Catholic Apologetics on Homosexuality?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Eliza10
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

Eliza10

Guest
I am wondering if anyone can direct me to some good Catholic teaching on homosexuality online. I am thinking perhaps in a format of answers-to-common questions/protests about our teaching? Or a columnist who explains our position particularly well?

I am going to visit with an old friend soon who now has developed some pretty militant stances in defense of the gay lifestyle, which is in fact now her lifestyle, which is why she defends it so. Perhaps its more accurate to say of her that she is very much indoctrinated in the common stances of today’s culture on this issue.

I’m not really looking forward to discussing the topic with her since she is so married to it, but if she brings up the Church and its teachings I want to be able to explain them well and charitably, and maybe even leave her with something to think about. But I need to read up. I have no time to obtain and read a book before then, though.
 
CONGREGATION FOR THE DOCTRINE OF THE FAITH
LETTER TO THE BISHOPS OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH
ON THE PASTORAL CARE OF HOMOSEXUAL PERSONS

vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19861001_homosexual-persons_en.html

This is very good.

Here is another one.

CONGREGATION FOR THE DOCTRINE OF THE FAITH
CONSIDERATIONS REGARDING PROPOSALS
TO GIVE LEGAL RECOGNITION
TO UNIONS
BETWEEN HOMOSEXUAL PERSONS

vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20030731_homosexual-unions_en.html
 
Eliza, have you searched the files at the Catholic Answers homepage?

For example:

Homosexuality (written by Jim Blackburn and published in the magazine This Rock)
catholic.com/thisrock/2006/0604btb.asp

Homosexuality (written by the COURAGE Apostolate)
(a tougher chew, but COURAGE is the Catholic organization dedicated to helping homosexuals live celibate lives)
catholic.com/library/Homosexuality.asp

Quick Questions related to homosexuality
(this is kind of a grab bag, rather than organized in a sequence, however the questions are interesting)
catholic.com/thisrock/quickquestions/keyword/homosexuality
 
I am wondering if anyone can direct me to some good Catholic teaching on homosexuality online. I am thinking perhaps in a format of answers-to-common questions/protests about our teaching? Or a columnist who explains our position particularly well?

I am going to visit with an old friend soon who now has developed some pretty militant stances in defense of the gay lifestyle, which is in fact now her lifestyle, which is why she defends it so. Perhaps its more accurate to say of her that she is very much indoctrinated in the common stances of today’s culture on this issue.

I’m not really looking forward to discussing the topic with her since she is so married to it, but if she brings up the Church and its teachings I want to be able to explain them well and charitably, and maybe even leave her with something to think about. But I need to read up. I have no time to obtain and read a book before then, though.
What you may call ‘lifestyle’, i’m sure she considers her life. Too many religious people think that gay people just wake up one day and think, ‘hey, i’m going to play for the other team from now on.’ As if they werent always like that, only because you think that god doesnt make people that way. Well a major flaw in that logic is why would god ‘make’ handicapped people? Why would he make child molestors or sociopaths?

Have you known any gay people? Most people who condemn them usually have no history of being friends or having them in the family. Homosexuality isnt just about getting your rocks off, its a form of love as well.

My suggestion is to be supportive of her, don’t be combative or you just may lose your old friend.
 
Thank you for the links. Right here on this site too.

Mulder, you have made many assumptions here. At least I can see what gay lifestyle advocates think that I think. I wonder why you ask if I have known gay people. I wonder where you get the idea I am condemning gay people? Please don’t jump to conclusions and don’t be so quick to be a judge.

In this case its my friend who is likely to be combative She is always all-out for what she believes in. However, I have seen her do about-faces over the years. And that is what I am hoping for someday - and I believe that is possible especially because of her previous devotion to Our Lady.

I agree - its pretty much impossible for a gay person to wake up and decide to “play for the other team”. But I also know that we can do all things through Christ who strengthens us. And I know that the intercession of Our Lady is powerful and efficacious indeed.
 
It probably won’t sound charitable to tell a person that their desires are intrinsically morally evil (more or less). Go for a lighter approach, perhaps.
 
It probably won’t sound charitable to tell a person that their desires are intrinsically morally evil (more or less). Go for a lighter approach, perhaps.
Oh, most certainly! The “grave depravity” and “intrinsically disordered” phrases would very quickly shut down any communication. After those remarks, all there would be would be two people talking past one another.
 
So far what I’ve seen in the responses are of a general inference concerning homosexuality. Does anyone have Scriptural reference supporting the Scripture that has been quoted?
 
So far what I’ve seen in the responses are of a general inference concerning homosexuality. Does anyone have Scriptural reference supporting the Scripture that has been quoted?
Leviticus 18:22: 'You shall not lie with a male as one lies with a female; it is an abomination.
New American Standard Translation
Some more verses here
 
here is what no one is talking about and as an apostle of Jesus He has me to tell all…

The Church has already established the inclinations and urges, passions are disordered and Not Truth. So this means that True Love is ordered is Truth which is man and a woman…
further…Jesus also demonstrates in the gospel Himself that a man can look at a woman and STILL sin without having ever done an outward act, correct…that is fact not opinion. In fact He says it is better to gouge out an eye than to be thrown into hell, implying GRAVE and SERIOUS MATTER
Since I am an apostle of His Sacred Heart and the Immaculate and in Union with Him. It is like this:

A soul with homosexual tendency, that has disordered inclinations and urges to be with another of the same sex can STILL commit grave sin in His Heart without ever doing one OUTWARD act. For all sin first starts in the heart.
A man may view pornography without ever stimulating his gentials yet giving in, in his heart, thru free will after these urges and disordered love, is still sin,self love it is called by the Saints.
So you may have a soul who has homosexual tendency that has done not outward sign to give into this act yet has already given in within and it is still sin…that is from Our Lord…
so to say and promote I am homosexual has already implied I have given into the disorder in my heart, this is indeed sin.
It is a disorder and a trial a Cross used by the Lord to bring a soul thru suffering more closer to the Light through purgation where the soul may then be freed of this sin.

Thus I have to go in and correct priests, bishops, and even cardinals and so forth…this is how Jesus sees it, this is His Heart. Love ordered. Yet we are called to Love souls with homosexual tendency to help them see this Truth. One does not going around promoting I am an alcoholic with pride, nor does one who has a panic attack disorder which I did before my conversion, come out with pride promoting such. It needs to stop today inside the Holy Church. The Spirit of Homosexuality is already in the Church including the clergy, to think otherwise is ignorant in my apostleship for the Lord I see it daily.
We must pray, fast and continue to suffer in Union with Our Lord, but espicially for this particular sin

the Word of God is comprised of two sources check the Catechism…
Scripture and Tradition (oral and written)

ill leave a site with both speaking on the sin of homosexuality

in the areas of Tradition there are interesting reads

scripturecatholic.com/homosexuality.html
 
private revelation from the Saints, and it is in Divine revelation that the Church will fall away from the Faith…

dividing over Homosexuality…that is why we must stand on the true Faith…

“The Church will be punished because the majority of Her members, high and low, will become so perverted. The Church will sink deeper and deeper until She will at last seem to be extinguished, and the succession of Peter and the other Apostles to have expired. But, after this, She will be victoriously exalted in the sight of all doubters. St. Nicholas von Flue (15th century)

“Among the strangest things that I saw, were long processions of bishops. Their thoughts and utterances were made known to me through images issuing from their mouths. Their faults towards religion were shown by external deformities. A few had only a body, with a dark cloud of fog instead of a head. Others had only a head, their bodies and hearts were like thick vapors. Some were lame; others were paralytics; others were asleep or staggering.” Ven Anna Emerich

“I saw what I believe to be nearly all the bishops of the world, but only a small number were perfectly sound…” Ven Anna Emerich

I saw that many pastors allowed themselves to be taken up with ideas that were dangerous to the Church. They were building a great, strange, and extravagant Church. Everyone was to be admitted in it in order to be united and have equal rights: Evangelicals, Catholics, sects of every description. Such was to be the new Church…” Ven Emerich

“… there is good reason to fear lest this great perversity may be as it were a foretaste, and perhaps the beginning of those evils which are reserved for the last days. Pius X

“Mankind must prepare itself for sufferings such as it has never before experienced.” This comment comes from the Pope who lived through World War I and World War II! He expressed dismay at what he saw facing humanity in the not so distant future, describing those times as “the darkest since the deluge.” Pius XII
 
Leviticus 18:22: 'You shall not lie with a male as one lies with a female; it is an abomination.
New American Standard Translation
Some more verses here
and·with
male not you-shall-lie-down beds-of woman abhorrence she

22
Thou shalt not lie with
mankind,
as
with
womankind:
it
[is]
abomination.

Westminster Leningrad Codex scripture4all.org/OnlineInterlinea …

dictionary.reference.com/browse/abhorr …

Note that the Westminster Leningrad Codex is legitimate and is used to fill in ancient Hebrew manuscripts that have missing passages, pages, etc.

Note that the mechanical translation uses “abhorrence” and is translated “abomination.” Look up the dictionary definition of “abhorrence.”

Legitimate translation: Leviticus 20:25,26.

and·with
male not you-shall-lie-down beds-of woman abhorrence she

and·you(p)-cseparate between
the·beast the·clean to·the·unclean and·between
the·flyer

the·unclean to·the·clean and·not
you(p)-shall-make-abominable »
souls-of·you(p) in·the·beast

and·in·the·flyer and·in·anything which she-is-moving the·ground which
I-cseparated for·you(p)

and·you(p)-become to·me holy-ones that holy
I
Yahweh and·I-am-cseparating »·you(p)

from
the·peoples to·to-become-of for·me

25
Ye shall therefore put
difference between clean
beasts and unclean, and
between unclean fowls and
clean: and ye shall not make
your souls abominable by
beast, or by fowl, or by any
manner of living thing that
creepeth on the ground,
which I have separated
from you as unclean.

26
And ye shall be holy
unto me: for I the LORD
[am] holy, and have severed
you from [other] people,
that ye should be mine.

Leviticus 20:25,26 defines abomination.

No reference to sin.

Leviticus 18:22; abomination=abhorrent(Westminster Leningrad Codex)=disgusting(Mechanical Translation); dictionary definition of abhorrent, disgusting; no translation uses the word sin, what makes you think that abomination means sin?
Any other interpretation is pure speculation. False, unless you can document that it says sin.

I take it that this verse has really nothing to do with condemning homosexuality as a sin. Catholicism does not condemn homosexuality as a sin. I contend that the Bible neither condemns nor supports homosexuality. Every passage used can be explained without reference to condemnation of homosexuality.

This passage is a simple one but pay close attention to the words in bold print especially, the word “lies.” What is the implied meaning of the plural word “lies?” From this word one begins to understand that the passage has a far different meaning condemning male-male intercourse. And so, what is the real emphasis of this passage?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top