Catechism Catholic Church

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mchristian
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Mchristian

Guest
Salutations ~ can anybody please tell me what is the best version of the Catechism is best for adults in USA. It appears there are different version by different publishers. What is the gold standard??
Thamk you.
Pax et Bonum ><>
 
Look at my profile, dude. I’m Catholic as they come.

Heck, the very mass has changed since then. Are you seriously telling me that a Catechism from 1566 contains everything the Catholic laity need to know?
 
Look at my profile, dude. I’m Catholic as they come.

Heck, the very mass has changed since then. Are you seriously telling me that a Catechism from 1566 contains everything the Catholic laity need to know?
The Catholic faith does not evolve. We are different from the Mormon faith. We have a deposit of faith. It does not evolve. Maybe “evolve” was not the word you were seeking.
The gold standard is the Catechism of the Catholic Church. Trent may be useful but it is not the gold standard.
A Catechism is only as good as teaching the faith to that person clearly. Trent offers clarity and is extremely easy to read. Faithful Catholics can use whichever Catechism they prefer; it is their duty to know the faith.
The Catechism of 1566 was written for clergy, not laity, and laity were not intended or encouraged to read it.
This is false. Have you read The Catechism of the Council of Trent? Most haven’t, but it is extremely clear and easy to understand. If you are saying that the clarity and format of CCC is easier than Trent, then it is clear you have never opened Trent.

The OP asked for best version. This is an opinion and I offered mine.
 
The Catholic faith does not evolve. We are different from the Mormon faith. We have a deposit of faith. It does not evolve. Maybe “evolve” was not the word you were seeking.
Many modern teachings may not be contained in the Catechism of Trent. We have added much understanding since then.
 
Many modern teachings may not be contained in the Catechism of Trent. We have added much understanding since then.
Yes there are some more thorough explanations for some things, this is true. I can refer to CCC online to review those when I come across them. However, these things are not revelation. If one was versed in Trent, these things would fall into place.

The Catechism is for us to know the faith, not to force anyone to use a certain one. I prefer Trent because of the clarity.
The Catechism of 1566 was written for clergy, not laity, and laity were not intended or encouraged to read it.
Maybe many of Shepards were feeding their flock so the laity didn’t have to read it? When I hear about climate change and not a word of mortal sin, state of grace, sacrilege, etc., aren’t I kind of forced to read it to know the faith?
The gold standard is the Catechism of the Catholic Church. Trent may be useful but it is not the gold standard.
The Gold Standard actually is Trent. It is what every other Catechism was written and will be.
 
The Gold Standard actually is Trent. It is what every other Catechism was written and will be.
That is your opinion only.

I notice you joined a few weeks ago (in June) but you remind me of another poster who was completely obsessed by the Catechism of Trent. Are you that poster back by another name?
 
The Catechism of the Council of Trent
Not an official Catechism of the Church.

OP, don’t be confused by posts like this. The Catechism is the one on the Vatican website that everybody has been posting to you. There’s always somebody who will come in pushing some very old catechism, usually with an agenda of proving that the current one is no good or that the current Popes don’t know what they’re doing.
 
Last edited:
There’s also the Compendium of the Catechism of the Catholic Church in case you’re interested in the crib notes version. It’s a much shorter summary in Q&A format.
 
Not an official Catechism of the Church.

OP, don’t be confused by posts like this. The Catechism is the one on the Vatican website that everybody has been posting to you. There’s always somebody who will come in pushing some very old catechism, usually with an agenda of proving that the current one is no good or that the current Popes don’t know what they’re doing.
Completely false. There is not one thing in the Catechism of Trent that any theologian would rebuke, not one single thing. You do realize that a lot of CCC came word for word from Trent. Trent is the Gold Standard.

A Catholic can use multiple catechisms, which many faithful do. I’m not saying anything bad about the CCC, all I am saying is I prefer Trent. It appears some here though do have a problem with Trent, which is very troubling. The catechism teaches the faithful the teachings of the church. Trent is easier to understand as a whole than the CCC so I prefer to use it.

. . . .
 
Last edited:
Some people do not like Trent because the wording is crystal clear and cuts like a knife. Some would prefer gray area so they can hope that things “evolve” like one user used that word. The deposit of faith does not evolve.
Pretty judgemental of you. Does Trent teach you that?
 
It’s inappropriate for you to imply that people prefer the recent official and universal Catechism of the Catholic Church because it somehow promotes changes to Church teaching or confusion and sin regarding Church teaching.

The Catechism was a project of St. Pope John Paul II, and Cardinal Ratzinger who later became Pope Benedict XVI was very much involved with it also. Are you saying those two Popes, one a Saint, promoted “evolved” teaching or unclear thought? Like I said, inappropriate, and also not credible.

I myself prefer it because it is what the Church says we are supposed to use as a catechism. When you go to RCIA, the catechists don’t take out a copy of the Catechism of the Council of Trent and teach people from it. I follow the Church authority in this matter.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top