Can we make the sign of the cross over food?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Kronk
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

Kronk

Guest
I was wondering if we are able to make the sign of the cross over food if we aren’t priests? Like how they do during the mass before the transubstantiation occurs?

I recall a story of St Benedict blessing wine and the chalice breaking due to it being poison, but I don’t think St Benedict was a priest so I am a bit confused as to who can do this.

Are we able to make the sign of the cross over food before we eat, and if so or if not, why?

Many thanks
 
Last edited:
We should say grace and ask the Lord to bless our food. We can make the sign of the Cross during this prayer.
 
We should say grace and ask the Lord to bless our food. We can make the sign of the Cross during this prayer.
I think the gist of the OP’s question is whether making the SOTC over the food is akin to “blessing it”, and whether blessing someone or something (as opposed to blessing oneself) is a thing that should only be done by a priest or deacon. OP, am I understanding you correctly? We can certainly ask Our Lord to bless the food, but that is not the same thing as making the SOTC over the food as though we are the one doing the blessing.
 
I was wondering if we are able to make the sign of the cross over food if we aren’t priests? Like how they do during the mass before the transubstantiation occurs?

I recall a story of St Benedict blessing wine and the chalice breaking due to it being poison, but I don’t think St Benedict was a priest so I am a bit confused as to who can do this.

Are we able to make the sign of the cross over food before we eat, and if so or if not, why?

Many thanks
No, unless you are a deacon.

Laypeople make the sign of the cross on themselves, even when saying the blessing over food.
 
Yes, the basic gist is if we’re allowed to do it, I do see it as more of a blessing it than asking God to bless it as I think about it more, so I’m leaning on no since that’s a priest thing, not something we can do. Perhaps as an addition, why St Benedict did so if he indeed was not a priest (I’m not well read enough on his life yet)?
 
Last edited:
Unless you are a deacon or priest, signing over your food is meaningless … as lay people we are supposed to say a prayer to our Lord thanking Him for the food and then we cross ourselves.
 
I gathered that laypeople traditionally asked God to bless (may God bless you…) by making the sign of the cross in the air with their thumb rather than their whole hand.
Where did you “gather” this from? I’ve never heard of that.

I would say it’s not advisable to mimic the gestures proper to the clergy. It’s certainly not allowed in the liturgy, as per the GIRM, and I think that “blessing” things after the manner of a cleric is problematic. I knew of a few younger seminarians who would “practice” blessing things at meals, only to be gently corrected by the more senior men, since that was something proper to the ordained.

-Fr ACEGC
 
Yes, the basic gist is if we’re allowed to do it, I do see it as more of a blessing it than asking God to bless it as I think about it more, so I’m leaning on no since that’s a priest thing, not something we can do. Perhaps as an addition, why St Benedict did so if he indeed was not a priest (I’m not well read enough on his life yet)?
Was St Benedict an abbot, and can there be such a thing as an abbot who is not a priest? Abbesses in convents, the female equivalent of an abbot, are clearly never priests. Do abbots and abbesses have the authority to bless people and things? Just guessing, I would think yes, because they have many aspects of authority over and above what a regular layperson or even priest would have. They are in a sense the “bishop” of their abbey.
 
Where did you “gather” this from? I’ve never heard of that.

I would say it’s not advisable to mimic the gestures proper to the clergy. It’s certainly not allowed in the liturgy, as per the GIRM, and I think that “blessing” things after the manner of a cleric is problematic. I knew of a few younger seminarians who would “practice” blessing things at meals, only to be gently corrected by the more senior men, since that was something proper to the ordained.

-Fr ACEGC
Hello Father:

I read this on a Catholic Answers tract:

START

In the name of the Father
and of the Son
and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.


What is the sign of the cross, and why do we make it?

Not all prayers are made with words. Prayers may also be made by gestures. Christians, like followers of all other religions, practically always pray by the position of the body—say, kneeling or standing—and of the arms and hands—for example, praying with hands outstretched or folded in front. Because we are both body and soul (a human being is not one or the other; a human being is both! We are not angels or simply spirits), we pray with both.

Now, all religions have gestures that express a devout attitude before the divine or heavenly beings they invoke, but the gesture that is most expressly Christian, and used only by Christians, is the sign of the cross. By making it, we profess the central truths of our faith: that God became one of us, with a human body and soul; that he died on the cross to save us; and that our own bodies and souls share in the same power of the Savior whereby we are freed from sin and death and brought to the resurrection and the life of heaven.

From the earliest times Christians have made the sign of the cross. St. Basil the Great tells us that the apostles themselves taught the sign of the cross. This is shown by the fact that the earliest mentions of the sign of the cross speak of it as an already established custom and simply encourage the faithful to make it correctly.

The sign of the cross was made simply with the fingers (the index or the thumb) on the forehead or lips or breast (as Latin-rite Catholics do at the beginning of the Gospel lesson) or with the whole hand over the torso. There are slight differences in how it is made between the various rites of the Church, but they are all legitimate. Those who are in holy orders bless by making the sign of the cross in the air toward the persons or things to be blessed, but layfolk bless others only by using their finger, usually the thumb. This “lay blessing” is common in Catholic cultures, made by parents on their children before bed or before going out or on a trip. It would be great if this custom could be revived.



END

I read the part in bold as being that laypeople could ask God to bless people/things by using their thumb.

I have probably misinterpreted it. I stand corrected.

Here is link to the tract: Sign of the Cross | Catholic Answers.

Sincerely Yours in Christ.
 
Last edited:
The sign of the cross was made simply with the fingers (the index or the thumb) on the forehead or lips or breast (as Latin-rite Catholics do at the beginning of the Gospel lesson) or with the whole hand over the torso. There are slight differences in how it is made between the various rites of the Church, but they are all legitimate. Those who are in holy orders bless by making the sign of the cross in the air toward the persons or things to be blessed, but layfolk bless others only by using their finger, usually the thumb. This “lay blessing” is common in Catholic cultures, made by parents on their children before bed or before going out or on a trip. It would be great if this custom could be revived.



END

I read the part in bold as being that laypeople could ask God to bless people/things by using their thumb.

I have probably misinterpreted it.

Here’s link to the tract: Sign of the Cross | Catholic Answers.

Sincerely Yours in Christ.
The key phrase is “but layfolk bless OTHERS ONLY by using their finger…”

This custom typically used by parents / grandparents / Godparents to bless their children / grandchildren / Godchildren

It is not used to bless things.
 
Last edited:
The key phrase is “but layfolk bless OTHERS only by using their finger”

This custom typically used by parents / grandparents / Godparents to bless their children / grandchildren / Godchildren

It is not used to bless things.
Thank you. You are right. My mistake, and God Bless.
 
Where did you “gather” this from? I’ve never heard of that.

I would say it’s not advisable to mimic the gestures proper to the clergy. It’s certainly not allowed in the liturgy, as per the GIRM, and I think that “blessing” things after the manner of a cleric is problematic. I knew of a few younger seminarians who would “practice” blessing things at meals, only to be gently corrected by the more senior men, since that was something proper to the ordained.

-Fr ACEGC
Just out of interest, Reverend Father, are lay people allowed to ask God to bless people by making the sign of the cross in the air with their thumb?

Thank you for your answer, I very much appreciate your presence here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top