Can you sin in a dream?

  • Thread starter Thread starter PiousTemplar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

PiousTemplar

Guest
I’m really confused at the moment. Can you sin in a dream? Sometimes I get dreams where I do very evil things, which actually sometimes scare me. I wasn’t worried because the priest who does ‘ask an apologist’ said you can’t, yet this website: thechristiandepot.com/dreamsinlucid.php
says you can. This really disturbs me.

I believe I have control in my dreams, and I know it is morally wrong, but it’s weird. It’s like, you have control, but you don’t… if that makes any sense. When I wake up I KNOW in my heart I would NEVER partake in any actions that happens in some of my dreams.

Cheers,

PiousTemplar
 
I’m really confused at the moment. Can you sin in a dream? Sometimes I get dreams where I do very evil things, which actually sometimes scare me. I wasn’t worried because the priest who does ‘ask an apologist’ said you can’t, yet this website: thechristiandepot.com/dreamsinlucid.php
says you can. This really disturbs me.

I believe I have control in my dreams, and I know it is morally wrong, but it’s weird. It’s like, you have control, but you don’t… if that makes any sense. When I wake up I KNOW in my heart I would NEVER partake in any actions that happens in some of my dreams.

Cheers,

PiousTemplar
The answer is NO you cannot sin while dreaming.
 
Pious Templar,

If Fr. Vincent Serpa was the priest you are referring to in the “Ask an Apologist”, I would go with his answer although I didn’t read his answer. Fr. Vincent is a very orthodox and faithful priest to the Catholic faith. I took a very quick look at the website you referenced but I can’t make any comment on its validity of the statements they presented. If you want to put your mind further at ease you can always call the Apologists line at Catholic Answers and they can help as well.

Also I’m sure you will get some very good answers within this forum as well.
 
I read the attachment, and find their claims to be fairly weak.

I think where the article goes astray, in its apparent conclusion that since it thinks it is possible that one can exert control over the content of a dream, then by golly then as dreamers we are responsible for what we do in our dreams. It doesn’t logically follow. :whacky:

The other thing I noticed was its assertion that REM sleep is when you are aware you are dreaming – and somehow that can be concluded from the fact that your eye muscles move.

Hells bells, by that definition then breathing itself would be a conscious act during a dream. I’m not buying it. Just because a muscle is moving doesn’t mean that I am conscious, or through deliberate act of will.

I don’t know why the author was led to write the article this way, but if ones gives him any heed it will add nothing but paranoia and anxiety to a person, and then if they “catch” themselves it will give them a sense of guilt where there is no wrong.

Alan
 
Relax. You can not sin when you are sleeping. You don’t have control over your thoughts and dreams when you are sleeping. It is a good question though,because many of the “sins” we are supposed to comity sleeping are of a sexual nature. You may dream of a girl you love and “things” can happen,but nobody is in control as long as we sleep,so they are not a sin. Sweet dreams.:sleep:
 
PT,
The short answer is NO you cannot sin while dreaming.
However, having said that I would not entirely dismiss what you describe either - especially if it is vivid and recurring.

My take is that, while your actions are not sinful, such dreams if they are recurring can be indicators of spiritual areas that might need attention.
For instance if you keep dreaming about hurting someone who hurt you, it may indicate that, while you consciously have suppressed your anger, there still lingers underlying unforgiveness…Things like that.
This type of thing might need to be discussed with your confessor and/or spiritual director.

The thing to remember about dreams and “control” etc is that, even if you say you can control your dreams, that control is very tenuous. The problem is that in dreamland a "thought’ is instantly transformed into “action” since there really isn’t any seperation between the two… One may be able to change the direction of the action but that is about all.

So - I agree with the others that you have not sinned. but if what youa re experincing is recurring and troubling, by all means talk to a trusted spiritual councilor about what might be underlying this.

Peace
James
 
No, you cannot sin in a dream. I took a look at the link you provided, and the person writing the article so twisted the psychological study that it is not even recognizable. We cannot control our dreams. Sometimes things we have seen and experienced throughout the day comes into our dreams in a mixed up form- but not always. A lot of times our dreams have nothing to do with our experiences of daily life. I think what the author was trying to say is that by looking at sinful things during the day will lead to having impure dreams at night. That may be true, but the willful sin committed during the day is the actual sin, not the dream at night. There are many people who are chaste and good Christians who have bizarre or impure dreams through no fault of their own. It could simply be natural human urges, the devil trying to tempt us through dreams, or the unconscious running amok. We are only responsible for sins in our waking life. We have to will them to contract mortal sin.
 
I’m really confused at the moment. Can you sin in a dream? Sometimes I get dreams where I do very evil things, which actually sometimes scare me. I wasn’t worried because the priest who does ‘ask an apologist’ said you can’t, yet this website: thechristiandepot.com/dreamsinlucid.php
says you can. This really disturbs me.

I believe I have control in my dreams, and I know it is morally wrong, but it’s weird. It’s like, you have control, but you don’t… if that makes any sense. When I wake up I KNOW in my heart I would NEVER partake in any actions that happens in some of my dreams.

Cheers,

PiousTemplar
I would think not. I remember one bizzare dream I had walking nude down Times Square eating a peanut butter and jelly sandwhich. I don’t think that would be a sin even wake but an example of how we have no control over our dreams.
 
When I was very psychotic, before I received healing,I had some pretty out of control thoughts, and I translated them into action because I believed them at the time.

Alan
 
I’ve received the answer “no” from two different priests. The reason being that the dream is without your consent.
I might add, wakeful consent, since it was mentioned one can control one’s dreams on occasion. I don’t think so, even if it seems that way. If you were fully awake you wouldn’t choose to have a sinful dream. Don’t worry about it.
Dreams happen without your consent.🙂
God bless you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top