Can you whisper a confession?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JD27076
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JD27076

Guest
Question in title.

What I mean, can you, get the confession out, but not loud enough for the priest to hear.

My priest told us at a class that the priest doesn’t have to understand it to give absolution.

I think.
 
The Priest needs to be able to hear your Sins in order to give Absolution i think. - Hey Justin, Remember me 😉 -
 
Question in title.

What I mean, can you, get the confession out, but not loud enough for the priest to hear.

My priest told us at a class that the priest doesn’t have to understand it to give absolution.

I think.
Absolution is not given on the effectiveness of communication but on contrition VIA sincerity. If you whisper something so that the priest can’t hear it, are you really being sincere about confessing it? It’s dangerous to abuse any holy thing; more-so the sacraments.
 
If the priest can’t hear you, he will tell you to speak up.
 
It seems to me that if you were whispering you were ‘trying to hide’ what you did from the priest. If you are sincere in what you are doing, then you wouldn’t be trying to hide it, simply confessing it even if you are embarrassed. You must ask yourself, why would you whisper it other than shame?
 
Question in title.

What I mean, can you, get the confession out, but not loud enough for the priest to hear.

My priest told us at a class that the priest doesn’t have to understand it to give absolution.

I think.
He’s right. The priest does not have to understand it to give absolution.

However, the penitent does need to do everything reasonably possible to be heard and understood in order to be absolved.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top