Can you keep a secret?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TOP
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TOP

Guest
Can you keep a secret? I can’t. As soon as something comes to light about our Lord or His dealings with me , I’m blah blah blah. Are we supposed to keep our mouths shut. I’m hitting brick walls at every turn.I know St. Faustina kept things secret with our Lord, as well as the ineffable things St. Paul didn’t speak of, overheard in the third heaven by “someone”. What do you think? Tim
 
Can you keep a secret? I can’t. As soon as something comes to light about our Lord or His dealings with me , I’m blah blah blah. Are we supposed to keep our mouths shut. I’m hitting brick walls at every turn.I know St. Faustina kept things secret with our Lord, as well as the ineffable things St. Paul didn’t speak of, overheard in the third heaven by “someone”. What do you think? Tim
It depends.
If I feel the Lord wants me to share my experience as a testimony to encourage others, I will speak. There were couple times I wanted to mention something, but I sensed the Lord want me to keep silent. It seems those experiences were too precious and the Lord want me to keep it just with Him.
 
It depends.
If I feel the Lord wants me to share my experience as a testimony to encourage others, I will speak. There were couple times I wanted to mention something, but I sensed the Lord want me to keep silent. It seems those experiences were too precious and the Lord want me to keep it just with Him.
I can’t always discern what is from the Lord, therefore I can’t say some things, even to my confessor, without possibly causing offense. I think I have been mislead before, but can’t discern. This was over a few days time and alot was brought up. I was told I wasn’t a good example and I was discouraged and ended up in the hospital for 4-5 days. See what I’m getting at? I still feel this urge to tell my story and about God’s mercy. Thats just the spiritual side of it. Recently I have talked with my Priest about getting involved with jail ministries and was met with a civil lawsuit this week. I’m punch drunk. Tim
 
I can’t always discern what is from the Lord, therefore I can’t say some things, even to my confessor, without possibly causing offense.
Never keep anything from your confessor. If he doesn’t know the whole story, he can’t help you. Just like the doctor.

St. Faustina ran everything Jesus told her by the priest in confession and always obeyed the priest if he ordered something different from what Jesus told her. Jesus was pleased with this.

Betsy
 
I can’t always discern what is from the Lord, therefore I can’t say some things, even to my confessor, without possibly causing offense. I think I have been mislead before, but can’t discern. This was over a few days time and alot was brought up. I was told I wasn’t a good example and I was discouraged and ended up in the hospital for 4-5 days. See what I’m getting at? I still feel this urge to tell my story and about God’s mercy. Thats just the spiritual side of it. Recently I have talked with my Priest about getting involved with jail ministries and was met with a civil lawsuit this week. I’m punch drunk. Tim
I am sorry about your negative experience. Without knowing what’s going on, I can only give my opinion in general. When evangelizing, if we talk about our own experience without involving privacy of others, it should be OK. The bottom line of testimony is to give glory to God. While doing it, keep in mind of proper boundary to avoid possible offense.
 
Never keep anything from your confessor. If he doesn’t know the whole story, he can’t help you. Just like the doctor.

St. Faustina ran everything Jesus told her by the priest in confession and always obeyed the priest if he ordered something different from what Jesus told her. Jesus was pleased with this.

Betsy
I would have to write a book to bring everything up to my confessor and he may think I’m just crazy. I question that myself. One Priest told me that negative things are not from God. We didn’t get into the details. The things this “spirit” said still bother me today, but I’m slowly thinking I was duped. If thats the case, why are the physical manifestation allowed, such as deaths , car wrecks, lawsuits. I’m being tried on lessons I don’t understand from where they come. I really don’t know what to make of it. I need a good discerning S.A. that has experience with both kinds. I’m not going to find that local. Tim
 
I am sorry about your negative experience. Without knowing what’s going on, I can only give my opinion in general. When evangelizing, if we talk about our own experience without involving privacy of others, it should be OK. The bottom line of testimony is to give glory to God. While doing it, keep in mind of proper boundary to avoid possible offense.
Don’t be sorry. The Lord can make something good out of anything and did. Tim
 
Well , I wrote down part of one experience and may bring it up in confession Sat. If my confessor doesn’t think I’m nuts now, he will after hearing this. Say a prayer for him. Tim
 
I wouldn’t want to keep a secret from my confessor, but as far as the rest of the world, I know what you mean. I have noticed that there are many times in the Bible where Jesus tells people to tell no one. So I think there are times where you need to keep things to yourself, especially if you think telling others might cause you to be boastful.

As far as what to tell your confessor, I sometimes get stressed out about this too. I don’t want to get too wordy or detailed and lose the main focus of what I am intending to confess. If I am feeling that way, I will usually spend some time praying to Mary, asking her to help me make a good confession. Everything always does seem to come out right then, and I feel the peace of a good confession.
 
Never keep anything from your confessor. If he doesn’t know the whole story, he can’t help you. Just like the doctor.

Betsy
My experience with both priests and doctors, in general, is that they don’t have the patience for us to go into detail.
 
the classic spiritual advice would be to discern such things with your spiritual director or confessor, and otherwise to be quiet about them until you have permission to share them. other life events don’t necessarily have anything to do with such “spiritual insights” and it is a mistake to ascribe them to a direct spiritual intervention without proof, discerned under spiritual direction.
 
the classic spiritual advice would be to discern such things with your spiritual director or confessor, and otherwise to be quiet about them until you have permission to share them. other life events don’t necessarily have anything to do with such “spiritual insights” and it is a mistake to ascribe them to a direct spiritual intervention without proof, discerned under spiritual direction.
This is good advice. I can’t find a SA who is a Priest, Monk or Nun. This discernment affects almost all parts of my and my family’s life, faith, church , life and death issues, questions of the afterlife. Tim
 
My experience with both priests and doctors, in general, is that they don’t have the patience for us to go into detail.
I don’t mean to go into excruciating detail. I mean don’t leave out important things that have happened because you feel the need to keep them secret. That’s usually a temptation you should not give in to. When you feel that Our Lord is speaking to you in an extraordinary way or appearing to you, that’s pretty important.

If you are telling your doctor that you had a terrible headache and momentary confusion, you should not leave out the fact that your arm and leg on one side went numb. You may think it’s just because you slept funny, but that’s an important symptom of a stroke. If the doc doesn’t know that, he’ll have a more difficult time diagnosing and treating you. OTOH, he doesn’t need to know what was on TV at the time, or what you had for breakfast.😃

Betsy
 
My confessor shifted my focus on the Trinity for the better, Tim
I’m late coming to the conversation, but do you mind if I ask what the purpose was for this shift? And what was your focus on prior to this? Is it supposed to help specifically with the way you are interpreting events in your life? I’m not trying to be nosy, it just may help me with my own perceptions of life, etc.:hmmm:
 
I’m late coming to the conversation, but do you mind if I ask what the purpose was for this shift? And what was your focus on prior to this? Is it supposed to help specifically with the way you are interpreting events in your life? I’m not trying to be nosy, it just may help me with my own perceptions of life, etc.:hmmm:
I was told to walk a trail on my property, find a spot and read John 1:1. I was too focused on the angelic and spliting up the Trinity. It worked well. It was like I always knew and had forgotten something then remembered it again. Tim
 
I was told to walk a trail on my property, find a spot and read John 1:1. I was too focused on the angelic. It worked well. Tim
I understand. Sometimes our focus does get a little skewed. I have found myself at times doing similar things. My father used to call it, seeing demons behind every closed door, or being focused on the messanger instead of the message, which has already been given to us through the scriptures and the Church. It can create a lot of confusion and/or fear in life, and that’s not what we are called to, we are to be aware but not overcome!

God bless you, it sounds like you have a good advisor!
 
I like him alot, he’s a good guy for sure. Tim
P.S. I meant 1st book chapter 1 of John.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top