Can someone help me answer a question on salvation?

  • Thread starter Thread starter nekochan05
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

nekochan05

Guest
Somehow I accidentally got myself into an email debate with the president of an Evangelical website, and now he’s asked me a question that I need a little help on. We’ve been discussing salvation, and I’ve been trying to disabuse him of the notion that the Church teaches works-based salvation. I told him how salvation is by God’s grace, not good works, but that it can be lost (I didn’t touch on mortal sins yet though, it was a very short answer). So he asked me this:

“You say that salvation is by grace alone, but then you say we can lose salvation by serious sinning. So, you are saying that we have to “maintain” our salvation by not committing serious sins. Is that not works-based salvation? You are saying that we cannot keep our salvation unless we avoid serious sins. Is not avoiding serious sins a work?”

What’s the best way to answer that? I could answer it but not probably not adequately. I’m just a beginner apologist and I want to give him a good solid answer, because he does seem genuinely interested.
 
For a start you could refer him to Matthew 25 verses 31 to 46 where Jesus, who is the Judge of souls, clearly shows that His criteria for judging souls isn’t based on faith or anything else. The only criteria Jesus uses in His relating of the Last Judgement is whatever or not people lived acts of practical kindness to others…that is to say. Jesus bases salvation on our acts that are according to His commands of love. Given that He is God, Son of God, and Judge of souls, Jesus is THE expert on salvation!
 
Take the case, my brothers of someone who has never done a single good act but claims that he has faith. Will that faith save him? If one of the brothers or one of the sisters is in need of clothes and has not enough food to live on, and one of you says to them, ‘I wish you well; keep yourself warm and eat plenty’, without giving them these bare necessities of llife, then what good is that?: if good works do not go with it, it is quite dead.
This is the way to talk to people of that kind:'You say you have faith and I have good deeds; I will prove to you that I have faith by showing you my good deeds–now you prove to me that you have faith without any good deeds to show.

You believe in one God–that is creditable enough, but the demons have the same belief, and they tremble with fear. Do realize, you senseless man, that faith without works is useless. You surely know that Abraham our Father was justified by his deed, because he offered Isaac on the altar? There you see it; faith and good deeds were working together; his faith became perfect by what he did. This is what scripture really means when it says: Abraham put his faith in God, and this was counted as making him justified; and that is why he was called the friend of God. You see now that it is by doing something good, and not only by believing, that a man is justified." [James 2: 14-24]

“Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of my Father who is in heaven will enter” [Matthew 7, 21]. Faith increases as a result of our obedience to the will of God, and obedience is achieved by doing good works and trying hard not to neglect them. [2 Corinthians 10,15].
“Do not be deceived; God is not mocked, for whatever a man sows, that he will also reap. For he who sows to his own flesh will from the flesh reap corruption; but he who sows to the Spirit will from the Spirit reap eternal life. And let us not grow weary in well-doing, for in due season we shall reap, if we do not lose heart.” [Galatians 6:7-9] "Therefore, my beloved, as you have always obeyed, so now, not only as in my presence but much more in my absence, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling; for God is at work in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure. Phil 2:12-13
 
“A man had two sons, and he came to the first, and said, ‘Son, go work today in my vineyard.’ He answered, ‘I will not,’ but afterward he changed his mind, and went. He came to the second, and said the same thing. He answered, ‘I go, sir,’ but he didn’t go. Which of the two did the will of his father?” They said to him, “The first.” Matt 21:28-32

"If a virtuous man turns away from virtue and does wrong
when I place a stumbling block before him, he shall die.
He shall die for his sin,
and his virtuous deeds shall not be remembered. [Ezekiel 3:18]
 
REV.3:1-3

1 Write this to the angel of the Church in Sardis, "Thus says he who holds the seven spirits of God and the seven stars:
I know your worth: you think you live but you are dead.

2 Wake up and strengthen that which is not already dead. For I have found your works to be imperfect in the sight of my God.

3 Remember what you were taught;** keep it and change your ways. If you do not repent I will come upon you like a thief at an hour you least expect.**

Douay-Rheims translation:
1 And to the angel of the church of Sardis, write: These things saith he, that hath the seven spirits of God, and the seven stars: I know thy works, that thou hast the name of being alive: and thou art dead.

2 Be watchful and strengthen the things that remain, which are ready to die. For I find not thy works full before my God.
3 Have in mind therefore in what manner thou hast received and heard: and observe, and do penance. If then thou shalt not watch, I will come to thee as a thief, and thou shalt not know at what hour I will come to thee.
 
Grace means we share in God’s life. By grace we develop the will to follow the teachings of Jesus Christ, which leads us to work according to God’s will. I think this is called “actual” grace - grace that leads to action (another type of grace is “sanctifying” grace which is a state of being). Just as sunlight provides plants with the power to actually photosynthesize, grace provides us with the power to actually do good works.
 
Somehow I accidentally got myself into an email debate with the president of an Evangelical website, and now he’s asked me a question that I need a little help on. We’ve been discussing salvation, and I’ve been trying to disabuse him of the notion that the Church teaches works-based salvation. I told him how salvation is by God’s grace, not good works, but that it can be lost (I didn’t touch on mortal sins yet though, it was a very short answer). So he asked me this:

“You say that salvation is by grace alone, but then you say we can lose salvation by serious sinning. So, you are saying that we have to “maintain” our salvation by not committing serious sins. Is that not works-based salvation? You are saying that we cannot keep our salvation unless we avoid serious sins. Is not avoiding serious sins a work?”

What’s the best way to answer that? I could answer it but not probably not adequately. I’m just a beginner apologist and I want to give him a good solid answer, because he does seem genuinely interested.
James 2: 14-26 Faith without works is Dead. All therough the Bible we are commanded to do Good Works.

Jesus said:
Feed the Hungry
Clothed the Naked
Comfort the Sick
Visit the Jailed
Give water to those that thirst

These are all good works that we are commanded to do by our Lord - for starters.

Matthew 7:21 l"Not everyone who says to me, 'Lord,Lord, shall enter the kingdom of heaven. But he who does the will of my Father in heaven. Belief is not just a Noun. It is a Verb - something that we must do - A Work.👍
 
For a start you could refer him to Matthew 25 verses 31 to 46 where Jesus, who is the Judge of souls, clearly shows that His criteria for judging souls isn’t based on faith or anything else. The only criteria Jesus uses in His relating of the Last Judgment is whatever or not people lived acts of practical kindness to others…that is to say. Jesus bases salvation on our acts that are according to His commands of love. Given that He is God, Son of God, and Judge of souls, Jesus is THE expert on salvation!
This is a very good answer!

You might also borrow freely from my blog article Who REALLY Preaches “A Different Gospel”? and point out that Our Lord clearly tells us many times.

John 14:15 If you love me, keep my commandments.

John 5:2 In this we know that we love the children of God: when we love God, and keep his commandments.

John 15:10 If you keep my commandments, you shall abide in my love; as I also have kept my Father’s commandments, and do abide in his love.

John 14:23 Jesus answered, and said to him: If any one love me, he will keep my word, and my Father will love him, and we will come to him, and will make our abode with him.

John 14:21 He that hath my commandments, and keepeth them; he it is that loveth me. And he that loveth me, shall be loved of my Father: and I will love him, and will manifest myself to him.

1st John 2:3 And by this we know that we have known him, if we keep his commandments.

1st John 3:22 And whatsoever we shall ask, we shall receive of him: because we keep his commandments, and do those things which are pleasing in his sight.

1st John 5:3 For this is the charity of God, that we keep his commandments: and his commandments are not heavy.

Revelation 12:17 And the dragon was angry against the woman: and went to make war with the rest of her seed, who keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ.

Revelation 14:12 Here is the patience of the saints, who keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus.
 
…So he asked me this:

“You say that salvation is by grace alone, but then you say we can lose salvation by serious sinning. So, you are saying that we have to “maintain” our salvation by not committing serious sins. Is that not works-based salvation? You are saying that we cannot keep our salvation unless we avoid serious sins. Is not avoiding serious sins a work?”

What’s the best way to answer that? I could answer it but not probably not adequately. I’m just a beginner apologist and I want to give him a good solid answer, because he does seem genuinely interested.
Though I too am a beginner, I cannot resist the urge to share my thoughts and views; at the outset I declare that my views have mostly met with opposition from both fellow catholics and other christians.

In my understanding, the whole controversy of FAITH ALONE Vs FAITH+WORKS is an outcome of the following:
  1. Each group mis-reading the understanding of the other group not realising that they are actually the same
  2. Meaning attributed by each group for words like “faith” and “grace”
  3. Unawareness of non-catholics about different kinds of merit.
  4. Treatment of “salvation” as an event by Calvinists while Catholics treat it as a process
It is possible to have a convergence of beliefs by trying to understand the basis of the two different beliefs: FAITH ALONE & FAITH+WORKS.

Recall Romans 4:1-8 *Abraham Justified by Faith
What then shall we say that Abraham, our forefather according to the flesh, discovered in this matter? If, in fact, Abraham was justified by works, he had something to boast about—but not before God. What does Scripture say? “Abraham believed God, and it was credited to him as righteousness.” Now to the one who works, wages are not credited as a gift but as an obligation. However, to the one who does not work but trusts God who justifies the ungodly, their faith is credited as righteousness. David says the same thing when he speaks of the blessedness of the one to whom God credits righteousness apart from works: “Blessed are those whose transgressions are forgiven, whose sins are covered. Blessed is the one whose sin the Lord will never count against them.”
*

The catholic understanding is this: Abraham, David, Paul or for that matter every believer is helpless on his/her own to overcome the flesh. He/she is saved only by surrender to God/Christ, by putting all their faith in Him.

The non-catholic (calvin etc) view is no different: By our own effort (works) we cannot save ourselves. But faith in God/Christ saves us. Every good work is accomplished through faith and surrender to God’s will and NOT by an individual’s own will power
 
Hey nekochan,
Here are my thoughts on this topic.
  1. Catholics do not believe that our good works provide the merit to earn heaven. Only Jesus can merit heaven on our behalf. It is his sacrifice that pardons our sins and allows us to gain heaven.
  2. The merits of Jesus’ sacrifice are not automatically applied to every human being whether they want them or not. In other words, salvation is a gift that Jesus offers, and each of us is free to accept or reject this gift.
  3. Doing good works is a way for us to say “yes” to the gift of salvation that Jesus offers. Likewise, failure to do good works can be a way of saying “no.”
  4. Objectively speaking, what Catholics and certain Protestants are actually debating over is which works are important. To show you what I mean, I suggest that you ask this person on the Evangelical website the following question: “How does a person end up in heaven?” His answer will invariably involve something that a person is supposed to do. For example, here are some common responses one gets in these cases:
Example 1: “A person ends up in heaven by first trusting in the promises of the Gospel.” But notice that the person has the choice to either trust or not trust. Trusting leads to heaven, and lack of trust leads to hell. Therefore, trusting is the “work” that is needed for salvation.

Example 2: “Say the Sinner’s Prayer.” But, here again, a person has the choice to either say this prayer or not. In this case, saying the Sinner’s Prayer is the “work” that is needed for salvation.

Example 3: “Accept Jesus as your personal Lord and Savior.” Once again, a person has the choice to either accept Jesus in this manner or not. Therefore, acceptance of Jesus is the “work” that is needed for salvation.

Unless the Evangelical you are dialoging with believes that everyone automatically goes to heaven whether they want to or not, then he has to admit that someone has to do something in order to end up in heaven. In other words, Jesus provides the grace and the power, but we still have our part to play in the spiritual journey.

Once it is established that we have to do some form of work to say “yes” to the gift of salvation, the question remains exactly what are we supposed to do? Recite the Sinner’s Prayer? Accept Jesus as our personal Lord and Savior? Although I think that repentance and acceptance of Jesus are essential aspects of a spiritual journey, I think it is also important for all Christians to turn to what the Bible actually says we are supposed to do:

(And below some of the Bible passages I will quote will be repeats of what others have posted, but they bear repeating for the sake of the point I am making)

Matthew 25:32-46
This is the Parable of the Sheep and the Goats. Doing works of charity counts as acceptance of Christ and puts a person on the path to heaven. Failure to do works of charity counts as denial of Christ and puts a person on the path to hell. Keep in mind that, according to this parable, the only difference between the sheep and the goats is what they did and did not do.

James 1:22-23
"Be doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving yourselves. For if any one is a hearer of the word and not a doer, he is like a man who observes his natural face in a mirror; for he observes himself and goes away and at once forgets what he was like. But he who looks into the perfect law, the law of liberty, and perseveres, being no hearer that forgets but a doer that acts, he shall be blessed in his doing.

James 2:14 & 24
“So faith by itself, if it has no works, is dead.”
“…a man is justified by works and not by faith alone.”
(The context of this statements is the importance of doing works of charity).

1John 3:17-18
“But if any one has the world’s goods and sees his brother in need, yet closes his heart against him, how does God’s love abide in him? Little children, let us not love in word or speech but in deed and truth.”

Romans 2:6 & 13
“For he will render to every man according to his works.”
“For it is not the hearers of the law who are righteous before God, but the doers of the law who will be justified.”

2Corinthians 5:10
“For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ, so that each one may receive good or evil, according to what he has done in the body.”

Is believing in Jesus an important aspect of salvation? I think we would all agree that it is. But according to Jesus, what is involved in believing in him?
“Truly, truly, I say to you, he who believes in me will also do the works that I do…” (John 14:12)

And what about loving Jesus? Naturally, that is important also. But what does Jesus say that loving him entails?
“If you love me, you will keep my commandments.” (John 14:15)

“If you keep my commandments, you will abide in my love…” (John 15:10)

Obviously we have a choice to either keep Jesus commandments or not. Keeping Jesus’ commandments includes doing good works, especially in terms of his commandment to love one another (because throughout the gospels he expressed that loving our neighbor means being in loving service to others).
 
How about these verses (Ephesians 5:5-6)?:

For of this you can be sure: No immoral, impure or greedy person—such a man is an idolater—has any inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and of God. Let no one deceive you with empty words [eg. OSAS], for because of such things God’s wrath comes on those who are disobedient. (NIV)
 
WOW, thank you all so much! This is incredibly helpful. I used each of your answers and sort of summarized them in a way I really hope he understands–we’ll see! Thanks again!
 
  1. Each group mis-reading the understanding of the other group not realising that they are actually the same
Yes…, at first glance it seems to be the case. I live amongst a lot of Dutch Reformed people in my village and the difference in South Africa is as follows:

Durch Reformed (protestant) believe that as a means of salvation, we erroniously cling to the Law of Moses = works, by their understanding this is a totally different concept from good works.

Faith alone to their understanding = once saved always saved - and quote the verse which says “nothing can separate us from Christ/God, not heaven … etc”. However Christ said in
Luke 20:35
But they that shall be accounted worthy of that world, and of the resurrection from the dead, shall neither be married, nor take wives.
Although this subject is about the 7 brothers and the one wife Jesus says:

REPEAT: But they that shall be accounted worthy of that world, and of the resurrection from the dead

Conclusion: there is gaping gap between what they believe and Catholics believe. 🙂
 
Somehow I accidentally got myself into an email debate with the president of an Evangelical website, and now he’s asked me a question that I need a little help on. We’ve been discussing salvation, and I’ve been trying to disabuse him of the notion that the Church teaches works-based salvation. I told him how salvation is by God’s grace, not good works, but that it can be lost (I didn’t touch on mortal sins yet though, it was a very short answer). So he asked me this:

“You say that salvation is by grace alone, but then you say we can lose salvation by serious sinning. So, you are saying that we have to “maintain” our salvation by not committing serious sins. Is that not works-based salvation? You are saying that we cannot keep our salvation unless we avoid serious sins. Is not avoiding serious sins a work?”

What’s the best way to answer that? I could answer it but not probably not adequately. I’m just a beginner apologist and I want to give him a good solid answer, because he does seem genuinely interested.
 
Somehow I accidentally got myself into an email debate with the president of an Evangelical website, and now he’s asked me a question that I need a little help on. We’ve been discussing salvation, and I’ve been trying to disabuse him of the notion that the Church teaches works-based salvation. I told him how salvation is by God’s grace, not good works, but that it can be lost (I didn’t touch on mortal sins yet though, it was a very short answer). So he asked me this:

“You say that salvation is by grace alone, but then you say we can lose salvation by serious sinning. So, you are saying that we have to “maintain” our salvation by not committing serious sins. Is that not works-based salvation? You are saying that we cannot keep our salvation unless we avoid serious sins. Is not avoiding serious sins a work?”

What’s the best way to answer that? I could answer it but not probably not adequately. I’m just a beginner apologist and I want to give him a good solid answer, because he does seem genuinely interested.
I’ve never been one for reinventing the wheel. IF someone else already said it great, I don’t see why I need to re-explain it.

Are you aware of Evangelicals and Catholics Together? Many prominent evangelical leaders and pastors along with priests and bishops were on this committee.
THey came out with a joint statement, discussing where we agree and disagree.
Let’s at least be honest about what we disagree about.

Here is the joint statement on salvation:
leaderu.com/ftissues/ft9801/articles/gift.html
Hope it helps.
 
Sorry, something got lost in my posting.
So he asked me this:

“You say that salvation is by grace alone, but then you say we can lose salvation by serious sinning. So, you are saying that we have to “maintain” our salvation by not committing serious sins. Is that not works-based salvation? You are saying that we cannot keep our salvation unless we avoid serious sins. Is not avoiding serious sins a work?”
I applaud that you’re keeping the topic to “grace alone” and not accidentally shading off into “faith alone.” The latter is manifestly a loser for Catholics in this life arguing with its proponents, and I fear a loser for many on the Last Day when the manifest falsehood of it becomes manifest to those who had steadfastly maintained it.

Anyway, I take it then that Paul was writing to no purpose when he encouraged the Philippians (and all of us) to “work out your salvation (works) with fear and trembling; for it is God who is at work in you (grace), both to will and to work for His good pleasure”? What is he exhorting us to do, if there is nothing we have to do? See how God’s grace REQUIRES our works?!

Yes, we can LOSE the saving grace of baptism. Your nameless interlocutor must surely believe this too. Else, how can it be said that “if you do not eat the flesh of the Son of Man, and drink His blood, you have no life (eternal life, that is, grace) in you”?

So even those who have been born again by WATER and the Holy Spirit (in baptism, obviously, although your email companion most likely does not see that as obvious) have no life in them if they do not eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink His blood. By which is meant something that is done often enough that it can be said to be a characteristic of one’s life.

But, of course, the one who has been born again by water and the Holy Spirit is condemned if he eats and drinks unworthily, without having examined himself (1 Cor 11). The examination has two parts: it directly states that one needs to be sure that one believes (by faith) that this truly is the Body and Blood of the Lord, and given the context of this instruction, also one’s recent moral life must be “good”.

Possible objections:
  1. “God at work in you” does not mean “grace”. My own response? Holy s***, what DOES it mean, then?
    God gives us grace so that we will live holy lives. If we do not live the holy lives to which God’s grace moves us, we have indeed rejected God’s grace. There is no one who can snatch us out of God’s hand. That doesn’t necessarily mean that we can’t jump out on our own.
  2. Is it possible that a “Bible” Christian could object that the “life” that we don’t have if don’t eat and drink is NOT eternal life, ie, salvation? That it’s something else? I guess I’d wait to hear this objection raised before trying to come up with an answer.
  3. “Born again” does not refer to baptism. Unfortunately, it’s “born again of WATER and the Holy Spirit.” Of course it refers to baptism. Besides, what else could it mean? Baptism turns up too often in the New Testament as the way one becomes a Christian for “born again” to mean anything else.
  4. How often does one have to “eat and drink” for it to count? I wouldn’t get bogged down with that; if he’s walked with you this far, you’ve won. Besides, Scripture doesn’t say, so who could say? He can decide for himself, or he can follow the Church if he wants.
  5. Don’t agree that both faith (recognizing the Body and Blood of the Lord) and a moral life are required to receive worthily according to 1 Corinthians 11? That could be a bit more of a tough sell, except that if you’ve gotten him this far, he’ll find that the only Christians who agree are the Catholics and the Orthodox. So you’ve won.
    Not that they’re the “only” Christians. That’s 90% of Christianity.
 
Somehow I accidentally got myself into an email debate with the president of an Evangelical website, and now he’s asked me a question that I need a little help on. We’ve been discussing salvation, and I’ve been trying to disabuse him of the notion that the Church teaches works-based salvation. I told him how salvation is by God’s grace, not good works, but that it can be lost (I didn’t touch on mortal sins yet though, it was a very short answer). So he asked me this:

“You say that salvation is by grace alone, but then you say we can lose salvation by serious sinning. So, you are saying that we have to “maintain” our salvation by not committing serious sins. Is that not works-based salvation? You are saying that we cannot keep our salvation unless we avoid serious sins. Is not avoiding serious sins a work?”

What’s the best way to answer that? I could answer it but not probably not adequately. I’m just a beginner apologist and I want to give him a good solid answer, because he does seem genuinely interested.
The Church teaches that man cannot be saved without God (without grace), but that He still won’t save us without us-without our wills/cooperation being involved. He pulls us from the pit, IOWs, but doesn’t prevent us from falling back in if we so desire. Justification is a process whereby we’re molded by the Potter into the beings He’s always intended us to be, rather than remaining outside His will and being saved for some reason anyway. Faith is the beginning of this process. But His purpose is to help us-to draw us without coercion- into being one in will with Him-as opposed to our first parents rebellion against Him, the Original Sin which is the source of mans separation from God to begin with.
 
To the OP… Keep us informed! I’m interested to see how this turns out!
 
You might point out to your counterpart that faith and obedience are closely related in Judaism. In the Greek NT the following definitions are very helpful. The verse John 3:36 says a great deal about faith and obedience for salvation. The verse reads as follows:

“He who believes[pisteuo] in the Son has eternal life; he who does not obey[apeitheo the Son shall not see life, but the wrath of God rests upon him.”

Strong’s Number: 4100
Transliterated: pisteuo
Phonetic: pist-yoo’-o

Text: from 4102; to have faith (in, upon, or with respect to, a person or thing), i.e. credit; by implication, to entrust (especially one’s spiritual well-being to Christ): --believe(-r), commit (to trust), put in trust with.

Strong’s Number: 544
Transliterated: apeitheo
Phonetic: ap-i-theh’-o

Text: from 545; to disbelieve (wilfully and perversely): --not believe, disobedient, obey not, unbelieving.

Faith is a work and faith includes obedience which is a work. Likewise, love is a work. Ask your friend if he believes that a person is saved that has **no love for God.
If he acknowledges any of these things then “faith alone” is shot down as well as OSAS.
If anyone claims that it is not necessary to love God for salvation, then simply use a concordance for the NT on the word “love” and you will find many passages to refute their thinking.

If he denies that a dimension of faith is as a work, then simply show him where scripture says otherwise in: John 6:29, 1 Thess 1:3, and Revelation 2:19.

None of this adds to or in any way diminishes the work of Christ. Instead, these things are part of the outcome of the work of Christ within us. Without God’s grace and the passion, death, and resurrection of the Lord everything else is meaningless.

God bless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top