Catechism of the Catholic Church

[TradCatholic12]

How do I reconcile past doctrinal statements about the dignity of man and what the Catechism says? Here is the link

sspx.org/New_Catechism/new_catechism__is_it_catholic_I.htm

 

[Cat]

How do I reconcile past doctrinal statements about the dignity of man and what the Catechism says? Here is the link

I though SSPX discussions were banned.

 

[Freshman88]

I though SSPX discussions were banned.

It isn’t a discussion of the SSPX, its a discussion concerning old and new catechisms.

 

[Cristiano]

It isn’t a discussion of the SSPX, its a discussion concerning old and new catechisms.

Fine with me, then can you please explain to me why there are no details in the post except for a link to SSPX?

 

[TradCatholic12]

Because it is the only link that shows the “differences” between church doctrine and the CCC.

 

[Cristiano]

Because it is the only link that shows the “differences” between church doctrine and the CCC.

It seems that the Roman Church, or at least its “governing board” is not very sure of its faith… (from your link)

That to me is not talking about differences but the SSPX denigrating the Catholic Church.

 

[Nita]

That is a long ranting link. Too much for one thread. Start individual threads for the various topics you want discussed.

I didn’t bother reading very far. Just skimmed to the part where the article equates the CCC to putting “new wine in old wineskins”.

Quote from the article:
In other words, “a new wine in old wineskins,” contrary to the counsel of Our Lord (Mt.9:17).

If it’s to be equated with wine and wineskins, the author has it backwards. The CCC is like putting old wine (2000 yr old Catholic doctrine) into new wineskins (language more understandable in the present age).