Can you assist with these quotes?

  • Thread starter Thread starter PiousTemplar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

PiousTemplar

Guest
I was arguing with, I believe, an un-charitable Catholic. Here are some of his comments:
“Only Catholics go to Heaven. You are probably a heretic too, so you won’t be going to Heaven either.”

“You are not in communion with Rome. Pope Leo XIII said One is not Christian unless he submits to Rome.” Well, you are not Chrisitan because you tolerate non Catholic religions and you respect them. That is heresy. You probably believe that all people go to Heaven and that unbaptized babies go to Heaven too. All these things Rome is against. So you are not in communion with Rome. You are a heretic."

“You are exremely dumb if your defending a heretic. You can kiss your soul good bye too you disgusting liar.”

“Your prayers are useless. Jesus does not listen to the prayers of non Catholic heretics.”

I was saying to him: "Being so vile to people is not what Christ instructed us to do. It is un-christian. " I got raged up and started calling him a moron and an idiot for calling me a heretic. I acknowlege that this was inappropriate. He messeged me later on with these quotes. What do you think of them?

Pope Eugene IV
“The Holy Roman Church firmly believes professes and preaches that all who are outside of it, not only pagans, but also Jews, heretics and schismatics cannot share in eternal life and will go into the fires of Hell prepared for the devil and his angels unless they are joined to the Catholic Church before the end of their lives. It matters not how much they give away in alms, even if they have shed blood for the Name of Christ cannot be saved unless they persevere in the bosom and unity of the Catholic Church.”

Pope Gregory XVI
“Finally, some of these misguided people attempt to persuade themselves that men are not saved only in the Catholic religion, but that even heretics may have eternal life.”

Pope Innocent IX
To say that unbaptized babies go to Heaven is quite idiotic.

Pope Pius IX
“Perverse is that opinion that says all religions are good and equal.”

Pope Pius XI
“To say that all religions are good and equal is a grave sin. Not only the people who hold this position in error, but it is tantamount to denying the one true Faith revealed by God.”

Pope Saint Gregory the Great
“It is impossible to worship God truly except in the Catholic Church.”
 
Ok…

First I would ask for sources from your friend directly. There is so much nonsense floating around that is supported by partial Papal quotes. If people were to read the entire quote in context, it usually says something very different.

Take salvation outside the Church. It is true that the church teaches that salvation only comes through the Church. But in this case, we are talking about the Church as the Body of Christ. Paul mentions several times that the Church is the Body of Christ. Jesus tells us that no one can come to the father except through Him. So if the Church is the Body with Jesus as its head, then you can read that statement as, ‘No one is saved with Jesus’. If someone is actively seeking God, whatever the faith, and they have not rejected God’s church, then they have the possibility of salvation.

Second, not everything a pope utters is infallible teaching. There are only certain times when a pope is teaching or confirming other teaching that he is making a statement using the authority of the keys given to Peter by Christ.

Your friends needs many prayers to help lead him from his path. Your responses should continue to be charitable. It is frustrating to hear a Catholic say those things and I thank you for continuing to seek the light.
 
I was arguing with, I believe, an un-charitable Catholic. Here are some of his comments:
“Only Catholics go to Heaven. You are probably a heretic too, so you won’t be going to Heaven either.”

“You are not in communion with Rome. Pope Leo XIII said One is not Christian unless he submits to Rome.” Well, you are not Chrisitan because you tolerate non Catholic religions and you respect them. That is heresy. You probably believe that all people go to Heaven and that unbaptized babies go to Heaven too. All these things Rome is against. So you are not in communion with Rome. You are a heretic."

“You are exremely dumb if your defending a heretic. You can kiss your soul good bye too you disgusting liar.”

“Your prayers are useless. Jesus does not listen to the prayers of non Catholic heretics.”

I was saying to him: "Being so vile to people is not what Christ instructed us to do. It is un-christian. " I got raged up and started calling him a moron and an idiot for calling me a heretic. I acknowlege that this was inappropriate. He messeged me later on with these quotes. What do you think of them?
…
There was once a man who understood the Church’s teaching that “there is no salvation outside the Church” (Extra Ecclesiam nulla salus) in much the same way that this person seems to. That man was condemned as a heretic for teaching that this meant one had to be within the visible confines of the Catholic Church to be saved. As Fr. John Riccardo says, “At that point, he had to hope he was wrong.”

The person you are dealing with, as you said, has very much lost sight of the love of God. Your response should be to pray for him fervently that he might repent of his anger and uncharitableness, but the response he needs to hear from you is probably one of love and patience, because anger that begets anger will never relent its anger. It will only be stopped by the shockingly unexpected application of love.

As for the other things his understanding of Extra Ecclesiam nulla salus has lead him to believe, it seems he’s also not been reading his Catechism, because if to “tolerate non Catholic religions and… respect them… is heresy,” then the Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches heresy, and for that matter, Blessed John Paul the Great and Pope Benedict XVI must be heretics. (But wait, didn’t Benedict exercise the charism of infallibility when he named JPII a Blessed - a status definitely not available to those in hell? I’m so sarcastically confused!) CCC, paragraphs 818-9, states:
818 “However, one cannot charge with the sin of the separation those who at present are born into these communities [that resulted from such separation] and in them are brought up in the faith of Christ, and the Catholic Church accepts them with respect and affection as brothers . . . . All who have been justified by faith in Baptism are incorporated into Christ; they therefore have a right to be called Christians, and with good reason are accepted as brothers in the Lord by the children of the Catholic Church.”

819 “Furthermore, many elements of sanctification and of truth” are found outside the visible confines of the Catholic Church: “the written Word of God; the life of grace; faith, hope, and charity, with the other interior gifts of the Holy Spirit, as well as visible elements.” Christ’s Spirit uses these Churches and ecclesial communities as means of salvation, whose power derives from the fullness of grace and truth that Christ has entrusted to the Catholic Church. All these blessings come from Christ and lead to him, and are in themselves calls to “Catholic unity.”
The Church does teach that “there is no salvation outside the Church,” however she means that any measure of salvation that is granted to anyone who’s not a Catholic - even to the avowed atheir or those who, for whatever reason, are blindly opposed to the Catholic Faith while not actually having the first clue what we believe - originates from the Catholic Church, which, by the decree of God, is the very font of life in the world. God has bound the Church to the Sacraments, so that we who have received the grace to come to Her must rely on those means of salvation offered to us by the Church, but God Himself is not bound by them. If He chooses to have mercy on those outside the Church, that is His will and we have no right to question it nor deny it. Jesus said, “And I have other sheep, that are not of this fold; I must bring them also, and they will heed my voice. So there shall be one flock, one Shepherd” (John10:16). On earth, though we must call all men to the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church, there are those who will not have access to this sheepfold, yet they will hear the voice of Christ in their own way and He will lead them home to join us in the Church Triumphant. We know not from whence they come, but they will come. For He is a very good, very loving Shepherd…

As for infants who die without baptism for whatever reason, the Church entrusts them to the mercy of God. We do not know whether they go to Heaven or Hell (and it is profoundly wrong to insist that they or anyone is destined to hell, especially when you consider the deep psychological and emotional pain that is caused to those grieving parents who’ve lost a child through still birth or miscarriage and are then told by such uncharitable persons as you describe that their beloved child, whom they had every intention of initiating into the Body of Christ through Baptism at the earliest opportunity, is in Hell because God took the child away before they could do anything to save it) but we trust that our God, who is Love Incarnate, is far, far, far more loving and merciful than your friend.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top