Canada: Bracing for the Gomery report

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ani_Ibi
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Chretien taking Gomery to court over report

The former Prime Minister of Canada is really angry.
Chretien’s lawyer, David Scott, said the grounds – “with the utmost respect to his judicial office” – that Gomery showed a “reasonable apprehension of bias.” In addition, his findings didn’t have an evidentiary foundation in several key areas, Scott said, without going into detail.

Chretien accepted responsibility for what went wrong on his watch, but also defended his actions. “As soon as I got word of abuse, I asked the Auditor General and the RCMP to investigate,” he said. “Mr. Gomery … made an error about the role, responsibility and power of the prime minister,” he said.

Chretien also criticized the commissioner for accepting the testimony of federal bureaucrat Chuck Guite over that of Jean Pelletier, Chretien’s chief of staff. In addition, Chretien said some witnesses who could have said good things about him – such as former public works ministers Don Boudria and Ralph Goodale – were never called as witnesses.

Appointing Bernard Roy – a former chief of staff to Brian Mulroney – was another objection. “It was probably not the best decision made” by Gomery, said Chretien, adding at that Gomery’s daughter also works in the same firm as Roy – Ogilvy Renault in Montreal. Chretien called Gomery’s choice of Roy as “the beginning” of the war for him.
Of the record, Chretien has murmured that this report has made him think twice about his support of federalism.
 
This is the Gomery Report Phase One in its entirety: Click here.

I encourage American posters to keep up with this story. Things have gotten very dicey over this. It is not just a scandal. It has broken the confidence of the Canadian people in ‘federalism’ and most importantly given ammunition to the ever-simmering dreams of Kebekers to separate.

Kebekers did not need much ammunition. There have been two referendums in the past half century. In the last one, the federalists – that is those who wanted a Canada which includes Quebec – barely squeeked through.

People are rightfully asking what nether regions of reason justify the expenditure of $355M – much of which was wrongfully spent, unaccounted for, and just plain illegal – on keeping people within Confederation.

The response of Prime Minister Martin, former Prime Minister Chretien, those in government and those not in government is critical. A false step, a snapped temper could well result in a radically altered North America.

Here is the Globe and Mail Gomery Page. Click here. This has a chart with the major political figures on it and the amount of money to which they were each linked. It also has a list of the development of this story, it’s history and analysis thereof.

The Globe and Mail summarizes the findings of the Gomery Report here. This is a concise list in point form of Phase One and worth a read.
 
Here are a few points on the Globe and Mail summary of findings page. The link was given in the previous post.
The administration of the program was shrouded in a “veil of secrecy” and there was an absence of transparency in contracting processes.
Fear of reprisal resulted in a reluctance among “virtually all public servants” to go against the will of a manager who was circumventing established policies and who had access to senior political officials.
There was “gross overcharging” by communications agencies for hours worked and goods and services provided.

The sponsorship program was used for purposes other than national unity and federal visibility because of a lack of objectives, criteria and program guidelines.

There were “deliberate actions” to avoid compliance with federal legislation including the Canada Elections Action and the Lobbyists Registration Act.
There was also a "culture of entitlement" among political officials and bureaucrats involved with the program, including the receipt of both monetary and non-monetary benefits.
 
Thanks Ani,
This is a lot to take in …but good for US to keep up with…

What do you think of Prime Minister Martin, now? I heard him give a speech in French …English as well…he seems quite serious…
 
40.png
aimee:
Thanks Ani,
This is a lot to take in …but good for US to keep up with…

What do you think of Prime Minister Martin, now? I heard him give a speech in French …English as well…he seems quite serious…
I think Prime Minister Martin is a Liberal. I think his real job right now is in throwing away no further money, time, and energy on defending against the righteous indignation of the Canadian Street. His real job is to find a way to restore the confidence of Canadians and Kebekers in Canada. If he fails to do that within the next six months, then we are no better than a nationalized Family Compact at the trough.

Do I sound bitter? I suppose I do, but I am not alone. Here is a sampling of readership views at the Toronto Star:

Voices: Gomery report: We asked you what you think of Justice Gomery’s findings. Here’s what you had to say.

When I was younger, many of us in Quebec and in the other provinces thought that bilingualism and biculturalism was possible and – in the words of Jean Chretien – a noble cause. Since then Brian Mulroney eroded our confidence; Kim Campbell was a brief embarrassing blip on the horizon; and Jean Chretien had become a corporate man.

When Chretien first ran for the leadership of the Liberal Party way back in the Mulroney era, my Kebeker friend and I snuck into the leadership conference. When John Turner was chosen instead of Chretien, we began to see the face of the new cynical Canada.

When Chretien was young he had ideals and vision. As Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development he saw this country as I do for the beauty of its natural landscapes and for the bond between wild, open lands and the human soul. When Turner was chosen over him, Chretien joined a high-power law firm and I guess that must have been his fall from grace.

That Chretien correctly assessed the real and present danger not only of Quebec secession from Canada but of a renewal of the violence and instability of the FLQ era and that he genuinely believed that free enterprise was a solution to that threat by fast-tracking confidence, unity, and prosperity: I don’t question.

The trouble is that free enterprise is well… does anybody in Canada remember? We have become a nation which reflexively responds to business challenges by applying for government grants. The sponsorship scandal is the manifest result of a way of thinking that Canadians as a whole have accepted as part and parcel of Pierre Trudeau’s Just Society. It didn’t have to be, but people fell asleep at the wheel and that’s what we ended up with.

The sponsorship scandal is only one of many symptoms of the dark underbelly of Trudeau’s Utopia. We also had the HRDC scandal. Same thinking, same choices, same illegal actions. Canadians were out of work and being blamed for being out of work while public servants were at the trough literally inventing phantom jobs which they then expected the unemployed to waste time applying for.

Good money was being poured into the pockets of the few during a time when hospitals and schools were being closed, the environment was being pillaged and folks – ordinary folks with families and jobs – were freezing to death on the streets! We are talking about billions of dollars in misappropriation at the federal, provincial, and municipal levels! This is what Gomery termed the Culture of Entitlement. And don’t even start with our military being sent into harm’s way with inadequate clothing, equipment, materiels, and medical support!

What do I think of Martin? I have forgotten what it feels like to be Canadian when I listen to Martin, Layton, and Harper. I often feel like a stranger in a strange land. And for all the bumper stickers defiantly displayed in Kebek saying “Je me souviens” I truly wonder if anyone does remember on the one hand the national disgrace of the Montreal bombings, the Pierre Laporte kidnapping and on the other hand the boisterous hope of being at home in all parts of Canada regardless of language or ethnic origin.
 
Chretien to foot bill for future Gomery legal fees
Taxpayers paid for Chretien’s $440,000 legal bill during Gomery’s sponsorship inquiry. But lawyer Peter Doody says Chretien will foot the bill for the fees he racks up as he fights Gomery’s sponsorship findings in Federal Court…

In Commons, Martin said the party has already repaid taxpayers the $1.4 million that Gomery said was improperly donated to the Liberals. And Martin says charges are pending against people responsible for the sponsorship affair… “Those individuals have been banned from party membership, Mr. Speaker and charges are pending in a number of cases,” said the prime minister…

Though [Conservative leader] Harper has said he wants a fall election so that Canadian voters can render judgment on the Liberals, he is not prepared to press for one without the support of both the NDP and the Bloc Quebecois… Bloc Leader Gilles Duceppe has already made it clear he favours an immediate election…

The Liberals are currently trying to hold on to the NDP’s support and are negotiating with them to stop the growth of private clinics, which Layton calls a “step by step transforming (of) our public health care system into something Canadians don’t want.” The NDP wants to stop doctors from double-billing and to cut off federal funds to provinces that allow new private clinics.
 
Experts say Gomery entitled to judge credibility
Justice John Gomery called Chuck Guite evasive, a man without scruples and a generally unreliable witness. But in the end, he took Guite’s word over that of a former cabinet minister and Jean Chretien’s top aide… “In general, I have come to the conclusion that he is not always a reliable witness and that any affirmations made by him should be accepted with caution,” Gomery wrote in his report… “That being said, some of the statements of even the most unreliable witness may prove to be true.”

An unscrupulous witness may seem to be a thin reed on which to hang such a decision, but legal experts say it’s a judgment call. Ron Delisle, a retired law professor from Queen’s University and an expert on evidence, says… "Judges frequently, when they are addressing a jury, will say: ‘You’ve listened to witness so-so, you can believe all of what he said, none of what he said or you can believe some of what he said’… The credibility decision was Gomery’s alone, said Delisle. “That’s what they pay him for.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top