Can religious order priests become bishops?

  • Thread starter Thread starter tuviskazinai
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
In current use of the term, minor orders are still laymen, not clerics. (See the code of canon law).
Yes, but that is precisely my point. At the time that those in minor clerics were appointed cardinals, they WERE clerics, and not laymen. And everyone knew them to be minor clerics; there was no pretense that they were otherwise.
It’s only been a little over a century since the last non-priest cardinal was elevated. (late 1800s.)
Perhaps, but my point was that the earlier post, with its use of the phrase " ‘honorary Cardinals’ (retired lay theologians, mostly)" was misleading. I admit that I am not sure exactly what that expression meant, but since it appeared in a sentence immediately after one that spoke of the present (“Now, however,…”), it gave the impression that there are lay cardinals today.
 
Hi -
Does anyone know whether religious order priests (i.e., non-diocesan) can be elevated to bishops and cardinals? From what I can tell, this does happen (e.g., Boston Cardinal Sean Patrick O’Malley is a Capuchin friar) – but how common is it? It seems rather rare. And how is it usually done? Do religious order superiors make recommendations to Rome just like local bishops do?
Thank you very much!
Cardinal George of the archdiocese of Chicago belongs to the order of the Oblates of Mary Immaculate (OMI), so yes, religious order priests can be elevated to bishops and cardinals.
 
Bishop Anthony Fisher of the Archdiocese of Sydney, Australia is a member of the Order of Preachers
 
Priests who belong to religious orders or religious congregations can be consecrated as bishops.

Under the old code of Canon Law they were dispensed from their vows and no longer members of their religious communities. They were allowed to use the initials of their religious communities after their names, but did not have a vote in those communities nor did they continue to be members of the community.

In the revised Canon Law of 1983 any priest who belongs to a religious order or a religious congregation remains a member of his community. For example, Cardinal Sean is still a Capuchin Friar. When he walks into his communit house he is not refered to as Cardinal, but as Brother Sean, as are all Capuchin Friars.

Bishops who are religious may continue to wear the habit of their community when not celebrating liturgy. They usually wear the pectoral cross over their habit. This is more common among friars and monks, because they have habits. Most clerical institutes do not have habits. Communities of Brothers (Monks and Friars) usually have a habit.

In addition, religious priests who become bishops may only keep the salary they receive for serving as a bishop or gifts that they receive as a bishop. When they retire, they return to their community. Any money they have they must surrender to their community, as well as any personal property that they acquire while they are bishops.

Nonetheless, the diocese must make provisions for the retirement of its bishop. A religious bishop may choose not to live with his community. He may choose to live exclaustrated (outside the cloister).

While a religious bishop remains a full member of his community, he has a vote, but may not hold any office in his community. When he rejoins his community he may not hold office, because it poses a conflict of interests. Religious communities, especially religious orders, have Pontifical Right. This means that they are exempt from the intervention of the bishops in their affairs. The only bishop who may intervene in the internal affairs of a religious order of friars or monks is the Pope.

These rules are not retroactive. They only apply to religious priests who were ordained bishops after 1983. Bishop ordained before 1983 are all secular bishops, even if they were once religious. They were secularized when they were consecrated. This is no longer the case. Therefore, if these bishops were to be elected pope, the Pope would be a religious Pope, not a secular Pope.

There are many religious bishops in the USA. The smallest group are the Franciscans, because of their internal policy to reduce the number of men that they ordain in keeping with the mind of Francis. But there are many bishops who belong to clerical congregations such as the Oblates of Mary Immaculate or the Jesuits.

Fraternally,

JR 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top