Can a Non-Catholic Regularly Attend Mass

  • Thread starter Thread starter leamar3
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

leamar3

Guest
Is it ok for me to go to Mass regularly if I can’t become Catholic because of the use of contraceptives? Trust me, I know why it’s sinful to use them, but I’ve given up the fight with my husband for now. I love going to Mass, so is it ok to worship knowing I’m in a state of mortal sin?
 
Yes, it is fine. In fact, I’d recommend you keep attending Mass… and keep praying for your situation. 👍

You may already be aware of this, but just in case: you should not be receiving the Eucharist (Communion) at this time.

You might also speak with the priest about your options and concerns. I don’t know the details of your situation, but I at least want to point out that you are only responsible for your sins, and your husband is responsible for his.

I will pray for you both. :gopray2:
 
Yes, it is fine. In fact, I’d recommend you keep attending Mass… and keep praying for your situation. 👍

You may already be aware of this, but just in case: you should not be receiving the Eucharist (Communion) at this time.

You might also speak with the priest about your options and concerns. I don’t know the details of your situation, but I at least want to point out that you are only responsible for your sins, and your husband is responsible for his.

I will pray for you both. :gopray2:
I agree. God bless!
 
Even Catholics in mortal sin are still obliged to attend Mass. Non-Catholics are not obliged, but always welcome. However, you clearly understand the gravity of this sin so you should be taking extraordinary steps to avoid it. It is worth pointing out that most moral theologists agree that one contracepting spouse can be tolerated by the innocent one to a certain extent without risk of sin being imputed. So I would recommend you consult with a trusted priest about the actual state of your soul at this point in time. But of course you should also address the root issues with your husband and contraception and attempt to work them out. I do hope that you are able to enter the Catholic Church in the near future, and I will pray for you.
 
Yes and may the grace that you receive from being in our Lords presence, help you deal with your husband.
God bless you
 
Thank you all so much! I appreciate the kind words and the prayers. It really does help me a lot. 🙂
 
Is it ok for me to go to Mass regularly if I can’t become Catholic because of the use of contraceptives? Trust me, I know why it’s sinful to use them, but I’ve given up the fight with my husband for now. I love going to Mass, so is it ok to worship knowing I’m in a state of mortal sin?
I was a Methodist and I attended Mass every Sunday for 10 years with my Catholic wife before converting. Of course I could not receive Communion but I participated as best I could in the rest of the Mass.

By the way, if by using contraceptives you mean your husband uses condoms and insists on using them though you disagree because you know its a sin I don’t think you are culpable in a such a situation. Only your husband would be. I’m not sure that in itself would be a bar to conversion.
 
My wife attended mass regularly several years before converting - it’s amazing what one hour a week spent with Jesus can do! A question - does your husband attend as well?
 
Thanks for the responses!

He no longer attends church. He was a Methodist since birth, but he stopped going about 5 years ago.
 
By the way, if by using contraceptives you mean your husband uses condoms and insists on using them though you disagree because you know its a sin I don’t think you are culpable in a such a situation. Only your husband would be. I’m not sure that in itself would be a bar to conversion.
**1735 Imputability and responsibility for an action can be diminished or even nullified by ignorance, inadvertence, duress, fear, habit, inordinate attachments, and other psychological or social factors. **

If your husband is truly forcing you to use contraceptives, you probably fall under 1735 and have an exemption from mortal sin, owing to duress or social factors, whichever you want to call it – you don’t have freedom in the matter.

If you discussed your problem with a priest, I wouldn’t bet a dime that he’d refer to 1735, to even inquire about your problem. I think you have to interpret 1735 yourself, honestly, and leave the rest to the mercy of God (which is what 1735 is all about).

Now, this is not just me talking. Listen to Pope St. John Paul II in section 18 of his encyclical THE GOSPEL OF LIFE (Evangelium Vitae):

[Now, this encyclical is about abortion, euthanasia, and the death penalty, but he includes contraception into the discussion, in the preceding section. ] ***Decisions that go against life sometimes arise from difficult or even tragic situations of profound suffering, loneliness, a total lack of economic prospects, depression and anxiety about the future. Such circumstances can mitigate even to a notable degree subjective responsibility and the consequent culpability fo those who make these choices which in themselves are evil.

So, the use of contraception is objectively evil, but under your circumstances of duress (pressure from your husband) you should not consider yourself ineligible for the sacraments. Here, in this post, is the Catechism of the Catholic Church and a sainted Pope telling you about the mercy of God. You should not neglect it, but even use the grace of the sacraments to pray for your husband and your situation.

I think you should not only attend Mass, but become a Catholic and receive the sacraments. Jesus said we must not be ashamed to confess our faith in him. A lot of Catholics around these forums will argue with what I said. But, they cannot show me or you another encyclical from a pope or a paragraph of the catechism which overturns when I quoted above – you will find that they don’t like what the catechism says (yawn).
 
Worshiping yes, but please refrain from receiving the Eucharist in a state of mortal sin. I hear your position, and I really do feel for you. Have you or your husband looked into Natural Family Planning? It might be a good compromise. Either way, you are certainly still a catholic. Catholics sin all the time. God loves and wants you.
 
Worshiping yes, but please refrain from receiving the Eucharist in a state of mortal sin. I hear your position, and I really do feel for you. Have you or your husband looked into Natural Family Planning? It might be a good compromise. Either way, you are certainly still a catholic. Catholics sin all the time. God loves and wants you.
With all kindness and respect to CrusaderVassal, this is the type of negative attitude that I described in my previous post.

NOBODY can deny what the Catechism says (and be in full union with the Catholic Church), and which the sainted pope applies specifically to the use of contraceptives. Objectively evil: yes. If you have less than perfect freedom about using them owing to your husband’s pressure, you are not culpable for that contraceptive use, as a mortal sin.

As it says in the Catechism itself, this teaching is part of the deposit of faith – we are bound to it. I’m sure people object to it, because it sounds like a free ticket to sin, which it is not. This teaching in the catechism is biblically based and you should rely on God’s mercy, as well as on his judgment.

This teaching applies to all people of faith and to all serious sin. It is stated in the Catechism without qualification.
 
NOBODY can deny what the Catechism says (and be in full union with the Catholic Church), and which the sainted pope applies specifically to the use of contraceptives. Objectively evil: yes. If you have less than perfect freedom about using them owing to your husband’s pressure, you are not culpable for that contraceptive use, as a mortal sin…

…This teaching applies to all people of faith and to all serious sin. It is stated in the Catechism without qualification.
You’re right that it’s not definite that she is guilty of committing a personal mortal sin here. But it’s also not definite that she’s not (or wouldn’t be, if she became Catholic and continued to use contraception). I don’t think that’s for us to determine at all.

We have to be careful to read 1735 correctly. It only says that our personal responsibility for an action may be diminished or nullified under certain circumstances. (And keep in mind that it says, “can be,” not, “is,” or “always is.”) It does not say that it’s automatically not sinful to use contraception if your spouse wants you to or is pressuring you to do so.

Now, I’m not saying that 1735 wouldn’t apply to her situation, but we can’t just assume it would remove all of her responsibility for sin, either. For one thing, she has not said that her husband is forcing her, she simply said she’s “given up the fight” for now. There’s a lot of room for interpretation about what that really means.

Oh, and just to clarify for the OP et al, my advice not to receive the Eucharist had less to do with the OP’s question, and more to do with the need to become Catholic and to get some guidance from a priest before receiving. It was not intended as an opinion on whether or not she is personally sinning. 😉
 
Is it ok for me to go to Mass regularly if I can’t become Catholic because of the use of contraceptives? Trust me, I know why it’s sinful to use them, but I’ve given up the fight with my husband for now. I love going to Mass, so is it ok to worship knowing I’m in a state of mortal sin?
Yes, go to Mass. You will find comfort and graces there.

👍
 
Is it ok for me to go to Mass regularly if I can’t become Catholic because of the use of contraceptives? Trust me, I know why it’s sinful to use them, but I’ve given up the fight with my husband for now. I love going to Mass, so is it ok to worship knowing I’m in a state of mortal sin?
Code:
Making spiritual communion will be a great comfort - it's evident that you aren't attached to the practice which is in some way being imposed wrongly by a spouse who is not acting as a husband is commanded to, to love his wife as Christ loves the Church. 
The mercies of God are great and come when we least hope for them.
 
A friend of mine has a Catholic father and Protestant mother and she attends mass every week but can’t receive communion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top