Can't find the right balance

  • Thread starter Thread starter EIF5A
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

EIF5A

Guest
Sometimes, I can get emotional and teary when praying. It’s awkward when you’re in Mass and you have the sniffles and you’re paranoid that you’re causing a distraction. Coupled with that, I read a saintly writing saying that being too sensitive is sometimes bad.

So I determined not to be emotional and sensitive when praying or during Mass.

But now I find that I’m less able to resist temptation to sin. Not sure if that’s a cause or just a coincidence, but I feel less “close” to God.

My concern was that tears may not be a real indicator of a relationship with God, but how can I not cry when I confess my sins and look at my weak inability to grow in faith as I want?

If my faith is to grow, I thought I should be able to pray without resorting to tears and emotions.

I’m not in the Catholic Church, so I don’t have a priest to talk to. Any advice or writing from Church Fathers or saints would be greatly appreciated.
 
Sorry I don’t understand when you say your not in the Catholic Church, but then you go on to say you attend Mass, is it that your thinking of becoming Catholic ?:signofcross:
 
Sorry I don’t understand when you say your not in the Catholic Church, but then you go on to say you attend Mass, is it that your thinking of becoming Catholic ?:signofcross:
Thinking of converting…Can’t decide between the Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church
 
Sometimes, I can get emotional and teary when praying. It’s awkward when you’re in Mass and you have the sniffles and you’re paranoid that you’re causing a distraction.
It might not be a bad thing for others at mass to see such emotion. It could make them consider their own depth of relationship.
Coupled with that, I read a saintly writing saying that being too sensitive is sometimes bad.
Without greater context (who wrote this and where…I’d say it is a bad idea to act on one small snippet of writing out of it’s larger context. Whoever wrote this probably wrote more specifically why and what conditions being “too sensitive” would be a problem.
So I determined not to be emotional and sensitive when praying or during Mass.
This is creating a barrier - you are now focused on the wrong thing. You are focused on “emotions” instead of being focused on God.
Many great saints have written about this…It is very easy for us to lose our focus and this weakens us.
You have determined to be unemotional or sensitive when praying…This has taken your mind off of God and placed it on yourself…
But now I find that I’m less able to resist temptation to sin. Not sure if that’s a cause or just a coincidence, but I feel less “close” to God.
I suspect that there is definitely a correlation. As mentioned above…because you are consciously trying to be less sensitive and emotional…you are having to focus more on yourself. This takes the focus off of God.
My concern was that tears may not be a real indicator of a relationship with God, but how can I not cry when I confess my sins and look at my weak inability to grow in faith as I want?
You are quite right to say that tears are not (necessarily) an indicator of your relationship with God. They may be an indicator of where you are on your journey.
Again - in the writings of several great saints they indicate that one can go though stages - one can be deeply emotional for awhile and then not so much…one can be elated…then become more down…one might need seclusion for awhile and then later need to be out and about…
All of these things are simply points on a journey - or stages one passes through - or even returns to from time to time.

The bottom line here is that the tears are neither a good thing or a bad thing. They should be neither resisted or encouraged…only experienced.
If my faith is to grow, I thought I should be able to pray without resorting to tears and emotions.
At some point this may very well happen…but it needs to happen in it’s own time (or in God’s time)…It should not be forced - one way or the other.
I’m not in the Catholic Church, so I don’t have a priest to talk to. Any advice or writing from Church Fathers or saints would be greatly appreciated.
Not a Church Father - but a Doctor of the Church - you might find “The Story of a Soul” to be helpful in some of this.
Also the book in my signature is a wonderful distillation of the whole process of growing in holiness based on the writings of saints of the “mystic” tradition.

May God continue to guide you on your journey

Peace
James
 
Sometimes, I can get emotional and teary when praying. It’s awkward when you’re in Mass and you have the sniffles and you’re paranoid that you’re causing a distraction. Coupled with that, I read a saintly writing saying that being too sensitive is sometimes bad.

So I determined not to be emotional and sensitive when praying or during Mass.

But now I find that I’m less able to resist temptation to sin. Not sure if that’s a cause or just a coincidence, but I feel less “close” to God.

My concern was that tears may not be a real indicator of a relationship with God, but how can I not cry when I confess my sins and look at my weak inability to grow in faith as I want?

If my faith is to grow, I thought I should be able to pray without resorting to tears and emotions.

I’m not in the Catholic Church, so I don’t have a priest to talk to. Any advice or writing from Church Fathers or saints would be greatly appreciated.
That sounds like the gift of tears. A friend of mine has that and asked the Lord to take it away because she was embarrassed to have tears running down her face. So He did. Then she asked Him again to please give it back as she missed it! He did.
 
Sometimes, I can get emotional and teary when praying. It’s awkward when you’re in Mass and you have the sniffles and you’re paranoid that you’re causing a distraction. Coupled with that, I read a saintly writing saying that being too sensitive is sometimes bad.
There is no need to feel paranoid that you are a distraction. People hear many things during Mass and learn not to respond to all the sounds around them.

Make sure you have tissues and use them. Some sniffles are gone once you softly blow your nose. Use a fresh tissue to dab your eyes, pressing on the inner point near your nose. This may shorten your crying time.

Just because you read something does not mean it is true or always true. You are not wrong in being sensitive… its your true emotion.

Even though you have not joined the Church, you can still speak with a priest about your expressing of your emotions with tears. Hearing what he has to tell you, may actually relieve you of discomfort.
My concern was that tears may not be a real indicator of a relationship with God, but how can I not cry when I confess my sins and look at my weak inability to grow in faith as I want?
By confession, do you mean praying to God to confess since you are not Catholic and not receiving the Sacrament? Many people cry when they receive the Sacrament of Confession. There’s sometimes a box of tissues in the confessional.
If my faith is to grow, I thought I should be able to pray without resorting to tears and emotions.
Maybe you thought wrong. Maybe as your faith grows, you still feel an overwhelming emotion that is expressed by you in the form of tears. Do you easily cry at other points in life - besides during prayer?
 
My concern was that tears may not be a real indicator of a relationship with God, but how can I not cry when I confess my sins and look at my weak inability to grow in faith as I want?
St. Francis of Assisi cried himself nearly blind over his sins.
I think you’re blessed.

…
 
I think you’re blessed.
If only. I think I just have a more sensitive temperament, coupled with (at least mild) scrupulosity. The saints were blessed by tears because they led true lives of sanctity.

As easily as tears come, as easily they stop when I get distracted in thought.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top