Can a nun give Last Rites?

  • Thread starter Thread starter psteichen
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

psteichen

Guest
I visited a good friend in a nursing home recently and it was clear that the hours were few. I asked the head nurse if the priest had administered the Last Rites. She wasn’t sure, but she noted that either the priest or a nun they had on staff would be available to do so 24 hrs a day if the need arose. I left it at that, but I was quite surprised that they would allow a nun to administer the Last Rites. This is a Catholic facility, and the nurse seemed to understand what I was asking. Can a nun do this?
 
I visited a good friend in a nursing home recently and it was clear that the hours were few. I asked the head nurse if the priest had administered the Last Rites. She wasn’t sure, but she noted that either the priest or a nun they had on staff would be available to do so 24 hrs a day if the need arose. I left it at that, but I was quite surprised that they would allow a nun to administer the Last Rites. This is a Catholic facility, and the nurse seemed to understand what I was asking. Can a nun do this?
Nope. Maybe the nurse’s idea of Last Rites was not what you had in mind. If there is still time, try and arrange for a priest yourself and keep your friend in your prayers.
 
I visited a good friend in a nursing home recently and it was clear that the hours were few. I asked the head nurse if the priest had administered the Last Rites. She wasn’t sure, but she noted that either the priest or a nun they had on staff would be available to do so 24 hrs a day if the need arose. I left it at that, but I was quite surprised that they would allow a nun to administer the Last Rites. This is a Catholic facility, and the nurse seemed to understand what I was asking. Can a nun do this?
I believe the head nurse is either not properly informed of who can administer Last Rites, or she was not clear in stating what duties that a nun on duty would have (perhaps to call a priest). In answer to your question, a nun cannot administer Last Rites.
 
In terms of sacraments, there is nothing a nun can do that an ordinary layman can not.
 
I visited a good friend in a nursing home recently and it was clear that the hours were few. I asked the head nurse if the priest had administered the Last Rites. She wasn’t sure, but she noted that either the priest or a nun they had on staff would be available to do so 24 hrs a day if the need arose. I left it at that, but I was quite surprised that they would allow a nun to administer the Last Rites. This is a Catholic facility, and the nurse seemed to understand what I was asking. Can a nun do this?
Since you say that this is a Catholic facility, as a priest I presume that the head nurse is trying to answer your question as best she can, since the terminology you are using is antiquated and no longer suited to how we minister.

I do not ever give “last rites”. I act according to the provisions of either the “pastoral care of the sick” or the “pastoral care of the dying.”
  • When I first see a patient, I make a pastoral assessment of the patient’s situation and need and prognosis.
  • If they’re not Catholic, I do what I am able, either to assist them myself or to arrange pastoral care for them from their own Church/ecclesial community, if it can be had. I minister under the constraints I operate under…and at times, because of the unique situation, Can 844 becomes very important, actually. Our bishop is very good…Deo gratias.
  • If they’re Catholic, I begin by asking if they practice the faith. If they’re not, I visit with them about that, if they wish, to work through that. These conversations are critical if the prognosis is terminal.
  • If they’re practicing the faith, we begin talking about the sacraments…the need for absolution (auricular confession may or may not be possible if one is on a ventilator, they are in a non private room, on a ward, or even a carved out space in the casualty department (emergency room)).
  • I also would anoint them as soon as the criteria for doing so is met.
  • And finally also provide them regularly with Holy Communion (if they can receive anything, even a fraction of the Host, by mouth).
  • All of this, of course, is done in conjunction with the non-ordained pastoral care team of seminarians, religious, & lay volunteers who help the priest (in so far as they can) carry the burden of caring for the sick, praying with the patients, their families, etc. There are days, for example, when they have to take all the Communion calls & family visits because I am too pressed by things only I, as a priest, can do.
I have had it happen where it was necessary to baptise, confirm, anoint and give viaticum in quite short order! That is more unusual.

Thankfully, most patients recover & we try to liaise to their proper priest to make sure their pastoral care is transferred to their own parish.

Sometimes, the patient continues to decline toward death and we follow that progression…but note that we have been providing pastoral care and the sacraments throughout this continuum…not waiting for the approach of death.
  • Sister, obviously, would not absolve the patient or anoint the patient; she can certainly baptise in my place a dying person, if necessary. If it’s a baby, there is nothing more to do for the child sacramentally, although I will proceed to confirm the child, if the death is all but certain to occur and, of course, whoever is available from the pastoral care team comes to regularly pray over the baby and with the family.
  • For those older, Sister or someone else can give Holy Communion, even as Viaticum, as an extraordinary minister.
  • If she is a chaplain or pastoral care associate, she also can be the one to do visits to the sick and provide pastoral care and support to them and their families.
  • Depending on shifts, it can fall to her ultimately, on her duty watch, to say the prayers for the dying and the commendation of the soul, and to pray with the family after death…since all of this does not involve either absolution or anointing. That would all have been done before death is proximate and typically those sacraments would not be repeated; there is no need.
Since this person was the recipient of regular pastoral care, God forbid that absolution or anointing was delayed till the person’s final few hours since those sacraments, thanks to the liturgical reform, are explicitly to be celebrated when full, conscious and active participation is possible by the person whose pilgrimage is coming to an end and their gathered family and loved ones with them.

Today, pastoral care of the sick is done using more of a team approach than in the decades when we spoke of “last rites” or the priest arrived just before death and just ahead of the undertaker, as one of my older confreres still describes those days.

The sacramental needs, requiring a priestly intervention, can often be provided in a way that provides them to the patient while cognizant the priest likely has other duties…especially in a hospice setting or nursing home setting where the decline can be foreseen and there are fewer sudden onset crises such as the healthy person felled by a fatal heart attack rushed to the emergency an who needs an unforeseen emergency pastoral care intervention with a window of minutes to a few hours.

Those charged with animating the pastoral care of the hospital or nursing home, in turn, will supply for all that they can in the absence of the priest. It is no longer possible in many places to have a priest attending the dying but the sacramental needs can be addressed through careful planning and provision and the accompaniment in the last journey can be done by someone who is not a priest.

I would understand that the nurse, therefore, was telling you that when the end came, at whatever hour, the on-call chaplain would come to accompany the dying person with watch and prayer to her journey’s end. This is how we minister today.
 
[Last Rites] can refer to the Sacrament of the Anointing of the Sick, or that Sacrament together with the Sacrament of Penance
… neither of which a lay person can administer. 🤷
and reception of Holy Communion:
And, of course, a layperson is able to be deputed to be an EMHC and take communion to the sick; so, perhaps that’s a role that was being described to the OP?

I’ve also heard of folks who conflate ‘last rites’ with ‘praying with a dying person.’ So, being charitable, that’s what I would think that the nurse with whom the OP talked was trying to say…
 
Since you say that this is a Catholic facility, as a priest I presume that the head nurse is trying to answer your question as best she can, since the terminology you are using is antiquated and no longer suited to how we minister.

I do not ever give “last rites”. I act according to the provisions of either the “pastoral care of the sick” or the “pastoral care of the dying.”



I would understand that the nurse, therefore, was telling you that when the end came, at whatever hour, the on-call chaplain would come to accompany the dying person with watch and prayer to her journey’s end. This is how we minister today.
Father:

Thank you for explaining. My friend was already beyond most conciousness, so I presume that the time for action requiring a priest had already passed. I didn’t realize that it was such an involved process, but I’m glad to hear that the anointing and sacraments were likely completed at an earlier stage. I’m certain they must have done everything they could. Thank you for clearing up my confusion!
 
Even if someone in unconscious, a priest should be called. Extreme Unction can be administered and thus sins forgiven conditionally if someone is unconscious.
 
Even if someone in unconscious, a priest should be called. Extreme Unction can be administered and thus sins forgiven conditionally if someone is unconscious.
Is that distinct from Anointing? I assume in th he case mentioned that sins were forgiven by Reconciliation at an earlier date, but perhaps what you are referring to can be used in cases where it is uncertain?
 
Is that distinct from Anointing? I assume in th he case mentioned that sins were forgiven by Reconciliation at an earlier date, but perhaps what you are referring to can be used in cases where it is uncertain?
Extreme unction is anointing of the sick in extremis, in the danger of death. The reason why only a priest can administer Extreme Unction, or as it is more commonly referred to these days as anointing of the sick, is because when one is not able to confess his/her sins, it restores one to the state of grace. Only a priest has the ability to return someone to the state of grace, no lay person, including religious, no deacon, no subdeacon, etc, only a priest.
 
Is that distinct from Anointing? I assume in th he case mentioned that sins were forgiven by Reconciliation at an earlier date, but perhaps what you are referring to can be used in cases where it is uncertain?
From paragraph 73 of Sacrosanctum Concilium, the Dogmatic Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy:

“Extreme unction,” which may also and more fittingly be called “anointing of the sick,” is not a sacrament for those only who are at the point of death. Hence, as soon as any one of the faithful begins to be in danger of death from sickness or old age, the fitting time for him to receive this sacrament has certainly already arrived.
 
I visited a good friend in a nursing home recently and it was clear that the hours were few. I asked the head nurse if the priest had administered the Last Rites. She wasn’t sure, but she noted that either the priest or a nun they had on staff would be available to do so 24 hrs a day if the need arose. I left it at that, but I was quite surprised that they would allow a nun to administer the Last Rites. This is a Catholic facility, and the nurse seemed to understand what I was asking. Can a nun do this?
Absolutely not only an ordained presbyter or Bishop can give last rites
 
Extreme unction is anointing of the sick in extremis, in the danger of death. The reason why only a priest can administer Extreme Unction, or as it is more commonly referred to these days as anointing of the sick, is because when one is not able to confess his/her sins, it restores one to the state of grace. Only a priest has the ability to return someone to the state of grace, no lay person, including religious, no deacon, no subdeacon, etc, only a priest.
When my husband had a stroke he was medically paralyzed, sedated, and intubated and placed on a ventilator in the ER, and the hospital chaplain, a Byzantine priest, anointed him. He had been paralyzed on the entire right side of his body by the stroke and was losing consciousness quickly when they did this, and they took him to radiology and performed a procedure where they went into the occluded blood vessel in his brain and busted up and extracted the clot that had formed which caused the stroke.

The Radiologist who did this procedure said he did not think there would be much recovery as the left side of his brain had been without oxygen for so long, but he recovered 100% fully with no residual deficits within 24 hours, spent a week in physical therapy and was discharged. The doctors were astounded, but I knew that this recovery was connected to the anointing. The radiologist said it was the first time he had ever seen anyone fully recover after the procedure. Medicine did their part, and God, through the sacrament, did His. That was 5 years ago and he is perfectly fine.
 
When my husband had a stroke he was medically paralyzed, sedated, and intubated and placed on a ventilator in the ER, and the hospital chaplain, a Byzantine priest, anointed him. He had been paralyzed on the entire right side of his body by the stroke and was losing consciousness quickly when they did this, and they took him to radiology and performed a procedure where they went into the occluded blood vessel in his brain and busted up and extracted the clot that had formed which caused the stroke.

The Radiologist who did this procedure said he did not think there would be much recovery as the left side of his brain had been without oxygen for so long, but he recovered 100% fully with no residual deficits within 24 hours, spent a week in physical therapy and was discharged. The doctors were astounded, but I knew that this recovery was connected to the anointing. The radiologist said it was the first time he had ever seen anyone fully recover after the procedure. Medicine did their part, and God, through the sacrament, did His. That was 5 years ago and he is perfectly fine.
God bless you! And God bless your husband. I venture to say most priests have a fair number of amazing moments of divine intervention in their ministry to the sick in situations just like what you describe. It is, truly, a marvel to behold.
 
Is that distinct from Anointing? I assume in th he case mentioned that sins were forgiven by Reconciliation at an earlier date, but perhaps what you are referring to can be used in cases where it is uncertain?
There is a reason why this can be confusing:

In Latin, there is only one word “unctio” (I’ll not list every variation).

In English, there are 2 words, “unction” and/or “anointing” which mean exactly the same thing.

In the 1970’s there emerged a trend in the English language to say “we don’t have unction anymore, instead we have anointing.” They wanted to imply that an entirely new sacrament had been invented, and using a new word furthered that agenda. Which is utter nonsense because the 2 words mean exactly the same thing. Nevertheless, it worked and the message stuck.

The Latin word for the sacrament never changed—it still is, and always has been, “unctio.”

What did change are the adjectives that might (I say might) be added to that word. Words like “extreme” to describe an extreme situation (at death’s door).

The point is that we may use the nouns “unction” and “anointing” in English interchangeably. It makes no difference whatsoever.

What does matter is the adjectives that we add to those nouns. So, it’s only “extreme unction” if the situation is extreme. If it’s not extreme (and we should not wait that long), then we don’t use that adjective. We could just as easily call it “extreme anointing” so long as that aptly describes the situation.

There’s a common misconception that the terms “last Rites” and “extreme unction” mean the same thing. They don’t at the present time, and they never did.
 
I would also add to what my brother priests have already said, and that is that it’s far better to call the priest earlier rather than later. Perhaps I’m unique in my experience of this, but I’ve often been called to a hospital (or more commonly now to a nursing home) when the patient is unable to receive any food. This is common in the very end stages of life.

This wasn’t much of a problem a generation ago when life expectancy was less. But, with the advance of modern medicine, people live longer, and the dying process may be more prolonged. About six weeks ago, I had the privilege of ministering viaticum to my dying grandfather. I visited him five days before he passed away. He was still able to receive the Eucharist at that time. Had I waited another day or so, he would have been unable to receive.

Now, certainly, God can work apart from the sacraments, but all things being equal, I’m very grateful that my grandfather was able to receive our Lord for the final time, even if it was five days before he went to his final judgment.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top