Can I gain an indulgence for this?

  • Thread starter Thread starter 14er
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
1

14er

Guest
I know that an indulgence can be gained by reading scripture for 30 minutes or something like that, along with all the usual conditions, but how about listening to the Bible for 30 minutes? I listen to the Truth and Life audio bible for hours at a time, and was wondering. I know there probably isn’t a definitive answer to this because I doubt the handbook of indulgences has been updated to reflect this new reality. Do I need to ask my bishop?
 
I know that an indulgence can be gained by reading scripture for 30 minutes or something like that, along with all the usual conditions, but how about listening to the Bible for 30 minutes? I listen to the Truth and Life audio bible for hours at a time, and was wondering. I know there probably isn’t a definitive answer to this because I doubt the handbook of indulgences has been updated to reflect this new reality. Do I need to ask my bishop?
My opinion, and bear in mind it is only my opinion would be no. I think to gain an indulgence you can’t just read the bible but you also need to process what is being read.

For instance, have you ever read something and let your mind wander and then realized you have no idea what you just read? So just reading words doesn’t help you. You need to reflect upon them – particularly on something as dense as the bible.

I think listening to the bible is good but are you doing other things while listening that prevents you from giving your full concentration, ie are you trying to go to sleep, are you working on a paper, are you cleaning etc etc… From my experience when I listen to something like a book on CD or whatnot it is usually because I am doing something else so that I can’t read it ie driving and therefor I am not giving it my full concentration.

Maybe if you are actually meditating on it as you go by pausing the CD and reflecting so that you give it your full attention.

Just my two cents.
 
I know that an indulgence can be gained by reading scripture for 30 minutes or something like that, along with all the usual conditions, but how about listening to the Bible for 30 minutes? I listen to the Truth and Life audio bible for hours at a time, and was wondering. I know there probably isn’t a definitive answer to this because I doubt the handbook of indulgences has been updated to reflect this new reality. Do I need to ask my bishop?
I’m not so sure that you can gain an idulgence from listening to the Bible on CD. Reading the Bible requires more effort… which is a part of the whole point.

To my way of thinking - if one could gain an idulgence from listening to the Bible on CD, then why not watch Sunday Mass on television and consider that to be meeting ones Sunday obligation.

When in doubt, ask a priest. 🙂
 
I say, who cares? Listening to audio bible can be tremendous. I played the new testament on repeat for several months; slept to it, worked to it, occasionally paid attention to it. To me that’s an indulgence right there, being able to listen to audio bible. 🙂
 
Reading or listening is the same as long as you pay attention. You hear the Word of God either way. Be careful about being too legalistic about this indulgence.

Consider for a moment the illiterate. Do they not read the Bible by hearing it? Are they unable to gain this indulgence because they cannot read?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top