Cannot differentiate between dreams and thoughts

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lea101
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Lea101

Guest
Ok, so a friend told me something that have happened to her. Might be “tmi” for some, but it’s important information. She had a sexual dream, woke up still feeling dazed + “in the mood” and she thinks she succumbed to lust (porn, but probably impure actions as well), but like 10 seconds in, she told me she quickly got her s*** together and shut down her computer.

Now I wouldn’t say that this is a sin simply from these facts, but she told me that she doesn’t know if she was dreaming or just thinking. She says she woke up and then “fall asleep” and then all of this happened. Which could mean that she was tired but had these thoughts awake or at least she was half asleep. I asked her if she felt that she was in control of what happened, but she said at the time yes, but after she shut down her computer and everything, she was not sure

I’m so confused now, because I don’t know what to tell her? Is she being scrupulous? Or is her guilt there for a reason? Was “those 10 seconds” a sin? (I think yes actually, but then she said that she didn’t really get to do anything 😊 and that she felt guilty and stopped, so is the “aroused/in the mood” thing she felt when she was awake lust or desire?)

I am also asking this because sometimes I feel like I kind of have this issue as well. When I think I’m half awake-at that time it felt like I have total control of my thoughts, but when I’m fully awake, I’m like “HELL NO” (Not necessarily lust, but unpleasant thoughts). So I’m also interested in your opinions.
 
PS: she also feels guilty bc when she was awake, she was aware that she was about to commit a mortal sin, but didn’t care. But then she felt really really guilty and didn’t go through with it.

From what I believe, thinking of doing a sin is a sin, yes?
 
PS: she also feels guilty bc when she was awake, she was aware that she was about to commit a mortal sin, but didn’t care. But then she felt really really guilty and didn’t go through with it.

From what I believe, thinking of doing a sin is a sin, yes?
Update: i got her to just go for confession, so much easier that way:D
 
PS: she also feels guilty bc when she was awake, she was aware that she was about to commit a mortal sin, but didn’t care. But then she felt really really guilty and didn’t go through with it.

From what I believe, thinking of doing a sin is a sin, yes?
You both need to see the priest. If you do not commit the sinful act, there is no sin.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top