sources.
God bless.
The reason St. Anthony’s life was not taken by the demons is becuase God did NOT permit. And St. Anthony was not possessed. Case closed.No demon could take your brother’s life. St Anthony, an early monk, went into the desert, to some tombs near his home to confront the demons. At that time it was believed that the desert and especially the tombs were the Devil’s stronghold. He was attacked by a horde of demons, they beat him and he was found by a friend who rescued him and took him back to the village. Anthony insisted his friend take him back to the tombs. The demons were furious and appeared to him as wild animals. Anthony wasn’t fooled, he told them that if they had any power over him, it would only need one of them to kill him.
God bless
You know I did not think of that Scripture as well for supporting that demons can take life, but yes thanks for sharing this insight.Ditto, I would like to see a counter…perhaps in Summa Theologica or something… It is quite evident in scripture not to fear those that can destroy the body, but those that destroy the soul, be it human or other…
The demon would take their lives in the way that God would permit them. How can I answer this question, since I am not God and have no idea of what He would permit or not permit? I cannot, but this I can fully say with confidence, demons can and do take lives IF AND ONLY IF God permits them to do so.In what way would the demon take the life?
Through dragging a soul and body into sin and death ?
Satan entered Judas’s heart which caused the betrayal and arrest of Christ leading him to crucifixion…
Satan could be in heart of some psychpath with a gun or axe who then shoots us or kills us,
or incites some enemy of ours to poison us.
Yes it is possible. It shows that even though Satan wishes to take and destroy lives, God puts limits on him. However it does go the other way, if God permits Satan to take a life, believe me Satan would not hesitate in taking someone’s life.In the Bible book Job ,God says to Satan afflict his body with sickness,destroy his livestock but dont take his life …
Is it possible Satan couldve taken his life if God allowed it,or seeing that God said that does it suggest that Satan does take life at other times?
Demons can actually compel someone to do something that they do not want to do. It happens in a lot of possessions. Most of the people who are possessed do not want to be doing what they are being compelled to do. Many regret the things that they were compelled to do. They can compel, but they cannot change the Will of the possessed person.I’ve always wondered this too, I know they can’t force you to do anything but you always hear stories of people who are in the occult having odd deaths…can they kill you if you let them?? not saying that your brother is in the occult…I don’t believe a person reasonably close to God can be killed by a demon…they can only attack from the outside with temptation and inside with possession.
Hi,Thank you all for tour helpful answers. To give you more of an idea of what happened … he and my son have been seeing and talking to things in his room. My baby would be completely covered with a blanket that could jot have done done unless someone did it. Things like that have been happening for some time. But this time hy brother was driving and he saw a back figure with red eyes. It started choking him. He somehow made it home and it stopped. He still had claw marked on is neck. This al happened at 3:00 am.
I just couldn’t remember if a demon could physically kill a person or just hurt them. I feel much more comforted by your answers. Thank you.