Can nuns bless medals?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Eufrosnia
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

Eufrosnia

Guest
I was wondering if nuns can bless things like medals? Recently I was at the Our Lady of Miraculous Medal Chapel in France and it was a nun that came out and blessed my medals.

Is this blessing the same as one I would receive from a priest? Also, is this practice valid?
 
I was wondering if nuns can bless things like medals? Recently I was at the Our Lady of Miraculous Medal Chapel in France and it was a nun that came out and blessed my medals.

Is this blessing the same as one I would receive from a priest? Also, is this practice valid?
I never heard of a Nun blessing anything before and I do not believe it carries the same Blessing as a Priest or Deacon’s Blessing. I would have them Blessed by your Priest. God Bless, Memaw
 
=Eufrosnia;10902179]I was wondering if nuns can bless things like medals? Recently I was at the Our Lady of Miraculous Medal Chapel in France and it was a nun that came out and blessed my medals.
Is this blessing the same as one I would receive from a priest? Also, is this practice valid?
Anybody CAN bless ANYTHING, but that is not your question.

A nun’s blessing does not the power to make someting a sacramental as does the Blessing of:) a priest.
 
Anybody CAN bless ANYTHING, but that is not your question.

A nun’s blessing does not the power to make someting a sacramental as does the Blessing of:) a priest.
That was my initial guess as well. But it seems like my experience was not an isolated incident and I have seen others who mention that nuns blessed their medals and even blessed them too.

Which is why I was wondering if there was perhaps some permission or special power granted to these nuns perhaps.
 
I was wondering if nuns can bless things like medals? Recently I was at the Our Lady of Miraculous Medal Chapel in France and it was a nun that came out and blessed my medals.

Is this blessing the same as one I would receive from a priest? Also, is this practice valid?
No.

From the Code of Canon Law:
Can. 1166 Sacramentals are sacred signs by which effects, especially spiritual effects, are signified in some imitation of the sacraments and are obtained through the intercession of the Church.

Can. 1167 §1. The Apostolic See alone can establish new sacramentals, authentically interpret those already received, or abolish or change any of them.

§2. In confecting or administering sacramentals, the rites and formulas approved by the authority of the Church are to be observed carefully.

Can. 1168 The minister of sacramentals is a cleric who has been provided with the requisite power. According to the norm of the liturgical books and to the judgment of the local ordinary lay persons who possess the appropriate qualities can also administer some sacramentals.

Can. 1169 §1. Those marked with the episcopal character and presbyters permitted by law or legitimate grant can perform consecrations and dedications validly.

§2. Any presbyter can impart blessings except those reserved to the Roman Pontiff or bishops.

§3. A deacon can impart only those blessings expressly permitted by law.
There is no provision for a non-cleric, whether religious or not, to bless objects. The sacramentals referred to in 1168, which indirectly refers to blessings in 1169, may issue blessings in very narrow circumstances (for example, ministering a blessing on a meal, blessing ones own children, blessing a harvest, etc.)
 
Nuns “blessing” medals is scandalous and should be reported to the bishop.
 
Nuns “blessing” medals is scandalous and should be reported to the bishop.
hmmmm, I wouldn’t mind writing a letter to the Bishop but for one thing, I would rather write to the chapel first and for another, I do not even know who the Bishop in charge of the area is (I am not from France).

It is also a widely visited pilgrimage site. So I am thinking there might be some legitimate explanation for all of this. If this was illegitimate, I don’t know why it was not spotted for so long (because some stories I have heard are not recent). But as you say, it is a bit confusing.
 
I know I could be wrong, but it has long been my understanding that sacramentals such as rosaries, holy cards, medals, etc., don’t have to be blessed. They are “blessed” by their use. I’ve never asked a priest to bless any of my sacramentals.
 
I know I could be wrong, but it has long been my understanding that sacramentals such as rosaries, holy cards, medals, etc., don’t have to be blessed. They are “blessed” by their use. I’ve never asked a priest to bless any of my sacramentals.
They are not a sacramental unless blessed by a priest.
Being used does not bestow a blessing to make them a sacramental.
 
Can. 1168 The minister of sacramentals is a cleric who has been provided with the requisite power. According to the norm of the liturgical books and to the judgment of the local ordinary lay persons who possess the appropriate qualities can also administer some sacramentals.

Bolding mine. Looks like it’s up to the bishop to permit blessings of sacramentals by lay people. So the nun very likely had the bishop’s permission.

But - being stubborn - I still think the unblessed rosaries, chaplets, and holy cards that I use in my prayers are sacramentals. They are not used for anything other than prayer & meditaion.​
 
Bolding mine. Looks like it’s up to the bishop to permit blessings of sacramentals by lay people. So the nun very likely had the bishop’s permission.

But - being stubborn - I still think the unblessed rosaries, chaplets, and holy cards that I use in my prayers are sacramentals. They are not used for anything other than prayer & meditaion.
Read the last para in post #5.
 
The Bishop has delegated the right to bless the Miraculous Medals to the nuns at Rue du Bac, because of the affluence of visitors and pilgrims.

I live in France and someone asked this very question in our adult catechism class. This is our priest’s answer.
 
Bonnie, I think that your canon law quote probably refers to such activites as lay people imposing ashes on Ash Wednesday. Blessings are a different matter. Nuns are lay people, they are not ordained. Lay people only have the authority to bless in specific situations such as a father blessing his children. I hope that a priest or canon lawyer can weigh in on this. The OP can fix this problem by having the parish priest bless the medal. It only takes a minute.
 
Bolding mine. Looks like it’s up to the bishop to permit blessings of sacramentals by lay people. So the nun very likely had the bishop’s permission.

But - being stubborn - I still think the unblessed rosaries, chaplets, and holy cards that I use in my prayers are sacramentals. They are not used for anything other than prayer & meditaion.
A sacramental is not just an object. The sign of the cross is a sacramental. So is an exorcism.

From Fr Hardon’s Modern Catholic Dictionary:

Objects or actions that the Church uses after the manner of sacraments, in order to achieve through the merits of the faithful certain effects, mainly of a spiritual nature. They differ from sacraments in not having been instituted by Christ to produce their effect in virtue of the ritual performed. Their efficacy depends not on the rite itself, as in the sacraments, but on the influence of prayerful petition; that of the person who uses them and of the Church in approving their practice. The variety of sacramentals spans the whole range of times and places, words and actions, objects and gestures that, on the Church’s authority, draw not only on the personal dispositions of the individual but on the merits and prayers of the whole Mystical Body of Christ.
The Catholic Encyclopedia has the following categories:
The number of the sacramentals may not be limited; nevertheless, the attempt has been made to determine their general principles or rather applications in the verse: “Orans, tinctus, edens, confessus, dans, benedicens”.
  • Orans indicates public prayer, whether liturgical or private;
  • tinctus, the use of holy water and the unctions in use at various consecrations;
  • edens, the eating of blessed foods;
  • confessus, the general avowal of faults which is made in the Confiteor recited at Mass, at Communion, in the Divine Office;
  • dans, alms;
  • benedicens, papal and episcopal blessings etc., blessings of candles, ashes, palms etc.
Another distinction classifies sacramentals according to whether they are acts, e.g. the Confiteor mentioned above, or things, such as medals, holy water etc. The sacramentals do not produce sanctifying grace ex opere operato, by virtue of the rite or substance employed, and this constitutes their essential difference from the sacraments.
The Bishop has delegated the right to bless the Miraculous Medals to the nuns at Rue du Bac, because of the affluence of visitors and pilgrims.
I am not trying to second guess the local ordinary’s judgment…but that is an odd move. If not for his delegation, the effect of a blessing by a nun would be no different than the effect of a blessing by any of us.
 
The Bishop has delegated the right to bless the Miraculous Medals to the nuns at Rue du Bac, because of the affluence of visitors and pilgrims.

I live in France and someone asked this very question in our adult catechism class. This is our priest’s answer.
I also saw this when I visited Rue du Bac, very strange!
 
The Bishop has delegated the right to bless the Miraculous Medals to the nuns at Rue du Bac, because of the affluence of visitors and pilgrims.

I live in France and someone asked this very question in our adult catechism class. This is our priest’s answer.
Oh that is interesting. Do you know if it possible to get more information about this permission?

Because in a way it seems as if it is not something that can be given by permission because the nuns do not already have such an ability similar to a priest. So that is why it is a bit confusing as to whether this was actually given permission and what the theological underpinnings of it may be.

If you can shed some more light on this, that would be most certainly helpful!
 
The whole thing sounds bizarre to me, Eufrosnia.
I have to admit, I do not know what do make of it as well. I hope our friend Dies_Irae can shed some light on this issue for all of us.
 
Dies Irae said the Bishop delegated the right to bless certain objects to the nuns and Canon Law 1168 says he has the authority to do that.

How is that “bizarre?”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top