Can a Protestant enter the Catholic Church without RCIA?

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

PRmerger

Guest
Just wondering if RCIA is always a requirement before an adult enters the Church…

Specifically, if an Episcopalian who’s been an active member of the Catholic parish he and his wife belong to wants to make it “official”, is there another way besides joining RCIA?
 
The pastor is responsible for the formation and preparation of those entering the Church. Some pastors handle individual cases differently, depending on individual circumstances and the amount of preparation a person needs. (For example, a woman wanted to enter the Church before her husband was deployed to Iraq; the pastor arranged for individual instruction for her, which was easily accomplished because she had been attending Mass for years.)

If you (or someone you know) want to enter the Church but have a problem with the RCIA process, talk to the pastor about it.
 
Just wondering if RCIA is always a requirement before an adult enters the Church…

Specifically, if an Episcopalian who’s been an active member of the Catholic parish he and his wife belong to wants to make it “official”, is there another way besides joining RCIA?
i was coming from the episcopal/anglican communion. i contacted a local catholic church and spoke with a priest there. they allowed me to meet one on one with the woman who leads the RCIA. i was given topics to read each week and then we would meet and discuss them. we met for about 6-8 weeks and then i was confirmed in the summer.
i have to admit though, that watching the people come into the church at Easter, almost made me wish i could have entered the church with the other candidates.

so i would think if you spoke with a priest and they know you are coming from the episcopal church and you have already been an active member of the Catholic parish, they will find a way to get you in rather quickly. you definitely need some instruction, however, and some background because there is a bigger difference between the epsicopal church and the roman catholic than i had thought.
 
The short answer is no - RCIA is not always required.

However, with the lack of priests (at least in our area) it is difficult to find one who would do one-on-one formation sessions, so pretty much everyone (that I know of) comes in via RCIA.

In the case you describe, I don’t think there would have to be an extensive faith formation process though.
 
i didn’t have one on one formation with a priest. i had one on one formation with the person who teaches RCIA.

you probably get more going through with the group of candidates, but i had a special situation, so they were able to hurry me through. i did a lot of reading in those 6-8 weeks and had been in the process of conversion for close to 10 years.

i don’t know how long the OP has been an active member of the Catholic parish, but i would have them contact someone in the RCIA at the church they are attending.
 
Yes, a non-Catholic can become a Catholic without going through the RCIA process.
 
i was coming from the episcopal/anglican communion. i contacted a local catholic church and spoke with a priest there. they allowed me to meet one on one with the woman who leads the RCIA. i was given topics to read each week and then we would meet and discuss them. we met for about 6-8 weeks and then i was confirmed in the summer.
i have to admit though, that watching the people come into the church at Easter, almost made me wish i could have entered the church with the other candidates.
But candidates are supposed to be received into full Communion as soon as they are ready – they shouldn’t have to wait for the Vigil which, ideally, should only be for those being baptized. I know that most parishes initiate both candidates and catechumens at the Vigil but it’s not what the North American Forum for the Catechumenate preaches as I learned when I did the “Beginnings and Beyond” sessions some years ago.
 
But candidates are supposed to be received into full Communion as soon as they are ready – they shouldn’t have to wait for the Vigil which, ideally, should only be for those being baptized. I know that most parishes initiate both candidates and catechumens at the Vigil but it’s not what the North American Forum for the Catechumenate preaches as I learned when I did the “Beginnings and Beyond” sessions some years ago.
at the Easter vigil, they, of course, had baptisms, and they had adults who were baptized and confirmed and then those that were just confirmed.

i don’t know what the rules are, but i was brought into full communion when they felt i was ready.
 
i don’t know what the rules are, but i was brought into full communion when they felt i was ready.
And for a candidate that’s exactly as it should be. Catechumens, OTOH, should be baptized at the Vigil.
 
And for a candidate that’s exactly as it should be. Catechumens, OTOH, should be baptized at the Vigil.
what is the difference between a RCIA candidate and a Catechumen? aren’t they the same?
 
what is the difference between a RCIA candidate and a Catechumen? aren’t they the same?
Candidates are those who are already validly baptized. Catechumens are those who are not yet baptized. They’re in very different situations though they are often lumped together for both instruction and the reception of the sacraments.
 
what is the difference between a RCIA candidate and a Catechumen? aren’t they the same?
No, they are not the same. A catechumen has not previously been baptized. A candidate has. A catechumen recieves all 3 sacraments of initiation (including baptism). The candidate is confirmed and receives first Holy Communion when they enter into full communion with the Catholic Church.
 
Just wondering if RCIA is always a requirement before an adult enters the Church…

Specifically, if an Episcopalian who’s been an active member of the Catholic parish he and his wife belong to wants to make it “official”, is there another way besides joining RCIA?
The answer is technically “yes”, but practically I doubt it usually happens. In most large parishes it seems the task of evaluation is given to the RCIA director rather than the priest. These people are often very busy or to busy to bother truly evaluating the candidate. The typical route is to just throw you in with the rest of the RCIA group. A cursory read through this board will show that this is the case.

I was a Baptised Christian and had attended Christian school K5-8th grade (I home schooled for high school), went to church (Methodist) since I can remember, and then started going to Catholic Mass for 6 years, we were members of the parish for 5 years, my wife is Catholic, and I have read copious amounts of literature about Catholicism…and I still had to go through most of the RCIA program (6 months) because the RCIA director did not really evaluate me. We met once where she explained that the Catholic Church was a church of “smells and bells”:rolleyes: (I guess she forgot I had been going to Mass for 6 years) and did not listen to what I had to say at all. Nice person, but not interested in truly evaluating Candidates.

Our priest is much to busy with other matters to handle the RCIA, so he has given it to a person he trusts to do it well. I am sure that is the case in most parishes in the US. The only real answer is to talk to your priest and see what he has to say.

But no matter what they make you do…DO IT! Being able to fully participate in the Eucharist is amazing and I wish that I had done it way sooner!👍

Steve
 
Candidates are those who are already validly baptized. Catechumens are those who are not yet baptized. They’re in very different situations though they are often lumped together for both instruction and the reception of the sacraments.
thanks to those who answered and clarified the difference between an RCIA candidate and a Catechumen.
 
I’m proof that it happens!

I’m actually an RCIA class dropout, but there was discussion about my entering the church after only a couple of classes. I guess I sort-of "CLEP"ed out of the remaining classes.

And very glad for it!

😃

Is there still such a thing as CLEP?
 
I did… I had studied Catholicism a few years on my own before I was confirmed and received the Eucharist for the first time. Father met with me one on one for a few sessions, gave me a few tests that the CCD takes when they’re being confirmed before he got approval from the Bishop, and I was received into the Church Pentecost last year.

E
 
My story is kind of like tampasteve.

I had a reconversion experience back in 2008 and ended up in a group of Assembly of Gods people.

Anyway, I ended up in Lafayette, Louisiana which is heavily Catholic (as is all south Louisiana).

I went to my first Mass at the Cathedral and for the next six months read every Catholic apologetic book (Keating, Staples, Hahn, Currie, etc) and met the RCIA director for the diocese. I was a baptized Christian (Baptist) and I explained my whole story. I represented him with a document from the USCCB that stated that candidates are to be treated differently than catechumens (i.e., didn’t have to go through the RCIA process). I felt left out of Mass because I couldn’t take Communion and I wanted to “shorten” the process to Confirmation.

While the above is that’s true, in the Lafayette diocese (and the Austin, TX diocese where I was on assignment for five months) they just throw everybody together and everybody goes through RCIA, unless your circumstances are very unique. By the time the RCIA classes started, I’d already read the CCC and many more books and other documents. I knew for more than any of the RCIA parish directors did I thought. The classes were really somewhat on the boring side too, I thought given the knowledge I had obtained up to that point.

But anyways, it was very special to come into the Church at the Easter Vigil. In my parish, I was the only candidate, all others were actually cradle Catholics who had never been confirmed in the Church, so there were no baptisms performed. But starting with Palm Sunday, every day during Holy Week builds as every day you become closer to being confirmed. It’s kind of like the week before getting married or graduating from college. That type of feelings.

I was allowed to take the first Holy Communion which I thought was a special honor from the parish priest.

The next day, the diocese RCIA director who I had actually met almost 10 months earlier, called me and asked how it felt to be Catholic. I said it was fantastic to have finally crossed the Tiber. Looking back, I’m glad I went through the whole RCIA process and came into the Church at the Easter Vigil. It’s a great way to end Holy Week if you’re coming into the Church.

As a side note, I watched the activities at the Vatican during Holy Week. It was interesting to see Benedict celebrate Mass during the week and thinking in 7 hours, I’ll be going through the same Mass. There were five catechumens from across the globe that were chosen to receive the rights of Baptism, Confirmation and Holy Communion from the Holy Father. That had to be one life long enduring memory for those five adult individuals.
👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top