Can someone go to hell becuase no one prayed for them?

  • Thread starter Thread starter 300WhiteKnights
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think Mary spoke those words as a mother and not as an analyst. Mary could have easily said, “So many souls go to hell because they do not respond to the sufficient grace given to them.” But that is not how a mother speaks. A mother wants more help than necessary to be given to her (potential) children to be saved. So she adjures us, her children, to pray for them, as though their salvation was dependent on our prayers. In a way it is, but in a way it is not. But by speaking in a way that makes the salvation of sinners dependent on our prayers, Mary is urging us all the more to pray for them.

So I would take Mary’s words in that sense.
I may have misunderstood what you said above, but this is my response:

You said earlier, “So she adjures us, her children, to pray for them, as though their salvation was dependent on our prayers. In a way it is, but in a way it is not.” This is where I am still confused. The idea that the salvation of sinners is even “in a way” dependent on our prayers still does not rest easy in me. I understand that God has given everyone sufficient grace to respond to, but the idea of others seemingly receiving more grace than others by chance seems unfair. I just don’t understand how it is possible that there could be souls in Hell right now that could have very well been in Heaven if people had prayed for them.

By the way, I want to thank you and everyone on this forum who has been patient with me and have helped me on this subject.
 
WhiteKnights,

Maybe think of it this way:

Sufficient grace means you’ve got an invitation to the wedding. You still have to cooperate with that invitation – you have to get dressed, and walk to the Church. You can’t just watch t.v. on Saturday afternoon at home and expect the wedding to happen around you in your living room!

So, everyone is on equal footing here – everyone has that invitation. All they have to do is to do what is in their power to do, get dressed, and go to the wedding. Some people just won’t do it. They don’t make it to the wedding.

Some of THOSE people though have friends who bang on the door and shout “Get up! Time to go!” Or who carry them to the wedding. Or who find their lost invitation for them.

Some of THOSE people might even resist.

In the end, God will always have done his part, we will always have chosen our part,

VC
 
I understand that God has given everyone sufficient grace to respond to, but the idea of others seemingly receiving more grace than others by chance seems unfair.
Fairness = justice = giving someone what is due to him/her.

God does not owe anyone any favors. It is fair to give everyone sufficient grace. But if someone asks for more grace and such grace is given to him, it is not injustice to others, but God showing generosity towards that person. This is how God looks at it, as Jesus explained in the parable. This is true even if someone else prayed on behalf of that person.
I just don’t understand how it is possible that there could be souls in Hell right now that could have very well been in Heaven if people had prayed for them.
It is because they didn’t receive the extra favors that they could have received if someone had prayed for them. But that is not injustice being done to them. They have received what they deserved - sufficient grace.
 
It is because they didn’t receive the extra favors that they could have received if someone had prayed for them. But that is not injustice being done to them. They have received what they deserved - sufficient grace.
I suppose you could reword that to be “It is because they didn’t respond to sufficient grace NOR the extra favors they did receive, and they died before receiving any additional extra favors.”

At some point, an accounting happens. There are perhaps some that would be in a different state had they lived a year longer (both for good or for ill).

VC
 
“It is because they didn’t respond to sufficient grace NOR the extra favors they did receive, and they died before receiving any additional extra favors.”
VC
If this is true, then all of this makes much more sense. Then is it safe to say that there are no souls in Hell who could have been in Heaven if they had been given more grace? (i.e. prayers)
 
I think Mary spoke those words as a mother and not as an analyst. Mary could have easily said, “So many souls go to hell because they do not respond to the sufficient grace given to them.” But that is not how a mother speaks. A mother wants more help than necessary to be given to her (potential) children to be saved. **So she adjures us, her children, to pray for them, as though their salvation was dependent on our prayers. In a way it is, but in a way it is not. But by speaking in a way that makes the salvation of sinners dependent on our prayers, Mary is urging us all the more to pray for them. **

So I would take Mary’s words in that sense.
This is kind of what I was thinking and attempting to convey in my #2 post. 😉 Sometimes I’ve had trials in my life that I had trouble even knowing how to pray about so I’d ask a friend to pray for me. And then on another occasion, that friend, or another friend, would have something he or she would need me to pray for them about when he/she was at wits’ end. It seems that we “bear one another’s burdens” as it says in Scripture and that’s actually more powerful a lot of the time. :grouphug:
I may have misunderstood what you said above, but this is my response:

You said earlier, “So she adjures us, her children, to pray for them, as though their salvation was dependent on our prayers. In a way it is, but in a way it is not.” This is where I am still confused. The idea that the salvation of sinners is even “in a way” dependent on our prayers still does not rest easy in me. I understand that God has given everyone sufficient grace to respond to, but the idea of others seemingly receiving more grace than others by chance seems unfair. **I just don’t understand how it is possible that there could be souls in Hell right now that could have very well been in Heaven if people had prayed for them. **

By the way, I want to thank you and everyone on this forum who has been patient with me and have helped me on this subject.
That’s the part I struggle with too. I’m pretty sure, btw, that the original quote was indeed from Our Lady of Fatima. And I’m nowhere near qualified to answer it the way a theologian or apologist or Marian scholar might be able to. Somehow it has to fit in, though, I believe, with Mary and Jesus at the wedding feast of Cana, and her telling the servers “Do whatever He tells you.” She is trying to lead us to Jesus and she is telling us to trust in Him. This doesn’t totally answer your original question or mine, but it helps me a little . . . hopefully more will unfold from other posters or from the apologists.
 
that pretty much sums up all the main points on this thread. But im wondering… I submited this question on the AAA forum and they have not responded yet, however they seem to have answered other’s questions today. Should I re-submit this question, or wait till they respond?
 
I’d wait awhile; say, a couple of weeks - they may have a backlog, IDK:shrug:
 
According to the messages of Fatima, Mary is reported saying, **“So many souls go to Hell because no one prays for them.” **To me this seems extreamly unfair and I do not understand this at all. She seems to suggest that the salvation of an evil soul arbitrarily depends if people know him/her and pray for the person. It seems inconcieveable to me that there are people in Hell right now because NO ONE prayed for them, while there are people in Heaven right now simply because people DID pray for them.

Let me draw this out this on a diagram:

For the sake of argument lets say there are two equally evil souls on their way to hell.
Person 1 was born in China,where most people are Buddist and do not believe in God. As a result, no one prayed for this evil soul, so Person 1 never became good and went to Hell. (Im not saying Buddists are evil, Im just using a setting where no one prays to God)

Person 2 on the other hand was born in America, where there is a high Christian population. Person 2 was extreamly anti-christian and helped women preform abortions. Since Person 2 made the news quite often, he was well known and many people prayed for his soul. As a result, Person 2 turned from his ways when he died and went to heaven

Person 1
-Evil
-Not prayed for
-Not well known
-Went to Hell
Code:
       ** Person 2  **
-Evil
-Was prayed for by many people
-Was well known
-Went to Heaven

So in the end, you have two equaly evil people. But one goes to Heaven and the other goes to Hell simply because one was born into a setting where people were more prone to pray for evil souls.
Do you see my point? Please help me understand, thank you for your time
I think the proper evaluation of this quote is to note that the soul goes to hell because of its state of grace at death. Once someone dies his soul is immediately judged as saved or damned based on the state of the soul’s relationship with God at that instant.

No amount of prayer for the soul after death can change that.

What the Blessed Mother revealed, to my mind, was that the lack of prayer for live persons, living in various unsavory situations, was a failure to contribute to them while alive, thus allowing them to continue on a path to damnation as a soul after death. We shold pray for souls in Purgatory to speed their purging but we can’t pray anybody out of hell. We can, hopefull, help their soul not go to hell if we pray for them during life.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top