Can contracepting individuals expect to hear "Well done, good and faithful servant" when they stand before the Lord?

  • Thread starter Thread starter setter
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Persuming that they have a correctly formed conscience is bordering on ludicrous, and unless they have a correctly formed conscience, it is, to put it politely, somewhat hard to make the case that they have committed a sin. That it is objectively sinful I think we can all agree. That they even have a slight hint of that is significantly debatable.
1791 This ignorance can often be imputed to personal responsibility. This is the case when a man "takes little trouble to find out what is true and good, or when conscience is by degrees almost blinded through the habit of committing sin."59 In such cases, the person is culpable for the evil he commits.
 
NFP is contraception, although it is not artificial. Artificial contraception is what the Church condemns.
Correct, I should have stated that after “Catholic contraception” but that is where the water is so murky for so many.

Thanks for clarifying for me. 👍
 
How is it contraception? Contraception is intrinsically evil.
No, fix. Artificial contraception is intrinsically evil. NFP, on the other hand, is natural and inline with natural law, therefore it is not intrinsically evil.
 
NFP is contraception, although it is not artificial. Artificial contraception is what the Church condemns.
I am not sure I understand how it is contraception?

con·tra·cep·tion(kntr-spshn)
n.
Intentional prevention of conception or impregnation through the use of various devices, agents, drugs, sexual practices, or surgical procedures

The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition copyright ©2000
 
No, fix. Artificial contraception is intrinsically evil. NFP, on the other hand, is natural and inline with natural law, therefore it is not intrinsically evil.
No, NFP is not contraception. With NFP the marital act is not altered in any way. Contraception alters the act. It separates the two aspects that must not be separated.

Spacing births, by NFP, is never the action of contraception.
 
No, NFP is not contraception. With NFP the marital act is not altered in any way. Contraception alters the act. It separates the two aspects that must not be separated.

Spacing births, by NFP, is never the action of contraception.
👍 Agreed!
 
I am not sure I understand how it is contraception?

con·tra·cep·tion(kntr-spshn)
n.
Intentional prevention of conception or impregnation through the use of various devices, agents, drugs, sexual practices, or surgical procedures

The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition copyright ©2000
According to Merriam Webster (which is the definition I am using):
Main Entry: con·tra·cep·tion m-w.com/images/audio.gif
Pronunciation: "kän-tr&-'sep-sh&n
Function: noun
Etymology: contra- + conception
: deliberate prevention of conception or impregnation
 
According to Merriam Webster:

Quote:
Main Entry: con·tra·cep·tion
Pronunciation: "kän-tr&-'sep-sh&n
Function: noun
Etymology: contra- + conception
: deliberate prevention of conception or impregnation
So then tell me how NFP fits into this definition? If it does not then we can agree that it is not contraception.
 
No, NFP is not contraception. With NFP the marital act is not altered in any way. Contraception alters the act. It separates the two aspects that must not be separated.

Spacing births, by NFP, is never the action of contraception.
I fully agree. But there is a difference between artificial contraception (which you are talking about) and natural contraception, which NFP is.
 
I fully agree. But there is a difference between artificial contraception (which you are talking about) and natural contraception, which NFP is.
Sorry, but I refuse to accept your choice of words. Contraception is a grave sin. It is always wrong. It is not mere wordplay.

Birth control is not a sin. Contraception is a sin.
 
So then tell me how NFP fits into this definition? If it does not then we can agree that it is not contraception.
If a couple is abstaining from marital acts on fertile days in favor of infertile ones then isn’t that a deliberate prevention of impregnation?
 
In this case, they mean the same thing according to the dictionary definition of contraception.
Really …contraception; defn: –noun, the deliberate prevention of conception or impregnation by any of various drugs, techniques, or devices;
 
Considering the dismal statistics about the number of Catholic couples who use ABC during their fertile years, do these folks actually expect to hear “Well done, good and faithful servant” (Matthew 25 :14-33) when they stand before the Lord on their personal judgment day? …or the converse “cast the worthless servant into the outer darkness”? The reason I ask, is not to presume to render judgment or discount the infinite mercy of God, but the impression one gets that many lax and dissident Catholics do not consider the reality of having to make an accounting for the “talents” given them to multiply for the kingdom.
I will be so bold as to guess what God would do. I think for the unrepentant, he would show them what their life would have been like if they didn’t use ABC and then ask them “Why didn’t you trust me?” Even so, I don’t even know if he would cast them out. There are SO many reasons why people don’t trust God. It may have been the religious parent who was abusive, it may have been the betrayal of the religious. Only God knows why someone doesn’t trust Him.

Please pray for those who don’t trust God. They don’t know what they’re missing.
 
I will be so bold as to guess what God would do. I think for the unrepentant, he would show them what their life would have been like if they didn’t use ABC and then ask them “Why didn’t you trust me?” Even so, I don’t even know if he would cast them out. There are SO many reasons why people don’t trust God. It may have been the religious parent who was abusive, it may have been the betrayal of the religious. Only God knows why someone doesn’t trust Him.

Please pray for those who don’t trust God. They don’t know what they’re missing.
True. But, part of me cannot get beyond the sense of entitlement, self-indulgent attitudes that I have encountered amongst my many fellow Catholics. Trust implies knowing the person of God through the extension and gift of faith; through a life of lived faith experience; of dying to self and entering the desert of self-deprivation in order to experience the resurrection and bountiful blessings of God …yes, pray for these self or otherwise deceived and short changed folks.
 
True. But, part of me cannot get beyond the sense of entitlement, self-indulgent attitudes that I have encountered amongst my many fellow Catholics. Trust implies knowing the person of God through the extension and gift of faith; through a life of lived faith experience; of dying to self and entering the desert of self-deprivation in order to experience the resurrection and bountiful blessings of God …yes, pray for these self or otherwise deceived and short changed folks.
Yes, but you would have to remember not to be like the older brother in he Prodigal Son parable. I think that if people knew what they were doing they would weep and I think that God is so merciful enough that he can forgive ignorance. He forgave the people that killed him, I doubt he will cast into hell people who were victims to a sick culture. Like I say, It is my hope that he won’t.
 
Yes, but you would have to remember not to be like the older brother in he Prodigal Son parable.
There is always the temptation to look with preumption at the other family members who have strayed from the estate …but, still … :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top