Can we watch movies where a priest character is insulted?

  • Thread starter Thread starter fakename
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

fakename

Guest
Can we watch a movie where a priest character is insulted?

Can we watch one where the insult is just part of a bigger story of redemption?
 
Can we watch a movie where a priest character is insulted?

Can we watch one where the insult is just part of a bigger story of redemption?
That depends on the insult and the character of said priest.

Just because a person’s a priest doesn’t mean they’re automatically free from scrutiny.
 
Can we watch a movie where a priest character is insulted?

Can we watch one where the insult is just part of a bigger story of redemption?
Apart from pornography we can watch whatever movies we want.
However, it would be foolish for those weak in faith to watch movies that might sway them for one reason or another.
 
However, it would be foolish for those weak in faith to watch movies that might sway them for one reason or another.
If someone’s faith can be swayed simply by watching a film then said person should seriously reconsider their religious beliefs.
 
Where priests are insulted. Which multitude of these kinds of movies do you refer to?
Anything which is holy is treated as stupid.
 
Where priests are insulted. Which multitude of these kinds of movies do you refer to?
Anything which is holy is treated as stupid.
Well I’ve been taught to always respect the priestly office, so I’m just guessing I should never tolerate the mistreatment of priests even fictionally. As such, it doesn’t matter what movie I refer to; but If you need one, imagine a hypothetical movie x, wherein a priest is insulted. Should I watch it?
 
Way not enough information. An insult can be againtst the Priest’s person, where he shows that he is the bigger man and responds with love. The insult can also be against his office, which is very different.

Without the specifics, it’s not possible to say.
 
Well I’ve been taught to always respect the priestly office, so I’m just guessing I should never tolerate the mistreatment of priests even fictionally.
The priestly office is hardly a shield against criticism. That sort of attitude is what complicated the sex abuse issue and I certainly won’t be one of those apologizing for it in that regard.
 
The priestly office is hardly a shield against criticism. That sort of attitude is what complicated the sex abuse issue and I certainly won’t be one of those apologizing for it in that regard.
Correct. Had there been more scrutiny on the part of the Church hierarchy – in its entirety – the Church would not have found itself in a situation where it can be derided and insulted. It’s time to face the music with humility, penitence and an awareness that everything can’t always be swept under the carpet as it always used to be before.
 
If someone’s faith can be swayed simply by watching a film then said person should seriously reconsider their religious beliefs.
I agree. I watched so-called Christians being interviewed after watching The Da Vinci Code and many of them thought it might be true. Weak in faith people should steer clear of such movies.
 
Way not enough information. An insult can be againtst the Priest’s person, where he shows that he is the bigger man and responds with love. The insult can also be against his office, which is very different.

Without the specifics, it’s not possible to say.
It was probably insulting to both.
 
I agree. I watched so-called Christians being interviewed after watching The Da Vinci Code and many of them thought it might be true. Weak in faith people should steer clear of such movies.
Or maybe some small idea is starting to make sense and resonate in their mind.
 
Scruples over whether to watch a story in which a priest character is insulted might fairly lead one to ask: what human beings* may *be safely insulted without a scruple?

Hard truths can be treated in the movies without undue insult. Comedy can be at the expense of a fictional character or at the expense of the foibles of real people without denigrating anyone’s basic human dignity. There is such a thing as taking onesself way too seriously, even for one’s own good. There is such a thing as building plaster saints to hide real sinners who wrongly desire the cloak of darkness, as well. Heaven forbid that our reverence for the priesthood give priests a place to hide a guilt that deserves the cleansing of light!

So when you decided what is acceptable for you to watch in a movie, ask yourself this: Can this piece entertain me or provoke the intended thoughts without hardening my heart? If the truth is difficult, is it a truth that can be safely left hidden? Is the piece a comedy, a fair challenge, or is it just plain cruelty at someone else’s expense?

I believe that’s a better litmus test, and I think most priests would say so, too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top