Can someone not be responsible for their sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Love6493
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Love6493

Guest
When are we not held responsible for our sins? I know from reading that if someone is possessed by demons, they are not responsible for the sin that they commit while possessed. Is there any other circumstance that would make a person not responsible for their sin?
 
Last edited:
Well you see, for a sin to be a sin it must be committed with the knowledge of it being an offence against God and His Church, natural order, and our faith. Venial sins are committed with knowledge, but a mortal sin is far greater in that we must be fully aware that we are committing a grave, immoral, deprived, and seditious act against God’s framework and commandments. We must wilfully consent to a sin, indeed a mortal sin, and be aware of the consequences.

If someone (or something) else is in control of us, our culpability is either relinquished or completely free.
 
In order for one to be culpable of sin, the person must know it is sinful and do it on purpose.
 
Maybe this is a poor example, but blizzard-like weather can be the “controlling factor” in keeping us from attending mass. It’s out of our control, so it wouldn’t be a sin.
 
That’s a fine example. It’s death vs. life, really. My old headmaster’s mother was killed walking to the Church for a choir meeting during a blizzard. She couldn’t see the car coming up the road and decided to cross, and was struck.
 
I can think of an example: having a mental disorder, like schizophrenia.

A legal analogy would being found not guilty for a crime committed due to mental illness. A person might have committed the act, but a sufficient mental handicap can mitigate the blame.
 
In the Old Testament threre are many examples of objective sins. The Patriarchs often married several women, yet this is not considered sinful because God had not revealed the full Truth of the sanctity of marriage yet. Or rather, it was sinful and evil in the eyes of God, but no one were to blame for this evil, so it’s not even considered a venial sin.
 
Maybe this is a poor example, but blizzard-like weather can be the “controlling factor” in keeping us from attending mass. It’s out of our control, so it wouldn’t be a sin.
Not so good an example because that would not be a sin at all because in such a situation the obligation is dispensed of.
In the case of being mentally incapable or coerced to commit a sin you have actually committed the sin but culpability would be reduced.
 
I think that could depend on the kind of coercion and it severity or result of said sinful action(s).
 
CULPABILITY = The word you are looking for. It is used by Priests in the faith to help determine whether the act was entirely of their will or not.
 
Three conditions are necessary for mortal sin to exist:
  • Grave Matter: The act itself is intrinsically evil and immoral. …
  • Full Knowledge: The person must know that what they’re doing or planning to do is evil and immoral. …
  • Deliberate Consent: The person must freely choose to commit the act or plan to do it.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top