Captain America: Civil War thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Robyn_p
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Robyn_p

Guest
Anyone here seen it yet? What did you think?

My not at all biased opinion? It was spectacular.

I’m usually pretty lukewarm about the Marvel movies. They’re decent and I enjoy them, but I’ve never really loved any of them. Most of them I’ve found pretty forgettable. Not this one. This was the first time I can honest to goodness say I loved a superhero movie.

It was so good. The writing, the story, the characters…it’s all so well done. Darn near perfect. I can almost always find some flaw in a movie, even ones I really enjoy, but I can’t do that here. Nothing was wasted, not even a line of dialogue. This was a superhero conflict done right.

I won’t give away any spoilers, but I’m just going to say, there’s a moment at the climax where it really looks like one character is going to kill the other, and even though I “knew” in the back of my mind it wasn’t going to happen, my immediate reaction was to wince and hold my breath, because it seemed so possible! That’s how the whole movie is. It sells the conflict so well, you forget that there’s going to be other movies in the series.

This movie was everything BvS should have been. It was dark, but not grim. There was emotion, but it was earned. Cap and Iron Man’s conflict is so…personal. And the best part? The movie doesn’t side with either one! Cap has had ideological disagreements with people before, and the movie usually ends up vindicating him, but that doesn’t happen here. Neither is completely right, neither is wrong, and that makes it so much more painful. Especially since it’s also not just a matter that could be solved by communication. Each one makes the decision they make because of their past experiences. You feel like there was no other way the story could have gone, which is a sign of a solid script.

Anyways, I could talk a lot more about this but I probably should stop. Seriously though, go see this movie!
 
I’m tired of Marvel’s Civil War concept. I plan on skipping this one.

Ed
 
Anyone here seen it yet? What did you think?

My not at all biased opinion? It was spectacular.

I’m usually pretty lukewarm about the Marvel movies. They’re decent and I enjoy them, but I’ve never really loved any of them. Most of them I’ve found pretty forgettable. Not this one. This was the first time I can honest to goodness say I loved a superhero movie.

It was so good. The writing, the story, the characters…it’s all so well done. Darn near perfect. I can almost always find some flaw in a movie, even ones I really enjoy, but I can’t do that here. Nothing was wasted, not even a line of dialogue. This was a superhero conflict done right.

I won’t give away any spoilers, but I’m just going to say, there’s a moment at the climax where it really looks like one character is going to kill the other, and even though I “knew” in the back of my mind it wasn’t going to happen, my immediate reaction was to wince and hold my breath, because it seemed so possible! That’s how the whole movie is. It sells the conflict so well, you forget that there’s going to be other movies in the series.

This movie was everything BvS should have been. It was dark, but not grim. There was emotion, but it was earned. Cap and Iron Man’s conflict is so…personal. And the best part? The movie doesn’t side with either one! Cap has had ideological disagreements with people before, and the movie usually ends up vindicating him, but that doesn’t happen here. Neither is completely right, neither is wrong, and that makes it so much more painful. Especially since it’s also not just a matter that could be solved by communication. Each one makes the decision they make because of their past experiences. You feel like there was no other way the story could have gone, which is a sign of a solid script.

Anyways, I could talk a lot more about this but I probably should stop. Seriously though, go see this movie!
Well, I might have to go see it after that glowing review! 🙂
 
Anyone here seen it yet? What did you think?

My not at all biased opinion? It was spectacular.

I’m usually pretty lukewarm about the Marvel movies. They’re decent and I enjoy them, but I’ve never really loved any of them. Most of them I’ve found pretty forgettable. Not this one. This was the first time I can honest to goodness say I loved a superhero movie.

It was so good. The writing, the story, the characters…it’s all so well done. Darn near perfect. I can almost always find some flaw in a movie, even ones I really enjoy, but I can’t do that here. Nothing was wasted, not even a line of dialogue. This was a superhero conflict done right.

I won’t give away any spoilers, but I’m just going to say, there’s a moment at the climax where it really looks like one character is going to kill the other, and even though I “knew” in the back of my mind it wasn’t going to happen, my immediate reaction was to wince and hold my breath, because it seemed so possible! That’s how the whole movie is. It sells the conflict so well, you forget that there’s going to be other movies in the series.

This movie was everything BvS should have been. It was dark, but not grim. There was emotion, but it was earned. Cap and Iron Man’s conflict is so…personal. And the best part? The movie doesn’t side with either one! Cap has had ideological disagreements with people before, and the movie usually ends up vindicating him, but that doesn’t happen here. Neither is completely right, neither is wrong, and that makes it so much more painful. Especially since it’s also not just a matter that could be solved by communication. Each one makes the decision they make because of their past experiences. You feel like there was no other way the story could have gone, which is a sign of a solid script.

Anyways, I could talk a lot more about this but I probably should stop. Seriously though, go see this movie!
Dc is better than Marvel.
  • Waits for debate to start -
 
Civil War was absolutely excellent, definitely worth seeing for all those prospective viewers. 😃
 
I’m tired of Marvel’s Civil War concept. I plan on skipping this one.

Ed
Awww you’re missing out Ed. It handles the concept so well. The movie actually cares about the issues. It doesn’t just use them as an excuse to have an epic brawl. (Though the fight in the airport is super awesome)
 
Just got back from seeing it.

Pretty good. I’m not a huge comics fan, but I watch the movies once in a while.

I won’t give out any spoilers, other than to say I was and remain an Ironman fan.
 
Awww you’re missing out Ed. It handles the concept so well. The movie actually cares about the issues. It doesn’t just use them as an excuse to have an epic brawl. (Though the fight in the airport is super awesome)
Missing out on infighting between heroes? I’ll gladly miss out.

Marvel Comics is about to roll out Civil War II - need I say more? I guess they didn’t get their fill in the first Civil War comics series.

Ed
 
Missing out on infighting between heroes? I’ll gladly miss out.

Marvel Comics is about to roll out Civil War II - need I say more? I guess they didn’t get their fill in the first Civil War comics series.

Ed
Alright. Fair enough. If it’s not your thing, it’s not your thing. 🙂 I just really enjoyed it because it wasn’t the typical “the entire world is going to die” storyline. The stakes were smaller and more personal. But I like movies that focus on characters.
 
Just got back from seeing it.

Pretty good. I’m not a huge comics fan, but I watch the movies once in a while.

I won’t give out any spoilers, other than to say I was and remain an Ironman fan.
I think this movie was by far RDJ’s best performance as Iron Man. His face when the big reveal happened and the emotion in his voice…man, that was some great acting. I actually got a little choked up.
 
I collected the comics when I was a kid… still have them… and enjoy the movies. This one was right up there. A little long, but very enjoyable.

Line of the movie for me… not a spoiler per se, but it might pique your interest even more if you’re a Marvel fan… from RDJ/Iron Man… paraphrased:

“Okay, anybody ELSE got new superpowers they might want to let us in on?” LOL
 
You might actually like this film a lot then if you’re not a big Captain America fan, because it’s the least “Cap” movie so far. The movie spends almost as much time with Tony as Steve, and doesn’t side with either one. I would almost say the movie was more about Iron Man. But all the characters get good moments.
 
I collected the comics when I was a kid… still have them… and enjoy the movies. This one was right up there. A little long, but very enjoyable.

Line of the movie for me… not a spoiler per se, but it might pique your interest even more if you’re a Marvel fan… from RDJ/Iron Man… paraphrased:

“Okay, anybody ELSE got new superpowers they might want to let us in on?” LOL
I loved that line. My favorite was also Spidey’s “Hey guys, you remember that really, really old movie? Empire Strikes Back?”
 
How did Ant-Man get so big? Wouldn’t that violate the laws of physics?
 
You might actually like this film a lot then if you’re not a big Captain America fan, because it’s the least “Cap” movie so far. The movie spends almost as much time with Tony as Steve, and doesn’t side with either one. I would almost say the movie was more about Iron Man. But all the characters get good moments.
I found myself rooting for Steve Rogers from the get-go as there’s something unsavory about superheroes doing the bidding of any government (or in this case the United Nations). Chris Evans really embodied the character as a paragon of moral rectitude in this one. Tony Stark came off to me at least as well-meaning but smarmy.
 
Man, I’m a HUGE comic book fan, and I’ve probably seen over 30 comic book movies in my life time… and I gotta say, this was the best comic book movie I have ever seen. Absolutely phenomenal, and I recommend it to literally everyone. People who haven’t seen past Marvel movies may be a bit lost, but it will still be enjoyable for the fantastic writing alone, even if the emotional impact won’t be as effective due to not knowing the characters as well. I absolutely loved this film.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top