F
fabio_rocha
Guest
In what base can the pope canonize someone without a second miracle? I’ve heard there’s guidelines from Benedict XIV. What are those? Cant find anywhere…
Because he is infallible. The Pope is protected by the Holy Spirit from canonizing anyone who is not actually in Heaven.OK the pope is above canon law I understand that. But how can a pope be so sure a person is truly in heaven without any proof (like miracles)?
I’m shooting from the hip, but are you sure that this was what the doctrine of infallibility was meant for? Passing judgement on the state of a soul based on what one believes seems to be a slippery slope.Quote:
Originally Posted by fabio rocha
OK the pope is above canon law I understand that. But how can a pope be so sure a person is truly in heaven without any proof (like miracles)?
Because he is infallible. The Pope is protected by the Holy Spirit from canonizing anyone who is not actually in Heaven.
Indeed, it would be a risky, slippery slope, if the Holy Spirit did not protect the Church from infallibly promulgating error.I’m shooting from the hip, but are you sure that this was what the doctrine of infallibility was meant for? Passing judgement on the state of a soul based on what one believes seems to be a slippery slope.
Posted from Catholic.com App for Android
I thought infallibility only dealt with dogma. I’ll admit that I am not an authority on the matter but this seems a little loose of an interpretation on infallibility to me. I’ll look into it and maybe someone will provide some additional fidelity for me.Quote:
Originally Posted by aTraditionalist
I’m shooting from the hip, but are you sure that this was what the doctrine of infallibility was meant for? Passing judgement on the state of a soul based on what one believes seems to be a slippery slope.
Posted from Catholic.com App for Android
Indeed, it would be a risky, slippery slope, if the Holy Spirit did not protect the Church from infallibly promulgating error.
Theologians universally recognize that canonizations are granted the charism of infallibility. This quality is what distinguishes them from beatifications.I thought infallibility only dealt with dogma. I’ll admit that I am not an authority on the matter but this seems a little loose of an interpretation on infallibility to me. I’ll look into it and maybe someone will provide some additional fidelity for me.
Posted from Catholic.com App for Android