Catholic and Sikh

  • Thread starter Thread starter phil8888
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

phil8888

Guest
Just a quick question. If a Catholic marries a Sikh, and the Catholic follows all the precepts of the church including going to Mass every Sunday, is he permitted to attend her service as well, since they are married? I would prefer real information rather than opinions. Thanks.
 
To answer your question directly, yes so long as you don’t “participate.” No praying to false gods, no communion or baptismesque rites. Just listening to someone talk is fine though.

But I must ask, how did a Catholic marry a Sikh? The marrying of non Christian (more specifically non baptised) peoples is absolutely forbidden. Even marrying a baptised Protestant requrires a dispensation from the Church.
 
I would prefer real information rather than opinions. Thanks.
Hi

Kindly note if somebody says that he is providing a real information, even then it might be only his opinion, not a fact.

Thanks
 
Truly if you want real information and not opinion, you should be in ask an apologist or talking to your priest and/or the local tribunal. Of course, that is my opinion. 😃
 
To answer your question directly, yes so long as you don’t “participate.” No praying to false gods,
Please inform me as to what false gods the Sikhs worship. I have not come across any instance of this.

Edwin
 
Originally Posted by linuxgeek71:
To answer your question directly, yes so long as you don’t “participate.” No praying to false gods,
Please inform me as to what false gods the Sikhs worship. I have not come across any instance of this.

Edwin
Hi

I think linuxgeek71: is mistaken. Sikhs worship OneGod only.

I love Jesus and Baba Guru Nanakji

Thanks
 
Please inform me as to what false gods the Sikhs worship. I have not come across any instance of this.

Edwin
It was a general statement about attending any other religion’s service. I know nothing about Sikhism.
 
It was a general statement about attending any other religion’s service. I know nothing about Sikhism.
Well, maybe you should know just a little bit before making statements on a thread about Sikhism?

Edwin
 
Well, maybe you should know just a little bit before making statements on a thread about Sikhism?

Edwin
The thread isn’t about Sikhism it is about a Catholic attending another religion’s services. It doesn’t matter what the religion is because the rules are the same. They apply even for other Christian groups, with a possible exception for the Orthodox.

If you would like to start a thread about the beliefs of the Sikh you are free to do so. But this is not the place because they are not relevant to the original poster’s question.
 
The thread isn’t about Sikhism it is about a Catholic attending another religion’s services. It doesn’t matter what the religion is because the rules are the same. They apply even for other Christian groups, with a possible exception for the Orthodox.

If you would like to start a thread about the beliefs of the Sikh you are free to do so. But this is not the place because they are not relevant to the original poster’s question.
What would someone have to do in order to be worshipping a “false” God?
 
What would someone have to do in order to be worshipping a “false” God?
Worship a god that is not real. As an example consider the religion of Rome before Christianity. In it were many gods and goddesses. We call all of them false because we, as Catholics, do not believe any of them to exist. Or possibly if they do exist they are in fact demons and not gods. Either way they are not gods, and thus false gods. There are examples in the Old Testament as well, such as Moloch.

To summarize the Catholic possition, if it isn’t the God of Abraham it is a false god. If you don’t believe all the Church teaches about God but still profess a belief in the God of Abraham, like the Jews and Muslims, then you still worship the true God but have erroneous doctrine.
 
Just a quick question. If a Catholic marries a Sikh, and the Catholic follows all the precepts of the church including going to Mass every Sunday, is he permitted to attend her service as well, since they are married? I would prefer real information rather than opinions. Thanks.
You cannot bow to the Guru Granth Sahib as this would be idolatry, though I believe you may participate in Langar as this is not specifically an act of worship and has no specific overtones of worship. You may observe the acts of worship but not participate.

The other posters are right, Sikhs have only one God.
 
To summarize the Catholic possition, if it isn’t the God of Abraham it is a false god. If you don’t believe all the Church teaches about God but still profess a belief in the God of Abraham, like the Jews and Muslims, then you still worship the true God but have erroneous doctrine.
Seeing as Sikhi derives some of it’s inspiration from Islam I would say it is a safe bet that although they do so in an erroneous way, they do indeed worship the God of Abraham.
 
Thanks guys for all your valuable information. The main point of my topic was to wonder if a Catholic can attend a non-Christian ceremony if their significant other is of that religion. I think I got the gist of the answer. Basically, yes but you cannot worship a false god.
 
Thanks guys for all your valuable information. The main point of my topic was to wonder if a Catholic can attend a non-Christian ceremony if their significant other is of that religion. I think I got the gist of the answer. Basically, yes but you cannot worship a false god.
It is slightly more complicated than that. You cannot take part in the religious ceremony at any level of participation beyond observing.

Protestants worship the same God as us but we may not partake in their communion nor their altar calls or anything else really.
 
It is slightly more complicated than that. You cannot take part in the religious ceremony at any level of participation beyond observing.

Protestants worship the same God as us but we may not partake in their communion nor their altar calls or anything else really.
Right.
 
You cannot bow to the Guru Granth Sahib as this would be idolatry, though I believe you may participate in Langar as this is not specifically an act of worship and has no specific overtones of worship. You may observe the acts of worship but not participate.

The other posters are right, Sikhs have only one God.
I’d like to make a correction. Siks don’t bow down to GGS rather they bow down to the Word of God. Just as kneeling b4 the cross isn’t idolatry, bowing down b4 GGS isn’t idolatry because we really aren’t worshiping GGS. When Christians kneel b4 the cross they are kneeling to God’s glory not the crucifix itself. same thing here. tho i do understand that it may feel uncomfortable to do so, especially if ur not Sikh, but it has no idolatry in it. 🙂 and another correction, Guru Nanak is a saint, not a god.
 
It is slightly more complicated than that. You cannot take part in the religious ceremony at any level of participation beyond observing.

Protestants worship the same God as us but we may not partake in their communion nor their altar calls or anything else really.
that makes a lot of sense now. thanx 🙂
 
I’d like to make a correction. Siks don’t bow down to GGS rather they bow down to the Word of God. Just as kneeling b4 the cross isn’t idolatry, bowing down b4 GGS isn’t idolatry because we really aren’t worshiping GGS. When Christians kneel b4 the cross they are kneeling to God’s glory not the crucifix itself. same thing here. tho i do understand that it may feel uncomfortable to do so, especially if ur not Sikh, but it has no idolatry in it. 🙂 and another correction, Guru Nanak is a saint, not a god.
But, as you know, the Catholic Church does not teach that the words in the Guru Granth Sahib are the word of God, so it is innappropriate for a Catholic to bow before it.

I didn’t say Guru Nanak is considered God did I? I certainly never intended to imply it anyway.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top