Can a non-Catholic have an incorrupt body?

  • Thread starter Thread starter distracted
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’ve seen a bunch of incorruptible pictures…they look rather ghastly. Some look way too good to be true…skeptical, uhm yeah big time.

I’ve also read about at least one Saint having a wax mask put over her face!

Anyway, in the right conditions, body decomposition is slowed.

If you want to believe that it’s a miracle…knock yourself out.

Members of other religions have been discovered in uncorrupted states. And at least one case of incorruptibility was discovered in a person who clearly hadn’t exactly lived a saintly life. Cardinal Shuster, an Italian archbishop, had been a fascist and friend of dictator Benito Mussolini. His corpse was found uncorrupted 31 years after his death [source: Fortean Times].

…Bernadette died in 1879 and was exhumed under candidacy of beatification in 1909. Her corpse was uncorrupted. She was reinterred in her crypt and dug up again in 1919 and 1923. Upon the third exhumation, she was dissected. Her organs were still soft and malleable [source: Fortean Times]. She was placed on display in a reliquary, where she remains today, at the convent of St. Gildard at Nevers, France.

Bernadette stands (or lies) as a sterling example of incorruptibility. But her corpse also provides ammunition for skeptics. Her hands and face appear incredibly lifelike, but this is due to a wax covering. Beneath the waxy exterior, her skin has browned. While there’s no scientific explanation for why her body would have remained so well-preserved without the aid of embalming or environmental conditions, she shows that all bodies will eventually rot. Just how long that process takes, however, may depend on any number of factors.
 
I’ve seen a bunch of incorruptible pictures…they look rather ghastly. Some look way too good to be true…skeptical, uhm yeah big time.

I’ve also read about at least one Saint having a wax mask put over her face!

Anyway, in the right conditions, body decomposition is slowed.

If you want to believe that it’s a miracle…knock yourself out.

Members of other religions have been discovered in uncorrupted states. And at least one case of incorruptibility was discovered in a person who clearly hadn’t exactly lived a saintly life. Cardinal Shuster, an Italian archbishop, had been a fascist and friend of dictator Benito Mussolini. His corpse was found uncorrupted 31 years after his death [source: Fortean Times].

…Bernadette died in 1879 and was exhumed under candidacy of beatification in 1909. Her corpse was uncorrupted. She was reinterred in her crypt and dug up again in 1919 and 1923. Upon the third exhumation, she was dissected. Her organs were still soft and malleable [source: Fortean Times]. She was placed on display in a reliquary, where she remains today, at the convent of St. Gildard at Nevers, France.

Bernadette stands (or lies) as a sterling example of incorruptibility. But her corpse also provides ammunition for skeptics. Her hands and face appear incredibly lifelike, but this is due to a wax covering. Beneath the waxy exterior, her skin has browned. While there’s no scientific explanation for why her body would have remained so well-preserved without the aid of embalming or environmental conditions, she shows that all bodies will eventually rot. Just how long that process takes, however, may depend on any number of factors.
What you’re missing is that Bernadette is in Heaven with Jesus, Mary and the Host of the Church Triumphant. This should be the focus of your “investigations,” not “why did God do this or that when he could have done that and this.” As was said in today’s Gospel reading, “he who has ears ought to hear.”
 
I’m saying that I do not believe that God uses his divine power to stop a corpse from rotting.

There are actual problems that could use some divine intervention, let alone using divine intervention to stop the natural decomposition of a corpse.
you don’t sound Catholic… So waht are you??
 
There are more effective means in converting people into believers than preventing a corpse from rotting…I know this, and I am a mere mortal and not an omniscient, omnipotent or benevolent God.
I’m glad you told us that… (sigh) 😃
 
St. John Maximovitch, Russian Orthodox Archbishop of San Francisco, is incorrupt.

His holy relic was removed from a tomb in the basement of the cathedral on Geary to a shrine in the upper church.
how long had he been buried? do you know much about his life??
 
?

I can assure you that no one will ever find out the miraculous ways God has worked in my life- but that doesn’t make it any less astounding.
excellent point… and i could have said the exact same thing… 🙂
 
. Cardinal Shuster, an Italian archbishop, had been a fascist and friend of dictator Benito Mussolini. His corpse was found uncorrupted 31 years after his death [source: Fortean Times].
maybe he repented or maybe he didn’t understand what Mussolini was doing. God in Heaven knows… I’ve never even heard of the guy… Maybe he was just well-embalmed… But in any case, you seem to contradict yourself (?) with the following:
…Bernadette died in 1879 and was exhumed under candidacy of beatification in 1909. Her corpse was uncorrupted. She was reinterred in her crypt and dug up again in 1919 and 1923. Upon the third exhumation, she was dissected. Her organs were still soft and malleable [source: Fortean Times]. She was placed on display in a reliquary, where she remains today, at the convent of St. Gildard at Nevers, France.
and you even add that she was NOT embalmed…

(thanks for reminding me to put it into my will not to be embalmed… I want to allow God to have the glory if he wants to perform such a miracle…🙂 )…
 
I might be wrong it is hard to judge everything on the net, but they sound angry…at the Church and those of us that believe
No kidding… but at least that one poster was putting positive alongside the negative (the thing about St. Bernadette…).
 
What? To amaze us? Keeping a corpse from rotting, just doesn’t make a lot of sense, especially when 99.9% of the time, no one would every found out.

I guarantee…take one of those miraculous :rolleyes: corpses, stick them in a swamp and they will rot like every single other biological organism on the planet.
What an offensive statement.

The Church recognises the reality of incorruptibles and their witness to holinness. If you have a problem with it then check on Church teaching about Sainthood and miracles.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top