Can This Be True?

  • Thread starter Thread starter AngryAtheist8
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I hope you’re right.
Because the other posters seem to imply that even things like chattiness and being too happy are sins. Which seems very Gnostic and ugly to me.

Of course it doesn’t concern me that much. Since I am not believer (or even a nominal Catholic). Nevertheless the idea that one of the world’s major religions regards happiness and talkativeness as sins to be actively discouraged is somewhat troubling:shrug:

This Daughters of Gluttony thing also buys into the stereotype that the more holy a person is, the more grim they are and unpleasant to be around.
Whose stereotype! Not one that we accept! If you had read our posts, including mine with its’ examination of the meanings of the words, you would have learned your interpretation is far from the truth!
You may wish to think the worst of us, but that gives no credence whatsoever to your gloomy view of us! 😃

AS St Teresa of Avila/Jesus said, “Spare us from sour faced nuns and gloomy saints!” Saints and genuine Christians have peace and joy in their hearts even in the face of awful suffering!!!
 
oh did I, I’m sorry,

certaintly living a sinful life is no fun at all.

I said that-prude, as sometimes I get the impression reading some of the posts that everything is sinful, and even in some Catholic literature,

Seems to be more sins in the Catholic faith than one can shake a stick at.

all of this is my opinion of course.🙂
Indeed.

I have often thought that it would be much easier to list the things that ARE NOT sins in Catholicism than the things that are (the list of not-sins would certainly be much shorter;)).
 
If you read all the posts responding to the atheistic original poster, you will see that we all agree! Including 1ke.

**Only the original poster was tersely sticking to his guns even though we had proved the case for joy! **And shown how the saints claims and the OP, AngryAtheist8’s, interpretation of it was incorrect.
Not really:shrug:

If the thing about Daughters of Gluttony IS an official Church teaching then the Church is clearly against people enjoying themselves and relaxing in general.
 
That is a gloomy opinion. Yes some very scrupulous people come to these forums. Many of us live in love of God and in trust in God, therefore we have fewer questions that appear in these forums. I like many have never asked a question here, only either asked prayer for people or answered their questions or sought to encourage and enlighten,
but like many of us have never asked in fear, is this a sin, is that a sin.

Of course those with the questions are more vocal about their worries and therefore the anxiety shows out of correct proportion in these forums. Many of us go forward in hope, in trust, in joy, and also don’t get caught by the anxiety of sin because sin has far less hold over those who live from hope, love, and knowledge of Church teaching and the Bible. The addictions etc simply don’t take hold where people live in joy, love, trust, and hope. So such people don’t come to the attention of those seeking our Catholic shortcomings! Of course we all do wrong, and do our best to become better Christians, better Catholics, but we are most definitely not gloomy, negative people, most of us!

And gluttony is not just enjoying food, it’s eating beyond reason. It certainly is not a beneficial thing to health and well-being.
We can enjoy food, enjoy nice things, without over-doing it.
Gluttony can lead to illness and disease. It’s something one regrets. Excess, which is what the so-called daughters are based on, can cause regret, discomfort, unnecessary expense and health or other problems.

Enjoyable eating doesn’t lead to those things. We can thoroughly enjoy something, at the time, and without later ill-effects if we enjoy them with at least some degree of moderation!!!

Someone with verbal diarrhoea leads to people wishing to escape the person, and rather than building relationship as inter-discussion can, causes a person annoyance and a wish to escape the person who never stops talking. Such a person cannot listen.

So how are such things good?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top