Can Catholics Merit Grace ? ECF Augustine answers

  • Thread starter Thread starter brb2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

brb2

Guest
What merits of his own has the saved to boast of when, if he were dealt with according to his merits, he would be nothing if not damned ? Have the just then no merits at all? Of course they do, for they are the just. But they had NO MERITS BY WHICH THEY WERE MADE JUST.

Certainly they can say that forgiveness of sins is a grace which is given with no antecedent merits. For what good merits can sinners have ? Yet even the very remission of sins is not without some merit, if faith asks and obtains it. For there is some merit even if faith, the faith by which that man said: “Lord, be mericiful to me a sinner”; and he went down justified by the merit of humble faith … since whatever good merits there are begin in faith, WHICH WE ACKNOWLEDGE AS A GRATUITIOUS GIFT OF GOD.

What merit, then, does a man have before grace, by which he might receive grace, when OUR EVERY GOOD MERIT IS PRODUCED IN US ONLY BY GRACE, and , when God, crowning our merits, crowns nothing else but His own gifts to us ?
 
I would suggest that being made in the image and likeness of God would be a start. When we are created, we possess immortal souls.

God the Father loves us, so He offers us what we need to attain Heaven, the gates of which were opened by God, the Son. We can reject those gifts, but they will be offered.
 
What merits of his own has the saved to boast of when, if he were dealt with according to his merits, he would be nothing if not damned ? Have the just then no merits at all? Of course they do, for they are the just. But they had NO MERITS BY WHICH THEY WERE MADE JUST.

Certainly they can say that forgiveness of sins is a grace which is given with no antecedent merits. For what good merits can sinners have ? Yet even the very remission of sins is not without some merit, if faith asks and obtains it. For there is some merit even if faith, the faith by which that man said: “Lord, be mericiful to me a sinner”; and he went down justified by the merit of humble faith … since whatever good merits there are begin in faith, WHICH WE ACKNOWLEDGE AS A GRATUITIOUS GIFT OF GOD.

What merit, then, does a man have before grace, by which he might receive grace, when OUR EVERY GOOD MERIT IS PRODUCED IN US ONLY BY GRACE, and , when God, crowning our merits, crowns nothing else but His own gifts to us ?
Man does merit Grace. But God expects man to “go and sin no more.” Paul makes it clear that even he has concerns. Jesus opened the gates of Heaven to man, but man must carry out the works expected by God.

Faith allows man to choose to follow God, but “faith without works are dead.”

Satan knows of God’s majesty; God expects man and angel to act.
 
Hi brb2!

The concept of merit in Catholic theology is often misunderstood by both Catholics and non-Catholics. Here’s some more food for though regarding conditional grace. It’s from another thread you might enjoy - there were some heavy hitters from both sides of the grace debate. Heres the link:

http://forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=265388&page=9** **

Philthy said:
Grace is grace regardless of the conditions unilaterally placed upon it’s dispensation by God. In fact, establishing any conditions at all which provide access to His grace is, in itself, a grace that we don’t deserve. The term “merits grace” simply refers to someone who has met those conditions.
For example:
Salvation is by grace through faith. The fact that faith is a condition of salvation does not obviate that it remains grace, does it? Having faith does not obligate the dispensation of grace in an absolute sense - Gods justice does since he has( by an act of grace) sovereignly declared that salvation is by grace through faith. Again, the rub is that the fact that He established any condition at all by which we have access to His grace (of which we are totally undeserving) - is gracious!

In addition, here is some more commentary and an anology I came up with of the relationship between faith and works from a Catholic perspective.

All acts of faith and love (repentance included) are impossible without God’s grace and in that sense it is all CONTIGENT upon God. That is orthodox Catholic theology.
There is a difference, however, between acknowledging that we are hopeless without God and claiming that it is “all God”. If it were all God in the absolute sense, there would be no need for the conversation we are having - God would do it all. There would be no need for baptism, faith, repentance, forgiveness, perseverance, etc. There would be no need for a bible or a Church - God would just do it all. That is not how God has chosen to accomplish salvation - He does not “force” himself upon us. Like every true love relationship, both parties are willing participants…or not. God will always be faithful, but we are still free to reject all that God offers us by way of grace. Simply look at how some of the Pharisees reacted to Christ. Think about it: we must cooperate with Gods grace in order for it to have its desired effect. We cant remain attached to other gods (money, power, ego, etc) and simultaneously derive the benefit of grace which has as its end remaking us -body and soul - into the image of Christ. So while we are completely dependent upon God to become more Christ-like, we simultaneously have the ability to reject that offer. Because of this reality, we must wake up and realize that we have a part to play in this as well. Our part is small, but we must make the small act of unwrapping the present that God has given us. If we allow ourselves to be overtaken by the lures of the world we run the risk of falling away from intimacy with God and failing to persevere to the end.

Here’s an analogy on grace and our need to cooperate with it for your consideration:

You have a pot, a watering can, a water supply and some dirt and you want to grow a flower.

You are hopeless without a seed. Nothing you do works. Your works do nothing!

God comes along and freely gives us a seed which begins to grow.Thank you God!

He also tells us - I’ll provide the Son, but you need to water the plant or it will die!
You don’t water the plant and it dies after a while.

Explanation:
The pot, can, water and dirt - everything we are - is us in our sinful state.
The flower is a living relationship with God:eternal life
The desire for a flower is the desire for eternal life
The attempt to grow the flower without a seed is works without faith
The seed is God’s gift of Grace and without it there will be no “flower”
Jesus is the Sun - the metaphor was to good to pass up - also necessary
The statement by God is His Word - it tells us what we need to do.
Failing to water the plant is “faith without works”
Watering the plant is the “works”(faith, repentace, forgiving others) part of eternal life - ignore them, and the plant dies. It may grow for a while, but if you ignore them it will die.
 
Man does merit Grace. But God expects man to “go and sin no more.” … Jesus opened the gates of Heaven to man, but man must carry out the works expected by God…God expects man and angel to act.
Hi Gene!

While I don’t disagree with anything you said above, I do think it is important to be clear about statements like “Man does merit Grace”. In an absolute sense there is nothing that a sinful man (ie, all of us) could do to merit God’s favor. Not repenting, asking for forgiveness, loving our neighbor - none of it would remove the stain of sin from the sight of our infinitely holy Father. In this sense man does not - in the absolute sense - merit grace. But there is more! In addition to being infinitely Holy, God is infinitely merciful, just and sovereign. And “he saved us** not because of any righteous deeds** we had done, but because of His mercy” Rom 5:8 In His mercy, God has provided the way to salvation through our Lord and Saviour, Jesus Christ. I dont think that is news to you! But what also was done was that God, in his sovereingty, declared various conditions upon which He would dispense his favor (aka, grace). Once He did this, and bound Himself to it, it could then be said and thought of as something that “man does” to deserve or merit grace, but it must always be remembered that God allowed for these conditions out of Mercy - it was not required by his perfect Justice. All of these conditions (faith, hope, love) are means of uniting ourselves to Christ who is the source of all of our merits.

Here’s my intended point:
Grace is grace regardless of the conditions unilaterally placed upon it’s dispensation by God. In fact, establishing any conditions at all which provide access to His grace is, in itself, a grace that we don’t deserve. The term “merits grace” simply refers to someone who has met those conditions.
For example:
Salvation is by grace through faith. The fact that faith is a condition of salvation does not obviate that it remains grace, does it? Having faith does not obligate the dispensation of grace in an absolute sense - Gods justice does since he has( by an act of grace) sovereignly declared that salvation is by grace through faith. Again, the rub is that the fact that He established any condition at all by which we have access to His grace (of which we are totally undeserving) - is gracious!
So how do we articulate such a reality?
Perhaps the words “earned” or “merited” probably aren’t best to say that we have “met the condition” that God has graciously established, but they simply need to be properly understood in the context they are used.
 
[All acts of faith and love (repentance included) are impossible without God’s grace and in that sense it is all CONTIGENT upon God. That is orthodox Catholic theology.
]

All life owes its existence to a graceful God. But, saying all acts of faith and love are impossible w/o grace … ?

Plenty will say they love God and have faith that he exists … but, they don’t hold Catholic concepts of God. They often hold illicit ideas on love. Augustine was an expert on illicit love, from his Manichean days.

Grace is a gift … says Paul and Augustine, and available to all who desire to be healed by God. The ‘mental merit’ in the equation … to submit our wills freely to Christ. And even this mental action of faith is enabled/inspired by God’s grace … so our meriting salvation is a circular argument for Augustine, that begins / ends with the Trinity.
 
brb2;:
All life owes its existence to a graceful God. But, saying all acts of faith and love are impossible w/o grace … ?
There is nothing we can do to merit God’s grace, brb2. If you think there is something, please tell me what it is and I will point out why I disagree.
Plenty will say they love God and have faith that he exists … but, they don’t hold Catholic concepts of God.
I dont see how this is relevant.
They often hold illicit ideas on love. Augustine was an expert on illicit love, from his Manichean days.
I dont see how this is relevant
Grace is a gift … says Paul and Augustine, and available to all who desire to be healed by God.
Unmerited gift, that is correct.
The ‘mental merit’ in the equation … to submit our wills freely to Christ. And even this mental action of faith is enabled/inspired by God’s grace … so our meriting salvation is a circular argument for Augustine, that begins / ends with the Trinity.
As I tried to point out we dont “merit” salvation in the absolute sense. Any merit that allows us to achieve salvation is entirely dependent upon the merits of Christ. All of Christs merits flow from God’s mercy and love. I personally don’t think the “we can merit salvation” side of the equation is as useful as the “we can merit condemnation” side. Its very easy to understand that concept that if we reject God and neighbor there is a consequence, and its a consequence we have “merited”.

Blessings!
 
Hi Gene!

… But what also was done was that God, in his sovereingty, declared various conditions upon which He would dispense his favor (aka, grace). ** Once He did this, and bound Himself to it**, it could then be said and thought of as something that “man does” to deserve or merit grace, but it must always be remembered that God allowed for these conditions out of Mercy - it was not required by his perfect Justice. .
👍
I bolded and underlined the part of your post that I think really captures the meaning of Church teaching in regards to what is meant when we speak of “meriting” grace.
 
Hi Gene!

While I don’t disagree with anything you said above, I do think it is important to be clear about statements like “Man does merit Grace”. In an absolute sense there is nothing that a sinful man (ie, all of us) could do to merit God’s favor. Not repenting, asking for forgiveness, loving our neighbor - none of it would remove the stain of sin from the sight of our infinitely holy Father. In this sense man does not - in the absolute sense - merit grace. But there is more! In addition to being infinitely Holy, God is infinitely merciful, just and sovereign. And “he saved us** not because of any righteous deeds** we had done, but because of His mercy” Rom 5:8 In His mercy, God has provided the way to salvation through our Lord and Saviour, Jesus Christ. I dont think that is news to you! But what also was done was that God, in his sovereingty, declared various conditions upon which He would dispense his favor (aka, grace). Once He did this, and bound Himself to it, it could then be said and thought of as something that “man does” to deserve or merit grace, but it must always be remembered that God allowed for these conditions out of Mercy - it was not required by his perfect Justice. All of these conditions (faith, hope, love) are means of uniting ourselves to Christ who is the source of all of our merits.

Here’s my intended point:
Grace is grace regardless of the conditions unilaterally placed upon it’s dispensation by God. In fact, establishing any conditions at all which provide access to His grace is, in itself, a grace that we don’t deserve. The term “merits grace” simply refers to someone who has met those conditions.
For example:
Salvation is by grace through faith. The fact that faith is a condition of salvation does not obviate that it remains grace, does it? Having faith does not obligate the dispensation of grace in an absolute sense - Gods justice does since he has( by an act of grace) sovereignly declared that salvation is by grace through faith. Again, the rub is that the fact that He established any condition at all by which we have access to His grace (of which we are totally undeserving) - is gracious!
So how do we articulate such a reality?
Perhaps the words “earned” or “merited” probably aren’t best to say that we have “met the condition” that God has graciously established, but they simply need to be properly understood in the context they are used.
Philthy,

While you cannot disagree with anything I said, I can. I tried to do something on the forum I hadn’t tried before–using my iPhone to post. It, it it’s infinite wisdom, changed “Man doesn’t (probably misspelled) merit Grace” to “Man does merit Grace.” That being said, I enjoyed your answer.

Gene
 
👍
I bolded and underlined the part of your post that I think really captures the meaning of Church teaching in regards to what is meant when we speak of “meriting” grace.
Thanks Nita for the kind words! I have to be honest in that I have not read a lot of Church teaching directly regarding this topic - at least I cant remember doing so. I have been exposed to plenty through others here. ItsJustDave and I were once involved in a thread on the topic and he was very knowledgeable on actual Church teaching, ECFs, etc etc. If I remember correctly, there is a term for the different merits - one is “condign merit”, but I cant remember the other…maybe I’ll go find it while its fresh in my mind…

Blessings!
 
Found it! Read his stuff if you want to truly understand this topic…he even has a website if you have a question…
http://forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=428417&postcount=24

…it is due to the condign merit of Christ, and not by any merit of ours that we are justified. We have no innate abilities to earn grace of justification. Why? Because we need antecedent actual grace, as “faith comes from what is heard, and what is heard comes through the word of Christ.” (Rom 10:17). Because “actual grace internally and directly enlightens and strengthens the will (sententia certa)” (Ott, 225). Without actual grace, such as that which we hear from God, through the word of Christ, which is always a gratuitous gift from God, we remain un-enlightened and un-strengthened. In other words, we remain unprepared for sanctifying grace. So, God gives us actual grace, and although this gift can be rejected, it is grace alone, earned by the merit of Christ (not anything we’ve done) that causes justifying faith, which always includes hope and love.
The analogy I like to use is that of the heavenly gift of manna. It, like actual and sanctifying grace, was purely a gift from God. Nothing the Israelites did gave them a strict right (condign merit) to manna. Yet, although completely undeserved, in order to receive this gift, God required their cooperation. God didn’t require their deservedness, but required their participation in enjoying the effects that manna would produce in them (ie., bodily nourishment). If they didn’t receive the manna as God prescribed, the manna turned to worms, and did not produce the intended effect. Yet, the Israelite’s cooperation DID NOT ADD to or in any way **cause **the nutritious effect of manna. Strictly speaking, it was ONLY the food of manna that produced the effect in them. The “collecting” did not add to the nutritious effect that manna already had. However, defiance in receiving this heavenly gift contrary to God’s instructions certainly place a barrier in receiving the effect of that gratuitous gift.

Think of this similarly to receipt of the Holy Eucharist. It too is a free gift and always conveys grace ex opere operato so long as we receive it as prescribed by God, that is, with proper disposition. My disposition does NOT ADD TO or cause the grace given by the Blessed Sacrament. It can only be a barrier to its effects. It is this grace alone (not anything we’ve done) that brings about (formally causes) its effect.

Keep this in mind, as it is an important point: antecedent free will acts can only be a barrier, not a formal or efficient cause to the grace of justification, just as our disposition can only be a barrier, not a formal or efficient cause to the grace of the Blessed Sacrament.
So, our free will cooperation with antecedent actual grace does not add to the effects of grace. It can only be a barrier to the effects. So, as the Lutherans and Catholics jointly declare “Lutherans do not deny that a person can reject the working of grace.” (JD, 21). Yet, it is equally true that no person’s natural merit can add anything to the working of grace.

Contrary to Calvinist doctrine of “irresistible grace,” JD 21 explicitly affirms that Lutheran and Catholic doctrine assert that man can freely reject the “working of grace.” That same paragraph does state that cooperation isn’t needed. I understand that to mean needed as a cause of justfication, which is correct. However, JD 21 affirms that the lack of cooperation can be a barrier to justification. That’s what JD 21 means when it asserts: “they mean thereby to exclude any possibility of contributing to one’s own justification.” (JD 21) In other words, just as our disposition is in no way an efficient or formal cause to the grace of the Blessed Sacrament, so too is our cooperation in no way an efficient or formal cause to the grace of justification.

Furthermore, just in case JD 21 is misinterpreted contrary to Catholic teaching, the Joint Doctrine provides a cross-reference at the end of section 4.1 to better explain the authentic sense of that section in more detail, in the appendix of the Joint Declaration. Observe,Quote:**For 4.1: **Human Powerlessness and Sin in Relation to Justification (paras 19-21) (LV:E 42ff; 46; VELKD 77-81; 83f)
  • “Those in whom sin reigns can do nothing to merit justification, which is the free gift of God’s grace. Even the beginnings of justification, for example, repentance, prayer for grace, and desire for forgiveness, must be God’s work in us” (USA, no. 156.3). (JD, appendix “for 4.1”) Is this contrary to Catholic teaching? No. According to Dr. Ott, the meritorious cause of justification is Jesus Christ. (cf. Ott, 251)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top