Can I tell my teenager to go to confession?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Liliellen
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Liliellen

Guest
My 16-year-old daughter was told by her priest that “nobody can tell her to go to confession.” Is this true? Aren’t we supposed to tell our loved ones to go to confession if they are apart from God and to encourage them to reconcile? If she is my daughter and I see she has committed a mortal sin, can I tell her to go to confession? If I don’t tell her, how is she going to change? Thank you very much for your help!
 
If your daughter’s confessor told her, “Nobody can tell [you] to go to confession,” then that is unfortunate. Bishop Fulton Sheen once told the story of how he literally shoved someone into a confessional who needed to confess (source). I don’t recommend doing what he did, but the point is that it is inaccurate to say that “nobody” (which would include those with spiritual authority like a priest or a parent) can “tell” a person to go to confession.

What the priest should have said is that “Nobody can force you to go to confession.” (Even Bishop Sheen likely would have agreed with that, and certainly would not have prevented the person he shoved from leaving the confessional if she had continued to refuse to confess.) While those with the authority to do so can encourage and even exhort someone to go to confession, each person must freely choose whether or not he will confess.

I should caution you though to be careful about deciding that you know your daughter has committed a mortal sin. Mortal sin requires grave matter, adequate knowledge, and deliberate consent. If one of those elements is missing, there is not a mortal sin. You can know that something is grave matter, but only your daughter, perhaps with the assistance of her confessor or spiritual director, can determine whether or not what she did met all of the conditions for mortal sin.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top