Can those who leave the Church for Anglicanism go to heaven?

  • Thread starter Thread starter LoyalViews
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don’t know of any stipulation made by our Saviour Jesus Christ, that apostolic succession dictates who can go to Heaven and who can’t.

Tradition is another matter entirely, of course.
 
If a person knowing the truth of the Church left it, he would be gravely guilty of a sin against faith (or, if it’s purely schismatical sect, against charity and obedience).

I hope this was helpful,
Benedicat Deus,
Latinitas
While my answer to the OP would be yes of course I have faith that those who leave for Anglicanism or TEC can go to heaven… as why would I or anyone, mere human beings, even begin to place limitations on the loving mercy of an infinite God…

Your answer nonetheless is one that I’ve found is often given by Catholics and is one that frankly will likely leave me scratching my head til the end of time.

What if a person has been properly catechized and knows what the Catholic Church teaches, knows Her interpretations and reasoning, and knows the Church believes it holds the truth…

But nonetheless the person simply still does not share the same faith or does not have faith in the Catholic Church or as they mature and grow in age, come to new understandings and no longer have faith in the Catholic Church or in it’s teaching authority… and they leave for a Christian home where their faith is better fed elsewhere?

So you are saying they follow their faith, but at the same time are gravely guilty of a sin against faith?
 
do any of you who posted see how offensive the thread topic is-?
Yes absolutely I do. All any of us can do is to seek God’s mercy no matter where it is we find our Creator. God’s blessings in your faith walk within TEC. Peace.
 
do any of you who posted see how offensive the thread topic is-?
Of course, but many questions and opinions could be taken as offensive, when really it is not necessary. I see it as a question asked in good faith and answered it as such.

I think we have to accept the possibility of this sort of thing, if we are to have discourse between denominations, it is an unavoidable thing.
 
do any of you who posted see how offensive the thread topic is-?
You have understand that I’m asking if in the eyes of the Church, can Anglicans go to heaven. I have been told by an Anglican priest, a friend of my father, that I was going straight to Hell for practising “popish” devotions. On another occasion at my uncle’s funeral, the Priest on the altar said “all who believe in Christ can come to Holy Communion except those under the devillish Roman mantle”, and I can’t be told it wasn’t an intentional comment because he well knew that my uncle’s family were Catholics.

I wasn’t offended, it’s only a comment from one person. It weighs nothing on my shoulders. The ground didn’t fall out from beneath me. I’m alive, I’m here, well and good. I apologise with my heart and soul for having phrase my question like that and I ask forgiveness; in Christian charity that isn’t the intent of my post. It’s a theological discussion, particularly in relation to the doctrine of Extra Ecclesiam Nulla Salus, and a personal discovery and attempt to see what the popular opinion is of where is Christ’s Church, and what are its boundaries.

Now, personally, I believe the Anglican Communion to certainly be within those boundaries of Christ’s Church, and I have witnessed it first hand. My great grandfathers were both priests ordained in the Church of England and Church of Ireland respectively, and I learnt a great deal from them growing up on how to love God and even my Catholic mother and father taught me to have a great respect for Anglican practise and belief, but my mind is allowed to wander and human nature is to ask questions.
 
You have understand that I’m asking if in the eyes of the Church, can Anglicans go to heaven. I have been told by an Anglican priest, a friend of my father, that I was going straight to Hell for practising “popish” devotions. On another occasion at my uncle’s funeral, the Priest on the altar said “all who believe in Christ can come to Holy Communion except those under the devillish Roman mantle”, and I can’t be told it wasn’t an intentional comment because he well knew that my uncle’s family were Catholics.

I wasn’t offended, it’s only a comment from one person. It weighs nothing on my shoulders. The ground didn’t fall out from beneath me. I’m alive, I’m here, well and good. I apologise with my heart and soul for having phrase my question like that and I ask forgiveness; in Christian charity that isn’t the intent of my post. It’s a theological discussion, particularly in relation to the doctrine of Extra Ecclesiam Nulla Salus, and a personal discovery and attempt to see what the popular opinion is of where is Christ’s Church, and what are its boundaries.

Now, personally, I believe the Anglican Communion to certainly be within those boundaries of Christ’s Church, and I have witnessed it first hand. My great grandfathers were both priests ordained in the Church of England and Church of Ireland respectively, and I learnt a great deal from them growing up on how to love God and even my Catholic mother and father taught me to have a great respect for Anglican practise and belief, but my mind is allowed to wander and human nature is to ask questions.
The examples you give in your first paragraph are horrible. I know Anglicans are of a variety of belief and practice that can only be described as motley, but those examples sound out of order even for Anglicans.

Your question seemed fair enough to me.
 
The examples you give in your first paragraph are horrible. I know Anglicans are of a variety of belief and practice that can only be described as motley, but those examples sound out of order even for Anglicans.

Your question seemed fair enough to me.
I can assure you that those two priests were the only Anglicans of any type that I’ve ever heard of passing remarks against the Church. They were ancient when they did, and I can only assume it was an “old fashioned, learned” hatred of sorts that existed in that generation amongst a certain class at a certain college. Something like that. My great-grandfathers were of the same generation however more in the line of Percy Dearmer, but married Catholics so obviously didn’t carry the prejudice 😛
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top