Merit
In the
Bull “Exurge Domine”
Leo X condemns the proposition (n. 38) “Nec probatum est ullis aut rationibus aut scripturis ipsas esse extra statum merendi aut augendae caritatis” (There is no
proof from
reason or
Scripture that they [the
souls in purgatory] cannot
merit or increase in charity). For them “the night has come in which no man can labour”, and
Christian tradition has always considered that only in this life can
man work unto the profit of his own
soul. The Doctors of the
Middle Ages while agreeing that this life is the
time for
merit and increase of grace, still some with
St. Thomas seemed to question whether or not there might be some non-essential reward which the
souls in purgatory might
merit (IV, dist. xxi, q. i, a. 3).
Bellarmine believes that in this matter
St. Thomas changed his opinion and refers to a statement of
St. Thomas (“De Malo”, q. vii, a. 11). Whatever may be the
mind of the
Angelic Doctor,
theologians agree that no
merit is possible in purgatory, and if objection be urged that the
soulsthere
merit by their
prayers,
Bellarmine says that such
prayers avail with
God because of
merit already acquired “Solum impetrant ex meritis praeteritis quomodo nunc sancti orando) pro nobis impetrant licet non merendo” (They avail only in virtue of past
merits as those who are now
saints intercede for us not by
merit but by
prayer). (loc. cit. II, cap. iii).