Can Labor Day be part of Catholic Tradition?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JReducation
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JReducation

Guest
A few days ago, I had to prepare a lesson for the postulants. I decided to reflect on Labor Day. As I was preparing the lesson, it struck me that labor and the worker are historically an important part of Catholic tradition. Sometimes on these threads, we reduce Traditional Catholicism to the never ending debates about the EF & OF, CITH & COTT, and Latin & Vernacular. When we do this, we risk missing much of Catholic Tradition. One of those is the Theology of Work.

Looking through the Scripture, in the opening chapter of Genesis, God reveals himself to us as a worker. The ancient Jewish writers present to us a God who is at work. To emphasize that point, they add a seventh day to the Creation Narrative where God rests. We know that God is not a corporeal being who gets tired as we do. The message is that God works. We have often written about “the work of creation” and “the work of salvation.”

As we navigate through the Scripture we see that God creates man in his image and likeness; but what does he do? He assigns to Adam the task of caring for creation. Again, we see God disclosing the value of work by building it into human nature.

But let’s not stop there. Let’s observe those whom God has called. The patriarchate of Israel begins with the call of a shepherd, Abram. The royal family begins with another shepherd. The Church begins with workers. The Apostles were not aristocrats. At the Incarnation, the Eternal Logos becomes flesh and appears to the world as the son of a carpenter.

As the Church evolves, we see the value and place or work in the life of faith. Some of the great theologians and spiritual masters teach us of the value of work. St. Benedict, the Theologian of Obedience par excellence, tells his brothers to work and pray. This is extremely important. Benedict and Scholastic founded their religious family on the principle of obedience. In fact, the Benedictine Rule requires only two vows: obedience and stability. However, work and prayer are necessary to nurture obedience. It is not enough to sit and obey. Benedict and Scholastica teach us that we cannot obey, unless we know how to pray and work. It’s not an either or proposition.

Holy Father Francis, the Master Theologian on Poverty, told his sons and daughters that they must obey without question. He went as far as including a curse in his writings for those who did not obey him. Let’s look at what he commands them to obey. Like Paul, he tells them that they must work. That those who do not know how to work, must learn to do so. At one point, there was an aristocratic man who joined the brotherhood, whom Franciscan Tradition has called Brother Hat. This particular brother would not wear a cowl. He insisted on wearing a hat. Brother Francis took a deep gulp of air and tolerated that. It soon became apparent that Brother Hat did not do his share of work. That’s when Brother Francis lost it.

It’s hard to imagine Brother Francis of Assisi losing it. We have distorted his image, presenting him as a pious, mellow, gentle chap. He was pious and gentle, but never mellow. He was very strong and very demanding of himself, his brothers and the laity. The one thing that he demanded was work.

You see, Francis understood that poverty is not a means, but an end. It is goal for which we work. The man who is poor owns nothing but his sinfulness. The man who is poor does not own his own Will. The man who is poor, does not own his achievements. Like the serfs who worked for the feudal lords, the poor man works for the Father. Like Christ, the poor man does not do as he wishes or gets frustrated because life does not turn out as he hopes it will. He accepts the will of the Father, as Christ accepted it on the Mt. of Olives. How do poor people sustain themselves? They work. The poor are not aristocrats who sit and live off the work of their subordinates.

Jesus Christ worked. Christ the King is a worker king. If we are to do as Paul says, “conform to Christ in all things” and as St. John says, “remain in his love,” then we must embrace obedience and poverty. Work is the external expression of our journey to the poor and obedient Christ.

Have we ever stopped to think about the workers of the world, the value of work, and our responsibility to work? The Holy Father Francis said that when we are not compensated for our work, we should feel no shame in appealing to “The table of the Lord,” in other words, we should beg. But begging should only come after we have attempted to work. We were not created for entitlement. Work reminds us of that reality.

Labor Day may be an American holiday, but it has a place in Traditional Judeo-Catholic theology.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
Br. JR,

Interesting thoughts.
However, work and prayer are necessary to nurture obedience.
Can you go a little more into the above please?
You see, Francis understood that poverty is not a means, but an end. It is goal for which we work.
More on this please.
Have we ever stopped to think about the workers of the world, the value of work, and our responsibility to work? The Holy Father Francis said that when we are not compensated for our work, we should feel no shame in appealing to “The table of the Lord,” in other words, we should beg.
I admit I don’t think of work in such glowing lights. In fact, I tend to think of it as a necessary evil. Although I feel blessed to have a job, I would prefer not to put in the 9-5 dealing with stress and office politics.

What is your opinion of panhandlers who sometimes sing a song or do a dance on the train and then beg for money. Some have been doing it for years and don’t want the responsibility or stress of paying bills, so they live day for day. What is your opinion of these type of people?
 
Br. JR,

Interesting thoughts.

Can you go a little more into the above please?
Obedience to the Father is requires discipline and grace. Prayer will be the means to grace and work disciplines the mind.
More on this please.
The objective of the Christian life is to become one with the Crucified Chrst, to become one with poverty. We have to begin somewhere.

We must begin with the simple steps of detachment, detachment from things. Then we move on to detachment from people and places. From there, we proceed to deatch from our opinions, our biases, and cling on to the only opinion that matters, the opinion of Christ.

We cannot see Christ’s message with clarity and without prejudice as long as we hang on to our things, our opinions and our sense of self-importance. “I must decrease so that he can increase.”
I admit I don’t think of work in such glowing lights. In fact, I tend to think of it as a necessary evil. Although I feel blessed to have a job, I would prefer not to put in the 9-5 dealing with stress and office politics.
The stress and pain that comes is part of our sinful condition. It comes to use from Original Sin, not from work. Before Adam sinned, he worked. God has never sinned and yet he worked. His eternal son rescued the world from sin, but he worked. He is the Worker King.

As St. Jose Maria Escriva said many times. Our work must be our contribution to building the Kingdom of God. When we do our work to the best of our ability, with honesty and with respect for those whom we serve, we enage in the Opus Dei (the Work of God).

However, if we see work as a necessary evil, we sin against the most high Lord. How can we call that which God himself does, work, an evil, necessary or unnecessary?
What is your opinion of panhandlers who sometimes sing a song or do a dance on the train and then beg for money. Some have been doing it for years and don’t want the responsibility or stress of paying bills, so they live day for day. What is your opinion of these type of people?
Whenever I meet one of these unfortunate souls I see myself in them. I see my spiritual poverty, my lack of love, my sinfulness, my desire to take the easy way instead of the cross. Therefore, I just walk up to them and I introduce myself saying, “I am Jay . . . your brother. How can I help you today?”

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
Br.Jay,
Thanks for the great post. I am still trying to wrap my mind (from conversations on earlier threads) about how the lay person expresses obedience and poverty in the secularism in our world. How does that play out in the work force, and also for a stay at home mom like me? Can you expound on this some? Thanks…
 
Br.Jay,
Thanks for the great post. I am still trying to wrap my mind (from conversations on earlier threads) about how the lay person expresses obedience and poverty in the secularism in our world. How does that play out in the work force, and also for a stay at home mom like me? Can you expound on this some? Thanks…
I would encourage you to become familiar with Mary. She was a stay at home mom, until Jesus reached adulthood.

Let’s look at her in bite size pieces. At the annunciation, Mary asked Gabriel how it was possible for her to become pregnant, since she did not know man. The angel answered her. He told her two things. He told her that “nothing is impossible for God.” Mary knew this. He also added, that the Holy Spirit would come upon her.” This is important. Until this point, we have not heard the Scripture speak about the Holy Spirit as a person. The OT speaks of “the Spirit of the Lord”. The Jews did not know that God is Trinitarian.

There was no reason for Mary to know this, much less understand it. However, she accepts it. Mary accepts not only the Will of God, also the Word of God at face value. She lays aside her prejudices, her own notions of how things like conception and pregnancies happen.

God knew that she would voluntarily strip herself of her preconceived notions and her doubts and do his Will. That’s why the angel tells her that she has found favor with God.

The hardest thing to put aside is our own ideas. We have a sense of self-importance. Our opinions cannot be challenged, because they come from us. How dare anyone question them? Our understanding of God is the correct one; after all, it’s ours.

No one ever listens to a poor man. The poor have no voice in society, not then and not today. Mary, took her place among the poor. She laid aside her voice and accepted God’s voice in her life and that of her family. She says as much to Elizabeth, “he has looked upon his lowly servant.” Two words here are important for any mother and any Christian, “lowly” and “servant”. We can go about our daily tasks and become upset when we’re not appreciated or respected or we can see ourselves as Mary saw herself, as lowly servants. What we do is not as important as how we do it. Poverty is a frame of mind, the same frame of mind that we see in Mary who called herself a lowly servant and in Christ who washed the feet of his apostles, as a common servant.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
I would encourage you to become familiar with Mary. She was a stay at home mom, until Jesus reached adulthood.

Let’s look at her in bite size pieces. At the annunciation, Mary asked Gabriel how it was possible for her to become pregnant, since she did not know man. The angel answered her. He told her two things. He told her that “nothing is impossible for God.” Mary knew this. He also added, that the Holy Spirit would come upon her.” This is important. Until this point, we have not heard the Scripture speak about the Holy Spirit as a person. The OT speaks of “the Spirit of the Lord”. The Jews did not know that God is Trinitarian.

There was no reason for Mary to know this, much less understand it. However, she accepts it. Mary accepts not only the Will of God, also the Word of God at face value. She lays aside her prejudices, her own notions of how things like conception and pregnancies happen.

God knew that she would voluntarily strip herself of her preconceived notions and her doubts and do his Will. That’s why the angel tells her that she has found favor with God.

The hardest thing to put aside is our own ideas. We have a sense of self-importance. Our opinions cannot be challenged, because they come from us. How dare anyone question them? Our understanding of God is the correct one; after all, it’s ours.

No one ever listens to a poor man. The poor have no voice in society, not then and not today. Mary, took her place among the poor. She laid aside her voice and accepted God’s voice in her life and that of her family. She says as much to Elizabeth, “he has looked upon his lowly servant.” Two words here are important for any mother and any Christian, “lowly” and “servant”. We can go about our daily tasks and become upset when we’re not appreciated or respected or we can see ourselves as Mary saw herself, as lowly servants. What we do is not as important as how we do it. Poverty is a frame of mind, the same frame of mind that we see in Mary who called herself a lowly servant and in Christ who washed the feet of his apostles, as a common servant.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
Thanks so much for the great answer, Br.Jay!
After reading this, something just clicked :newidea ! I understand poverty in a different way now. It is a setting aside of one’s preconceived notions, intelligence, ideas of how things should go, stripping of one’s identity, with the intention of being more open to the plans of our Lord. (Sorry it has taken me so long to catch on :rolleyes:)…beforehand I was thinking it of more of a penance in order to stay focused on God (which is also true) but now I see it more of an “opening up” of one’s heart with the goal of letting God do all the planning, scheming, determining of what He wants to accomplish…so that we can be his heart and hands here on earth…am I thinking right?
Blessings on this Labor day to you and all!
 
Hi Bro. Jay! Here in our part of the world, labor day falls on the 1st of May, Feast of St. Joseph the worker. Thanks for your post. One more point to reflect on. 🙂
 
Thanks so much for the great answer, Br.Jay!
After reading this, something just clicked :newidea ! I understand poverty in a different way now. It is a setting aside of one’s preconceived notions, intelligence, ideas of how things should go, stripping of one’s identity, with the intention of being more open to the plans of our Lord. (Sorry it has taken me so long to catch on :rolleyes:)…beforehand I was thinking it of more of a penance in order to stay focused on God (which is also true) but now I see it more of an “opening up” of one’s heart with the goal of letting God do all the planning, scheming, determining of what He wants to accomplish…so that we can be his heart and hands here on earth…am I thinking right?
Blessings on this Labor day to you and all!
BINGO!

But like all spiritual matters, we begin with concrete actions. The first place to being detaching or letting go is with material things. For example, the mother of a family owes it to her family to provide whatever is necessary. She may stay at home or go out and hold job. In either case, whatever money or material things are at her disposal are for the good of her family and of the poor, not for her personal enhancement. There is a place to begin material povery.

She places her family, the poor and the world before herself. There she begins to detach from preocupation with self. She reserves for herself only what she needs in order to serve her family and the poor. Obviously she needs certain things, but a lot less than most mothers think they need. She separates what she needs from what she wants.

Like Mary, she opens herself to be used by God for his purpose. To be so open, one must let go of preconceived notions, expectations, and one must meet people where they are, not where we want them to be. For a mother, this begins at home. We see this when Jesus is lost and found at the temple. The Scripture says that Mary gave Jesus and earful. That’s not unusual. He scared the daylights out of her. Kidnapping was very common in those days. That’s how slaves were taken from place to place. Many were people who had been kidnapped as children.

When Jesus responds that he is about his Father’s business, the Scritpure tells us that Mary kept all of these things in her heart. In other words, she met her son where he was at. She did not understand. She was still angry as heck at him and wanted to give him a good spanking and send him to his room without a meal. She probably did, if I know my Jewish mothers. 😃 Hey I’m Jewish. I have a righ to know my Jewish mothers. Trust me, they’re tyrants, but loveable. 😛

Let’s get back to Mary, poverty and work. She may have given Jesus a consequence for disappearing without letting anyone know where he was going. We don’t know. What we do know is that she does not hang on to her preconcieved notions of what her son should or should not be. She lets God use him as God wishes and she does not become an obstacle in God’s plan. For a mother to allow God this much freedom with her children requires a great deal of trust and detachment. This is poverty, when one can accept that one owns nothing, not even one’s plans for one’s children. Oh what a holy virtue. If only all mothers and fathers could be that reliant on God’s providence.
Hi Bro. Jay! Here in our part of the world, labor day falls on the 1st of May, Feast of St. Joseph the worker. Thanks for your post. One more point to reflect on. 🙂
This is important. The eternal Word of God, who was with God from the beginning, who participated in the work of creation, who should have been born master over creation, is born the son of craftsman, a simple worker. Yet, how often we complain about work, avoid work and look down upon those who do tasks that we consider beneath us.

Imagine sitting in an office and having Joseph and his young son Jesus arrive to setup your shelves. Don’t we usually ignore such workers as they come and go through our place of employment? The next time the maitenance man, the cleaning lady, or the carpenter walks by, remember, this could have been Joseph and Jesus.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
I suppose it can be apart of American Catholic tradition. (I don’t know what other countries have labor day 🤷). Because a lot of Catholic immigrants were blue collar workers who were true laborers if you know what I mean ;). But blue collar jobs are fading and more jobs are white collar or something like white collar. The middle class is now white collar-ish. So in conclusion, I don’t know.
 
Fascinating Brother!

For some reason I never thought of the Father as a worker, but as you point out, indeed he did. I never lkinked the process of creation with work but it is clear that is what the scriptures are telling us. Thanks for that!
 
As a secular Benedictine all I can offer to this thread is “Ora et Labora” 😉

BTW Brother, the rest of the world has a sort of “labour day” too, they celebrate it on May 1st. So it’s not exclusively N. American, just the date.
 
As a secular Benedictine all I can offer to this thread is “Ora et Labora” 😉

BTW Brother, the rest of the world has a sort of “labour day” too, they celebrate it on May 1st. So it’s not exclusively N. American, just the date.
I was actually wondering when you were going to weigh in. 😃
 
As a secular Benedictine all I can offer to this thread is “Ora et Labora” 😉

BTW Brother, the rest of the world has a sort of “labour day” too, they celebrate it on May 1st. So it’s not exclusively N. American, just the date.
Hey! 😃

That’s what I said above. 😛

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
As a secular Benedictine all I can offer to this thread is “Ora et Labora” 😉

BTW Brother, the rest of the world has a sort of “labour day” too, they celebrate it on May 1st. So it’s not exclusively N. American, just the date.
Americans prefer the Latin (spelling) “labor” ("-our" is French) but you probably already know that. 🙂

An interesting piece of trivia I ran across. Thomas Jefferson in his first draft of the Declaration of Independence actually wrote in the word “honour” and it was almost the first thing they corrected to the word “honor.” Happy Labor Day!
 
Thank you for this, Brother JR. Just moments before reading this (literally just a minute or 2), I was “lamenting” (only partially joking) over how being seen as a competent worker was like a curse, and that I’d like to give incompetence a try for a while. Your words struck my heart and my conscience with such force that I am sitting here with tears in my eyes. Thank you for the shift in perspective. It was much needed and is more appreciated than you can know.
May God continue to bless you and sustain your ability to teach in such a clear and compassionate manner.
.
No one ever listens to a poor man. The poor have no voice in society, not then and not today. Mary, took her place among the poor. She laid aside her voice and accepted God’s voice in her life and that of her family. She says as much to Elizabeth, “he has looked upon his lowly servant.” Two words here are important for any mother and any Christian, “lowly” and “servant”. We can go about our daily tasks and become upset when we’re not appreciated or respected or we can see ourselves as Mary saw herself, as lowly servants. What we do is not as important as how we do it. Poverty is a frame of mind, the same frame of mind that we see in Mary who called herself a lowly servant and in Christ who washed the feet of his apostles, as a common servant.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
 
Americans prefer the Latin (spelling) “labor” ("-our" is French) but you probably already know that. 🙂

An interesting piece of trivia I ran across. Thomas Jefferson in his first draft of the Declaration of Independence actually wrote in the word “honour” and it was almost the first thing they corrected to the word “honor.” Happy Labor Day!
Americans did not standardize spelling until the 1930’s. our instead of or was seen as interchangeable until this time. When I went to school colour, honour, labour were all acceptable forms of spelling.
 
Americans prefer the Latin (spelling) “labor” ("-our" is French) but you probably already know that. 🙂
I’m Canadian and we spell it “labour”, as do the Brits. 😃

In French it is actually “labeur” but we call it “fête du travail”. In French, “labourer” means “to plow”; “il laboure son champ” means “he is plowing his field”.

We also say “honour” too!
Hey! 😃

That’s what I said above. 😛

Fraternally,

Br. JR, OSF 🙂
That’ll teach me to skim trough a thread after a couple of glasses of a nice Tuscan red.
 
To be honest isnt every day Labor Day for Catholics!? 😃

[bibledrb]Lk 9:23[/bibledrb]

Happy Labor Day everyone!
 
Americans did not standardize spelling until the 1930’s. our instead of or was seen as interchangeable until this time. When I went to school colour, honour, labour were all acceptable forms of spelling.
When I went to school in London, honour and colour were the only acceptable forms of the spelling. You also posted a letter, not mailed it, “zed” was the last letter in the alphabet, and fortnight is the proper measure of two weeks. (A Pole remembers such things. 🙂 )

You could be right about the timeline of the American standardization of the spellings.
 
fwiw

The noon weekday Mass I frequent was well attended today. Ten times the number of a normal Monday.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top