Can Catholics practise Martial Arts?

  • Thread starter Thread starter pwsy18
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

pwsy18

Guest
I have this senior church elder who says that practising Tai Chi is nothing wrong as long as he doesn’t get into the spiritualism aspect of it. He does the “exercises” for his health, accordingly. Somehow this disturbs me (like St. Paul’s remarks on the consequences of food offered to idols); i tried to search for some answers or even a teaching from Catholic sites, but it appears there’s none. The other denominations have plenty to say about this. Can anyone assist? Thanks

Blessed day.

Paul…
 
Catholics most certainly CAN practise martial arts.I know this because I used to do kickboxing. & I went to a Catholic primary school and they had a tai chi course and we were even encouraged to do it.So there is definitely nothing wrong with Martial Arts.👍
 
I have this senior church elder who says that practising Tai Chi is nothing wrong as long as he doesn’t get into the spiritualism aspect of it. He does the “exercises” for his health, accordingly. Somehow this disturbs me (like St. Paul’s remarks on the consequences of food offered to idols); i tried to search for some answers or even a teaching from Catholic sites, but it appears there’s none. The other denominations have plenty to say about this. Can anyone assist? Thanks

Blessed day.

Paul…
I know a priest who is an expert in Tai Chi.
 
I have this senior church elder who says that practising Tai Chi is nothing wrong as long as he doesn’t get into the spiritualism aspect of it. He does the “exercises” for his health, accordingly. Somehow this disturbs me (like St. Paul’s remarks on the consequences of food offered to idols); i tried to search for some answers or even a teaching from Catholic sites, but it appears there’s none. The other denominations have plenty to say about this. Can anyone assist? Thanks

Blessed day.

Paul…
You can look into military fighting training. Modern army combatives program or seals h2h. Depends on your goals or job. Tim
 
Fr. Leo is a third degree instructor of Tae Kwan Do, a Korean art of hands and kicking defense and a third degree black sash instructor in Arnis, a Filipino art of full contact weapons defense. However that and his breakdancing days were probably before he entered the vocation to the priesthood.

See gracebeforemeals.com/

and catholicherald.com/articles/07articles/frleo.html

Fr. Leo, a Roman Catholic priest of the Archdiocese of Baltimore, may have a TV series on PBS this fall – “Grace Before Meals”.

I’m looking forward to the TV show.

Years ago, I got my green belt, and also blue belt (I don’t recall) at Hidy Ochiai’s Washin Ryu headquarters school. I took Karate for awhile during High School and it greatly helped me to concentrate in classes and improve my High School grades. This might not be everyone’s experience and perhaps my improved grades were because I may have otherwise had a slight learning disability that the Karate training helped me to overcome.

I am a fairly recent convert to the Roman Catholic church and went through RCIA only a few years ago.

I would say yes, a Catholic can practice the Martial Arts so long as it is helpful to life. As long as it helps to promote self-control, physical and mental health. But definitely draw the line and do not participate in non-Catholic religious practices. I think we can respect other religions, show respect and not be disrespectful without denying that we are Catholic.

I once saw a Buddhist priest who was so gentle, peaceful and humble that small birds would come and rest on his outstretched hand if he only wanted this to happen.

jmm08
 
Thanks guys for the heads up; but then again, somehow i still do not feel comfortable with the idea. Basically, after reading through a document written for the Pontifical Council for Culture;

Jesus Christ - the Bearer of the Water of Life
"www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/interelg/documents/rc_pc_interelg_doc_20030203_new-age_en.html. "

I find that most of us, including myself is somewhat still a bit unsure where the line is. It’s like when someone says that the water is hot, i put my hand in, just to verify the statement and i the process scald myself. But then again i’m no theologian, and my understanding of the doc may be due to my own precepts.

Blessed day…👍
 
When we do something or get involved in a routine activity, we cannot do something else at the same time. In other words, we cannot be two places at once (short of becoming a living saint and getting used to bilocation – something we should not count on at all).

In other words, we should stop and ask ourselves what is the best instead of stopping only at what is good or OK. Typically, we set up times in the day for each thing that we have included in our lives. Going to work, commuting, spending time with the kids, spending time with the spouse, spending time reading or watching TV.

When we get absorbed watching a good show on TV at home, this is really saying to everyone else in the family that “my TV show is more important to me right now”. More important than spending time with your spouse or children.

The same thing applies to martial arts. If you really need some physical training, improvement in concentration, then it might become a priority to get involved in something that will help. If this is the case, generally people get involved with a physical activity that interests them as well as meets their needs. We need to remember that this is for a purpose and we need to keep the purpose in clear focus. Being physically fit is not an end in itself. Being able to think clearly is also not an end in itself. If we want to acquire these things as Christians, it is to better serve and glorify the Lord and to be able to better do His will on earth.

Now that Fr. Leo is a Catholic Priest, I suppose he may not be break-dancing as much. But the TV show can be a ministry to others in helping to illustrate or facilitate family togetherness. The family is threatened as an institution, and it is admirable for Fr. Leo to try to do something positive that will attract people who need to see a good model.

Don’t consider that I’m all that bright. I’ve been taking some video classes at work on my computer (the employer provides) and there are a lot of good ones that I think are helpful.

It is important to say no and to disregard things which might be good when there is something better or more important to do.

There are urgent things (people wanting to talk with you, for example phone calls at work). There are important things (things that have bigger consequences if left undone). There are unimportant things (those that have little or no consequence if undone) and there are things not so urgent. For the most part, people may prioritize the urgent and important things first. But what next? Some make the mistake of working on the urgent but unimportant things next. Instead, more careful consideration should be given to important things that are not so urgent.

My experience taking Karate has definitely been helpful to me and helped me to accomplish some of my goals (especially educational goals when I was younger and a student). I am probably a better person because of it – with a little more patience and persistence. But I haven’t taken Karate since then and I don’t think it will become a priority for me again. At this time, I find praying the Rosary can be more important.

jmm08
 
There is nothing wrong with practicing martial arts for health, self defence or fun if there was I’d have to quit my job 😃 . There is something wrong however, if you look to it as a source of spiritual development. If you have to look past the Church for anything spiritual you haven’t searched the Church hard enough.
 
Growing up a huge Bruce Lee fan, heck yeah, the pope better be ok with martial arts! LOL…I’m kidding. I think martial arts, as long as there isn’t a deep religious element internalized by the student, are just fine and a good thing!
 
Catholics most certainly CAN practise martial arts.I know this because I used to do kickboxing. & I went to a Catholic primary school and they had a tai chi course and we were even encouraged to do it.So there is definitely nothing wrong with Martial Arts.👍
Regardless of the pros and cons of martial arts, the fact is the elder is doing it purely for the exercise.

It falls into the meat eaters argument. It appears some Christians were eating meat which had been sacrificed to idols, mainly because it was the best meat. They didn’t care two hoots about the purpose to which the meat had been put. Whereas to others of less faith, it was a threat. So Paul more or less said to be careful about its usage, but didn’t ban it.

The elder doesn’t feet threatened by it and is doing it purely for the exercise. So what’s the big deal?
 
I practice Ninjutsu - I do not practice the meditation aspects of it using the Eastern methods but instead take the time to use Rosary and other forms of Catholic meditation. On the same side there are many things that my Buddhist teacher and I have in common morally speaking that my Catholic husband and I did not morally speaking so I do take the time to look at the teachings she presents in her writings and take what I can use and leave the rest. God bless.
 
I have this senior church elder who says that practising Tai Chi is nothing wrong as long as he doesn’t get into the spiritualism aspect of it. He does the “exercises” for his health, accordingly. Somehow this disturbs me (like St. Paul’s remarks on the consequences of food offered to idols); i tried to search for some answers or even a teaching from Catholic sites, but it appears there’s none. The other denominations have plenty to say about this. Can anyone assist? Thanks

Blessed day.

Paul…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top