Can a priest tell a lie?

  • Thread starter Thread starter anon64704623
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

anon64704623

Guest
Can a priest tell a lie to save the innocent victim from an evil lawyer who twisted the facts to win in a court case?
 
was this the plot in a movie?
No. As you know, there are many rich people out there who can hire lawyers to win for them to cover up their crimes. I have studied a little law before and I know how to twist the law to protect my customer.
 
No. Evil does not justify a good result. And lying is evil.
 
Last edited:
Where do you get all of these scenarios? If the victim is innocent why would there be a need to lie?
 
Last edited:
But if the priest did not lie then he allows evil to win. There is no justice.
Maybe not in this life, but there will be in the next, and that is the justice that ultimately matters. But the ends do not justify the means in Catholicism.
 
40.png
Fauken:
No. Evil does not justify a good result. And lying is evil.
But if the priest did not lie then he allows evil to win. There is no justice.
If the priest lies than he has committed evil, and evil wins even if the lawyer loses the case.
Yes, but the bad guys are happy they win.
The priest is not responsible for the happiness of the bad guys. The priest must not do evil.
 
Last edited:
Can a priest tell a lie to save the innocent victim from an evil lawyer who twisted the facts to win in a court case?
The Church clearly teaches the end does not justify the means. You may not do an evil act even if the intent is to achieve a good.
 
A priest is also human therefore he can also sin like all of us we are all sinners even the saints when they were alive they still sinned but asked God for forgiveness and mercy
 
I’m sure that priests lied to the gestapo to save the Jews they could. In college, I had a professor propose that exact framework for the morality of a lie. Over 20 years later, I’m still pondering it! Of course we’d all lie in those circumstances, but the scenario of a court case brings too many permutations to the table. I’ll never be a priest but I always pray that I won’t be put to the test.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top