Can refusing to make a sacrifice be a mortal sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter timeandeternity
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

timeandeternity

Guest
Last night I had an opportunity to make a small sacrifice (giving up a treat). I am struggling with same-sex attractions, and know that denying myself legitimate pleasures strengthens me and makes my struggles easier. But instead of using this opportunity, I thought, “I’d rather enjoy this treat, even though I may be weaker next time I have to struggle, and even though it might make me more likely to fall.”

Under normal conditions, neglecting to take advantage of an opportunity to make a sacrifice is just an imperfection (at most, a venial sin), but I wonder if it can become a mortal sin in this kind of situation. At the same time, I do have some degree of scrupulosity (though not debilitating or severe), and am having a hard time making a judgment on whether this really was grave matter, or if I’m just being scrupulous. Please help! I would really appreciate your thoughts on this!
 
Can refusing to make a sacrifice be a mortal sin? No. Don’t be scrupulous. God doesn’t want you to suffer, especially not involuntarily, especially if you can’t handle it, especially if you aren’t ready for mortification.

Baby steps. Enjoy treats in moderation. Mortification in moderation. Next time, perhaps just say 3 Haily Mary’s if you decide to eat the treat.

You didn’t “refuse” to make a sacrifice anyway, as there was no obligation on you to make the sacrifice. You just “didn’t” make it. I do that all day, it’s called living. Remember, baby steps friend. When the time comes, mortification and sacrifices will come naturally.
 
We are called upon make moral decisions and act in a way that promotes moral holiness. Putting ourselves in a state of privation is not what we are necessarily required to do. Fasting for penance is fine but it should not be overdone. Privation for the sake of depriving ourselves is not what is being asked of us.
 
Whatever you focus on will become the focus of your attention. For example, focusing on not having the treat you want will make you think more about that treat. The trick is to focus on something postive that you want over something negative that you don’t want.

Sacrifice can be good for the soul but when you start to wrestle (get scrupulous) with the sacrificial object or issue (in your case, a treat or struggling with same sex attractions), the sacrificial object or issue now has power over you.

When Jesus came on earth to spread the Good News, his message was the same. “Come follow me.” If you’re struggling with sin as most people are, it’s easier to overcome if you look upon Jesus rather than look at how hard it is to deny the sin. When you focus on Jesus (read the bible, talk to him in or out of church) and really believe that he is Lord over you, you will be transformed by his grace. Because of our sinful nature, we wrestle with sin (we are in spiritual warfare) daily. But Jesus promised us he would never leave us alone (to our own defenses) but only if we call upon his holy name. Because he sent the Holy Spirit to take his place when he resurrected to heaven, you can call upon the Holy Spirit as well. When you start to get scrupulous over whether or not to sacrifice or feel you can’t overcome your attraction to the same sex, call upon Jesus and the Holy Spirit. But you must believe that help (grace) will be there when you ask for it.

Jesus Rocks
 
Can refusing to make a sacrifice be a mortal sin?
That is not the right question.
Here is the correct question.
Can refusing to make a sacrifice of a LITTLE treat be a BIG/ sin?
You’ve now answered your own question —LITTLE–
Does something little equal something big?

The trick is to say “yes” quickly, and then don’t look back.
 
Be very careful. Scrupulosity is not a good thing and can cause damage to you. Find a good spiritual director or priest and be very careful about confession.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top