Can a priest say no to hearing your confession?

  • Thread starter Thread starter schulze43
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Since venial sins can be remitted outside of the Confessional, the performance of pious acts can remit them.

The use of a prayer and holy water is one of the devout ways this is done.

For example the Asperges me:

Thou shalt sprinkle me, O Lord, with hyssop and I shall be cleansed; Thou shalt wash me, and I shall become whiter than show. Have mercy on me, O God, according to Thy great mercy.

Asperges me, Domine, hyssopo, et mundabor: lavabis me, et super nivem dealbador. Miserere mei, Deus, secundum magnam misericordiam tuam.

Or:

Lord, by this holy water and by Thy Most Precious Blood, I beg of you to wash me clean from sin and succor the holy souls in purgatory. Amen.

And so on. 🙂

It works for the small stuff. Anything grave should go to the box. I take my small stuff to the box too, as much as I can, as in the end it’s all something that’s bigger than we think and that has to be put an end to as swiftly as possible.
It’s a little misleading to say that the performance of pious acts remits venial sin. That makes it sound as though these acts have a power in themselves to remit sin which isn’t the case. They only do so when we do them in a spirit of sorrow for sin and love for God. It is God who forgives us.

The pious acts also include the corporal and spiritual works of mercy. And the best one of all is praying the mass and receiving communion.🙂
 
It’s a little misleading to say that the performance of pious acts remits venial sin. That makes it sound as though these acts have a power in themselves to remit sin which isn’t the case. They only do so when we do them in a spirit of sorrow for sin and love for God. It is God who forgives us.

The pious acts also include the corporal and spiritual works of mercy. And the best one of all is praying the mass and receiving communion.🙂
I think people would understand… Because it’s like saying well the priest by performing the act of the sign of the cross while saying the words doesn’t forgive you but God forgives you…

Of course only God can forgive you… but the priest [insert apologetics here] etc.
 
Yes, it is God who forgive us! The use of the sacramentals are aides to grace, that gain us forgiveness because we use them with devotion and they inspire it in us. 🙂

St. Charles Borromeo went to Confession more than once a day, regularly. This can be quite helpful at times, yet is for people who are not scrupulous. 🙂

Perhaps this will help too.

If we commit faults, says St. Augustine, let us at least confess and detest them, and God will pardon them. If we confess our sins, He is faithful and just to forgive us our sins. To obtain the remission of venial faults, Louis de Blois says that it is enough to confess them in general. And in another place he writes that such sins are more easily cancelled by turning to God with humility and love than by stopping to dwell upon them with too much fear. St. Francis de Sales also has written that as the daily faults of spiritual souls are indeliberately committed, so they are indeliberately taken away. He meant to say what St. Thomas teaches, that for the remission of venial sins " it is sufficient to detest them either explicitly or even implicitly, for example, by a fervent act of the love of God." The holy Doctor then says: “The remission of venial sins is brought about in three ways: 1. By infusion of divine grace; in this way by means of the Holy Eucharist and the other sacraments such sins are remitted; 2. By acts that include a movement of detestation, and thus by a general confession of sins, by striking the breast, by reciting an Our Father , we obtain the remission of such sins; 3. By every act of religion towards God and the things of God, such as the receiving of the blessing from a bishop, to take holy water, to pray in a consecrated church.” Speaking of the holy Communion, St. Bernardine of Sienna says: “It may happen that after Communion the soul finds itself so absorbed in God that all venial sins disappear before the fervor of its devotion.”

The Venerable Louis da Ponte used to say: “I have committed many faults, but I have never made peace with my faults. Many make peace with their defects, and this shall cause their ruin.” St. Bernard says that as long as a person detests his imperfections, there is reason to hope that he shall return to the straight path; but when he commits faults knowingly and deliberately, and when the commission of them excites neither fear nor remorse, they shall by degrees bring him to ruin. Dying flies, says the Holy Ghost, spoil the sweetness of the ointment. Dying flies are the faults that are committed but not detested; for they remain dead in the soul. “When a fly,” says Denis the Carthusian, “falls into a sweet-smelling ointment and remains therein, it will injure the ointment and its good odor. If we apply this to the spiritual life, the dead flies represent our idle thoughts, illicit affections, voluntary distractions things that spoil the sweetness of the ointment, that is, the sweetness attached to the exercises of piety.”

St. Bernard writes, that to say this is a light sin is not a great evil, but to commit it, and take complacency in it, is an evil of great moment, and shall, according to the words of St. Luke, be severely chastised by God. And that servant that knew the will of his Lord, and did not according to His will, shall be beaten with many stripes; but he that knew not, and did things worthy of stripes, shall be beaten with few stripes." It is true that even spiritual persons are not free from light transgressions; “but,” says Father Alvarez, " they daily diminish the number and grievousness of their faults, and afterwards efface them by acts of divine love." Whoever acts in this manner shall acquire sanctity: neither shall his defects hinder him from tending to perfection. Hence Louis de Blois tells us not to be disheartened by these little faults, be cause we have several means of expiating them: “If every day we fall several times, it will depend entirely on us to employ every day the means of atoning for our faults.” But how can he that entertains an attachment for any earthly good, and voluntarily falls and relapses into that attachment without any wish to get rid of it, advance in the way of God? The bird that escapes from the net instantly takes flight; but as long as it is held even by a slender thread, it remains on the earth. " Every little thread of attachment to this world," says St. John of the Cross, “impedes the spiritual progress of the soul.”

St. Alphonsus Maria de Ligouri

So, we must aim to never voluntarily commit venial sins, and then we are truly on the right path.🙂
 
SCHULZE43 wrote:
“I felt like I should have confessed my sin and felt really restless about not having confessed it even though it was just a venial sin”.
Code:
Dear Schulze:
Venial sins are forgiven during our participation of the Penitential Act in Holy Mass.

Mortal sins are a different story.
We MUST CONFESS our mortal sins through the Sacrament of Reconciliation.

Pax et bonum
--macaronte
 
Yesterday I went for my weekly confession and confessed all my sins but at the last second as I was saying those are all my sins I thought of another one but just dismissed it and said those were all my sins, afterwards I felt like I should have confessed my sin and felt really restless about not having confessed it even though it was just a venial sin.

Today I went to mass and after ward there was a really short confession line so I figured I could just go to confession and say that I had knowing left out a sin yesterday. I had also intended to ask for advice because I feel as though I am in a hard struggle to “stay afloat”… but when I said that it had been a day since my last confession the priest told me to leave and come back next week because I had already been forgiven. But I had always thought that if I knew that I had left out a sin that I had to go back to confession as soon as I could.

I know I might have been being a bit scrupulous but I didn’t think a priest could refuse to hear your confession??

I would apreciate any (name removed by moderator)ut anyone has:)

God bless:)
When You go to confession, and the Priest gives You absolution, all your sins are forgiven, even the ones you may have forgotten to confess:)
 
This is the reason why I end my confessions by saying something to the effect of “For these sins and those I don’t remember, I am truly contrite and sorry.” Now, if I do remember a forgotten and unconfessed mortal sin after I am done with that particular confession, I make a note of it, and mention it the next week (I usually go once a week). When I mention it in the next confession, I’ll say something to the effect of “The last time I confessed, I forgot to confess that I committed such and such sin,” especially if I had sinned in that same manner again, so the priest won’t think that I’m becoming scrupulous.

As far as a priest ever telling me “no” to hearing my confession… that’s not happened. What HAS happened is I’ve been told that the priest wasn’t able to AT THAT MOMENT, but was told either to come back when he was available or to call the office to set up an appointment.

Also, about confessing venial sins, I do mention a few venial sins, the ones that I’m having the most trouble with, for two reasons. First, the graces received in confession can help me better overcome those particular faults and sins, and secondly, the priest may have some very practical advise or assign a specific penance that may help me overcome that penance. The latter doesn’t happen every confession, but the times it has, I seem to do better when I follow that advise.
 
“For these sins and those I don’t remember, I am truly contrite and sorry.”
I end my confessions in the same fashion. 🙂 😃

I also sometimes say something about constant and general ingratitude and inattention.
 
I have had a Priest tell me that even forgotten mortal sin, as long as they were forgotten (as opposed to willfully concealed), should not be confessed at a later Confession. Then again, I am Scrupulous.
 
Remember you should go to confession at least once a year, during Lent. So even if you have commited no mortal sins in a year only venial sins, you are still required to go to confession that once during the year, even though venial sins can be forgiven outside the confessional.
 
The title begs the question:

If one goes to confession, having committed mortal sin, and is refused the sacrament for no good reason (let’s say there’s plenty of time, a short line, etc, etc.), then is one not able to receive the Eucharist?

This perhaps is a different subject matter, but I think the case could be made that if one had the disposition to go to confession and through no fault of their own were turned away, that the Almighty might just consider that an act of perfect contrition. :confused:
 
Yesterday I went for my weekly confession and confessed all my sins but at the last second as I was saying those are all my sins I thought of another one but just dismissed it and said those were all my sins, afterwards I felt like I should have confessed my sin and felt really restless about not having confessed it even though it was just a venial sin.

Today I went to mass and after ward there was a really short confession line so I figured I could just go to confession and say that I had knowing left out a sin yesterday. I had also intended to ask for advice because I feel as though I am in a hard struggle to “stay afloat”… but when I said that it had been a day since my last confession the priest told me to leave and come back next week because I had already been forgiven. But I had always thought that if I knew that I had left out a sin that I had to go back to confession as soon as I could.

I know I might have been being a bit scrupulous but I didn’t think a priest could refuse to hear your confession??

I would apreciate any (name removed by moderator)ut anyone has:)

God bless:)
If you INTENTIONALLY leave out a MORTAL sin you must return to Confession. You said that it was neither intentionally left out or a Mrotal sin, in addition you went to Mass which would also have forgiven a venial sin.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top