T
Tyrion
Guest
Sorry, your view of computers is too simplistic. You forget that many times quantitative changes will result in qualitative changes. When you combine one oxygen molecule with two hydrogen molecules, you will get a qualitatively different result, rather than just a mixture of two gases. If you pile up uranium atoms onto a mound, at a certain amount you will see an explosion.People can certainly emulate some feelings, but I don’t have to look at another person to decide whether he actually feels or emulates. I know that I actually feel some things. (At times I emulate as well, but I am still capable of feeling.) I would assume you do as well and that you have not been a mechanical emulator for your entire life.
Computers cannot be intelligent in the way humans are! Even a self-programming computer is a more complex version of my TI-84, which is a more complex version of an analog calculator. Have you ever heard the expression that a calculator is an “idiot box”? That is because any computer ONLY responds to external (name removed by moderator)uts and processes according to a set of predetermined rules. If it returns the wrong answer, it is the fault of the user. This is how all computers work. We can view the code, we can view which processes are running, we know what everything does (although there is a lot of stuff when you get to higher levels of processing - so we can’t feasibly look at it all).
No, I don’t. I am simply questioning the assumption that you can make a final judgment about information technology - which is less than a 100 years old - and declare “authoritatively” that certain developments are “forever” out of reach.Are you suggesting that you have an empirically verified model of the human mind that behaves likewise?
But you did not argue, you merely expressed your opinion.Their claims were false to begin with. The Catholic Church does not claim such specific conditions for ensoulment, and one does not even have to claim the existence of the soul in order to argue that computers are not intelligent or self-aware.