Scruples over whether to watch a story in which a priest character is insulted might fairly lead one to ask: what human beings* may *be safely insulted without a scruple?
Hard truths can be treated in the movies without undue insult. Comedy can be at the expense of a fictional character or at the expense of the foibles of real people without denigrating anyone’s basic human dignity. There is such a thing as taking onesself way too seriously, even for one’s own good. There is such a thing as building plaster saints to hide real sinners who wrongly desire the cloak of darkness, as well. Heaven forbid that our reverence for the priesthood give priests a place to hide a guilt that deserves the cleansing of light!
So when you decided what is acceptable for you to watch in a movie, ask yourself this: Can this piece entertain me or provoke the intended thoughts without hardening my heart? If the truth is difficult, is it a truth that can be safely left hidden? Is the piece a comedy, a fair challenge, or is it just plain cruelty at someone else’s expense?
I believe that’s a better litmus test, and I think most priests would say so, too.