Can Low Grades in School be a Sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MarytheDefender
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MarytheDefender

Guest
I’m a law student and the academic workload has been wearying. I’ve been really pressured by my Dad and his reputation in my law school because he was # 1 in the bar exam and batch valedictorian. So of course my profs know him etc.

The way my Dad talks, its as though not getting high grades means that I am wasting the talents God gave me. That I am not bearing any fruit.

I am not lazy. I even study harder than some of my classmates. But stress, low self-confidence, mental blocks and other problems have really given me a hard time academically.

I just wanted to ask, is what my Dad said true? Can low grades be a sin? A sign that I’m wasting God’s gifts? The last thing I want is to be committing more sins. I love God and want to please Him always! So I’d hate to think that the poor work I end up offering Him is offensive to Him. If don’t do as well as my Dad that would be okay as long as I know that this isn’t a sin.
 
It depend on what cause you to get low grades. If you drink all night and sleep all day it is a sin. If you honestly do your very best it is not.

I think I understand your problem. I can’t say I do because we all have a own way how we feel/deal with things. Your dad want you to be as good as he is. That is natural, and he do so because he love you. You should however think about talking with him. If you are not up to it you are not. Do you really want to be a lawyer? Or do you only want to keep your father happy? If the latter one is the case, tell him. It is a question about what you want. I really wanted to be a doctor and surgeon, but not to please anyone else but me. Nobody told me what they want me to be. All they did say was that “as long as you are happy…”. And that is how it should be. I have never told my kids what I want them to be. That is really not my business. If you are forced to be anything we can think, you will never enjoy your work. And if you don’t enjoy it, you are not good in what you do. If you love, you will be the best. But not because someone told you to. It is a long way to the top, and if you are not totally giving all you have and can, you will not reach the peak.

So, talk to your father. He will understand, no matter what you may think now.
 
The truth is I want to be a lawyer. A human/pro-life lawyer. I study almost all the time. Barely spend time with friends and extra-curriculars even. But the results aren’t there.

He will not understand! My dad isn’t working as a lawyer anymore. He is a businessman. And he wants me to help in his business. But he isn’t willing to admit that to me to my face. He keeps on discouraging me from becoming a human rights lawyer. While expecting me to excel! I am a big embarrassment to his peers from law school! In the end he wants me to work for his business. We have fought many times!

I honestly thought that this was my vocation… But all the pro-choice and corruption and materialism in school is suffocating. I love the end goal though! Being able to serve the poor and oppressed in society. But my grades are bad and my dad makes my feel like bad grades are sins…

Thank you for your reply and telling that I’m not hurting Jesus! It means a lot to me.
 
EDIT:…wrote this before seeing your reply above…

What your dad says can be true…but not necessarily.
There are those who waste the talents God gave them (I am a case in point) and this is indeed a sin.
However, if you are doing the best that you can, then you are not wasting your talents. It may just be that your talents lay in a different area. They may take a different path or display themselves in a different way.
A lawyer with great intellectual acumen and high grades will do well in some situations while a lawyer with lower grades but a great understanding of people may do well in other situations.

Then too…it might be that your talents do not really lay in the area of law at all.
There is an old saying that college has ruined many a fine plumber.
What this means is that in today’s society there is a pressure to go to college to the point where people go who really shouldn’t…their talents lay in other - equally important - areas.

The question here must be what do YOU want to do with your life - in keeping with the talents God has given you.

Peace
James
 
The answer is: it all depends. If like the above poster said your low grades are because you are out drinking and partying everynight then yes, but from what I read seems it is not your case. Law school is very demanding and can be extenuating (I went to law school so I have been in your shoes) and it has become even harder over the years. Sometimes older lawyer (who didn’t have to jumps as many hooks as recent law students) have a difficulty understanding that things now are so Mich harder than even 20 years ago.

Also, I don’t know (and didn’t look) in which state you are, most law schools I know have a curve. From what I read in your post doesn’t look like you are getting bad grades but that your grades are average (is that correct). Does your school have a curve? Because then that is the explanation, it can be extremely difficult to get grades outside the curve because it doesn’t depend on your performance but on other people’s performance. If for example no one gets F or D’s then no one is going to get A plus, and it has nothing to do with you but with the curve. You say you are working hard, as long as you read your cases, do your work and are being responsible, you are doing good. Again older lawyers do not understand how different becoming a lawyer and law school is (they didn’t even have to take the MPRE) so I would say don’t listen to him. Also now a days there is no way to know who is #1 on the bar because if you pass the bar you would never know your results. I am not going to give you the advice of talking with your dad just because from my own experience making old lawyers understand that there is a huge difference between now and then has been a lost battle so sincerely, I doubt your dad is going to understand that it is not that you are waiting your gifts, that it is not that you are not as good as him, it is that he went to a law school where things were much easier. I don’t know how.many years you have left but just ignore him, don’t pay attention, keep working hard and when you are done with school, just get away from him and hide yourself so you can study for the bar properly, without him bothering you.
 
The truth is I want to be a lawyer. A human/pro-life lawyer. I study almost all the time. Barely spend time with friends and extra-curriculars even. But the results aren’t there.

He will not understand! My dad isn’t working as a lawyer anymore. He is a businessman. And he wants me to help in his business. But he isn’t willing to admit that to me to my face. He keeps on discouraging me from becoming a human rights lawyer. While expecting me to excel! I am a big embarrassment to his peers from law school! In the end he wants me to work for his business. We have fought many times!

I honestly thought that this was my vocation… But all the pro-choice and corruption and materialism in school is suffocating. I love the end goal though! Being able to serve the poor and oppressed in society. But my grades are bad and my dad makes my feel like bad grades are sins…

Thank you for your reply and telling that I’m not hurting Jesus! It means a lot to me.
Are you 1L, 2L or 3L? And would you mind telling me which school you are attending, just curious because of the curve issue.
 
You are NOT hurting Jesus!! If it is as you say, that you are applying yourself and trying your best, what more could you possibly ask of yourself? We don’t have to be perfect to be perfect to Christ. Moses had a stutter, but look what God allowed him to do! You just keep on doing your best. Thank you and God bless you for wanting to become a human rights/pro-life lawyer. We need people who can defend what is righteous and good. :blessyou:
 
I agree with Ophelia 23. None of us are perfect, yet you are doing the best you can. That is a heck of lot different than being lazy and not caring at all about your studies. Sometimes people who struggle with getting good grades is not because they are ignorant or stupid, but because the topic being studied is very difficult, or because the professor is not doing a good job in explaining the material to you. I’ve had this experience many times in college. I also get overwhelmed and stressed out by the workload required in some of my classes. This is because I am majoring in a difficult field (Biomedical Engineering). God knows I’m doing the best I can and knows that I am putting as much effort as I can. If you are sincerely striving to be good at something and fall short because of its difficulty, you are not sinning.
 
Are you 1L, 2L or 3L? And would you mind telling me which school you are attending, just curious because of the curve issue.
Thank you so much for the encouragement and advice! But I live in the Philippines so those grading systems don’t apply here. Our country grades by percentage and has one bar exam for the entire country. My Dad really was #1 the year he took the exam.

He keeps telling law school is so easy. Since I find hard it’s discouraging for me to hear that. I’ll take your advice in dealing with him. Thank you! God Bless!
 
Thank you Ophelia and IamCatholic! Your kind encouraging words really helped me put things in perspective! They really consoled me. God is so good! So grateful I’m not sinning! Thank you! God Bless!
 
Thank you so much for the encouragement and advice! But I live in the Philippines so those grading systems don’t apply here. Our country grades by percentage and has one bar exam for the entire country. My Dad really was #1 the year he took the exam.

He keeps telling law school is so easy. Since I find hard it’s discouraging for me to hear that. I’ll take your advice in dealing with him. Thank you! God Bless!
Oh ok, definitely being in a different country changes that bit even in a different country what might not change is that things 30 years ago are not the same as today. I don’t know bout the Philipines but it is very likely that things were so different when he went to law school that he doesn’t have an adequate perception.
 
If you really want to be a lawyer, you will be one. But not because what your dad say, no, because you you want.

Sometimes it take a while for things to “sink in” but with time you will grasp those things as well.
 
You have said that you are not lazy and have done a good job explaining good and honest reasons why a good person would get bad grades. As long as your poor academic ability is not a result of any unchaste living on your part (impurity clouds one’s intellect) you are not to blame for your poor grades and are not sinning in the least – you just sound like your talents lie elsewhere. Maybe you should explore a new career plan. God bless you.
 
One can only do and try to do the best they can. IF you gave it your best try even a D or F is no sin. IF you want to be a lawyer, just try your best. IT may be that your apptitude for Law is just not there or just not there yet. your talents may lie elsewhere or it may just take you a little bit longer to catch on… BUT usually if it is really your hearts desire and you 'love the law, and the practice of it, one usually trys harder and does not give up easily…so ultimately they succeed.

Normally, IF one likes a subject one usually does well in it and vice versa. IF one does not do well in it, they usually hate it. Most folks do not enjoy failure after failure, except folks who are masochistic and enjoy pain and suffering. IF you just don’t have the aptitude for it, you will fail continuosly and you will hate it. Most folks know when to give up.

BUT it is one thing to to be a dismal failure and quite another to do average or just not at the top of the class. I suspect that you are NOT a dismal failure, otherwise you would not want to be a lawyer at all.

You can waste a lot of energy trying to live up to other peoples expectations. You may not be at the top of your class but if you know you tried, there should never be anything to be ashamed of. Not every one is a straight A student. IF everyone were, everyone would be mediocre. There’s plenty of room in the world for us bottom dwellers, so we can make other folks like your dad look good…
 
I’ve known lawyers who were not brilliant students who were good lawyers even so - as well as lawyers who did well in school but not in work.

Being a good lawyer requires things like commonsense, quickness and the ability to relate to and explain things to people of very different backgrounds and education levels, and other things that cannot be tested for very well, or taught very well in law school, that are not learned except by life experience.

Also - having a law degree gives you options for other careers, in things like politics or business or finance. You don’t have to be a lawyer like your father and his friends.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top