Catholic Artists--Do you self-censor? Why, why not?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Nom_the_Wise
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think this is especially true in much Christian music as well. IMO, it actually does a disservice to God and hinders evangelization. If the only art us Christians have to offer is a dim reflection of our secular counterparts, how can God be all that great? We should give God the best we have to offer!
Okay, not to be a blog-hog on my own thread (did I invent a term?) but you’ve hit on something, and I’ll be brief.

I am a musician, and I did write songs for years, and made many attempts at Praise and Worship music, with unimaginative chord progressions, and lyrics that sounded like homosexual love songs (I love Him!). 😊 I gave up.

What has happened to the great Catholic artistic imagination! The Church patronized most of the great art of the past. Where is our innovation? Why haven’t we spawned a new renaissance in Catholic/Christian art? Are we “self-censoring” to be dogmatic? Out of fear? Anyone want to run with this?

(cough step down from soap box, clop, clop, clop clop clop
 
Okay, not to be a blog-hog on my own thread (did I invent a term?) but you’ve hit on something, and I’ll be brief.
Sorry, I don’t think you invented the term. I did a google search for “blog-hog” and it yielded 15,500 results. 😃
What has happened to the great Catholic artistic imagination! The Church patronized most of the great art of the past. Where is our innovation? Why haven’t we spawned a new renaissance in Catholic/Christian art? Are we “self-censoring” to be dogmatic? Out of fear? Anyone want to run with this?
:amen: Bring back great Catholic art!

I don’t know if “self-censoring” is to blame. I think part of the reason is the influx of means of social communications coupled with the great increase in leisure time. Entertainment (which is basically popular art) is a huge business. There are tons of magazines, books, blogs, songs, etc., etc. that are out there for the public to consume. The internet, especially, offers an audience to those of us who may not even be trained for a particular art.

Now, there are advantages and disadvantages to all this, but, generally speaking, I think it makes it much easier for sub-par artists to have a voice and get their stuff out there. It often seems that the higher quality art gets drowned out in the sea of mediocrity.

Of course, these are completely my own anecdotal musings, so take them for what they’re worth (:twocents: …maybe less…).
 
But I am responsible for that message as well. I want it to be uplifting and hopeful not dark and
dysfunctional or intentionally offensive in a nihilistic way.
I agree. But a topic that comes up sometimes is “honest” or “actual” portrayal of what it is to be human.

Being “intentionally offensive” is off limits for me as well. BUT I have struggled with the art I have created (for me, poems and music) when I was struggling with my faith. We are not always hopeful. We despair, we lash out etc. I look at it like reading the biographies of the saints. Why do we read the biographies of the saints? I read them because the church says they are “models” of Christian life, and I want to know where they messed up. I read the saints for edification. “Hey, they made it! And look what they had to go through.”

So a further broadening of “do you self-censor” could be, **can despair ever be a legitimate subject and still be apart from being intentionally scandalous?
 
What has happened to the great Catholic artistic imagination! The Church patronized most of the great art of the past. Where is our innovation? Why haven’t we spawned a new renaissance in Catholic/Christian art? Are we “self-censoring” to be dogmatic? Out of fear? Anyone want to run with this?
I’ll bite. If an absolutely phenomenal Catholic/Christian art were to come down the pike, where would you hear of it?

Christian radio has a very specific set of guidelines as to what they play. In short, they are appealing to a very large niche group, namely, soccor Moms (aka “Becky”). “Safe for the whole family” is their mantra. Out the window are all songs that have anything remotely, poetically challenging, or doctrinally geared towards a single denomination (no Catholic-writ songs on purgatory, Mary, pope, etc, but also no Presbyterian rock songs either).

So you think quality Christian art does not exist? THINK AGAIN. Two years ago, according to metacritic.com (secular), the TOP album was Sufjan Stevens’ “Illinoise” (or, “Come on feel the Illinoise!”). That album contains songs that are as pro-faith and pro-God and as steered away from Christian-ese as one possibly can get, but it doesn’t take a magnifying glass to catch the themes he wished to convey. Many secular critics understood this, and they raved about the album anyway.

Just TODAY, the NY Times has a column on Ten Great Christian Rock songs from a secular Jew. Some songs I recognize, some I didn’t… just goes to show that there’s a huge influx of quality music being made, and not all of it is being marketed effectively, nor are radio stations playing them.

And Catholic Radio stations? They don’t play Catholic songs. Catholic Jukebox, a miniscule 30-minute program (compared to 24/7 for Christian radio music), recently ceased to exist because of increased fees from ASCAP/BMI. Catholics don’t support their radio stations, and this is what we get.

So the question you posed, like it or not, conveys your own ignorance on this matter. (It’s not your fault). Best to go to sites like www.topcatholicsongs.com to get yourself reaquainted with the scene.
 
I agree. But a topic that comes up sometimes is “honest” or “actual” portrayal of what it is to be human.

Being “intentionally offensive” is off limits for me as well. BUT I have struggled with the art I have created (for me, poems and music) when I was struggling with my faith. We are not always hopeful. We despair, we lash out etc. I look at it like reading the biographies of the saints. Why do we read the biographies of the saints? I read them because the church says they are “models” of Christian life, and I want to know where they messed up. I read the saints for edification. “Hey, they made it! And look what they had to go through.”

So a further broadening of “do you self-censor” could be, **can despair *ever ***be a legitimate subject and still be apart from being intentionally scandalous?
I think so.

Tolkien dealt with the sin of despair and its consequences in his LOTR trilogy. In Return of the King, one of the leaders gives in to despair and we see fully realized the action and all its ramifications (a scene that was, unfortunately, truncated in the film version).

But we also see despair contrasted against hope, in many of the other characters. If you can pull that off, you’ve got a work of art for the ages.
 
The story of the hero is the story of the one who overcomes great fear, great despair and in a few cases, life itself. For the Christian, we are told that the more we know Christ and imitate Him the more authentically human we become for He was True God and True Man.

In the modern/post-modern world, the artist needs to know where his inspiration comes from. Does it come from the self-appointed art critics and museum curators? A priest-like heirarchy that decides what will and what will not be shown? Does it come from a small group that defines the icons of our age for the rest of us? The same could be said for music.

Or does the inspiration come from some virtue? As Christians, we are told that we will suffer, that we will be refined like gold in the fire. That a capacity for real love requires a capacity to suffer as well. The saints, even in the face of their own admitted failings, looked beyond themselves to a real person who they recognized as working in their lives.

The outside world looks to its own devices, to a muse that is not God. Too often I read about artists being encouraged to offend or that they are not responsible if their audience does not understand their work.

In the 1950s and even 1960s, how many singers started out in Gospel?

God bless,
Ed
 
lyrics that sounded like homosexual love songs (I love Him!).
YES! Somebody finally, finally, finally said it!

Nom, thank you so much – you’ve said what I’ve thought about that drivel for years. Whenever I inadvertently listen to that sort of music I don’t hear ‘bow down and worship’, I hear ‘hi, I’m soooo gay for Jesus!’ You guys should have stuck with chant and left rock for people who can actually rock (and to be sure, many of those are Christian, but they don’t let that get in the way of art) 😉

Moving on… interesting perspectives from a lot of people. Not being Catholic, I suppose I can’t answer the question exactly, but I’m solidly in the ‘what needs to be there will be there’ camp. I don’t censor, because I don’t need to: if I find a subject repulsive and ‘utterly without redeeming social importance’, to steal a line from Tom Lehrer, why would I bother to cover it in the first place?
can despair ever be a legitimate subject?
Looks like somebody hasn’t read much Russian lit… Crime and Punishment? Notes From Underground?
 
No, I just take things at a different angle than expected from the explicit meaning of the request (Kenshin, you remember that story I wrote: the requester obviously wanted loli but I had a very different idea for it). I normally write on prompts, and I write for fandom rather than “the real world”, so I’ve got that luxury, 😃

But no, I don’t self-censor. I take my idea, whatever it is, and write it. If I’m not glorifying evil, just showing it as it is, I see no point in censorship.
 
So you think quality Christian art does not exist? THINK AGAIN.
I didn’t say that it doesn’t exist. But it is rare. And your response shows that I’ve hit the nerve that I was more or less groping for in the dark. I’ve brought this discussion *here *because I haven’t been able to have it anywhere else. And it always gets convoluted. This further broadens the definition of self-censorship. **We censor ourselves to please “the market.” **I was hoping this thread would become an artistic statement in and of itself. How lame to merely debate the use of the f-word, or whether it’s sinful to paint nudes (though these are still matters to be taken seriously, but we’re going deeper now).

There are different kinds of art. Art as a ministry tool, as **jmcrae **points out, is *very effective *and I’ve written songs for retreats myself. I gave up on “Christian music” years ago, as this was the typical paradigm:

**Verse 1: **
There you are–you’re very sad.
X has happened to you.
Wah wah wah.

**Verse 2: **
And you over there!
Y is a struggle for you.
But where will you turn?
Who can help you?

Chorus:
[slow drum crescendo, power chords, women’s choir]
IT’S JESUS! Yes, Jesus [glittering adjective, glittering adjective]
etc.

Has it changed? And I should say to Mirdath, post #27, despite the fact that you made me laugh, it’s the Protestant rock acts that were *mostly *guilty for the “hi, I’m *soooo *gay for Jesus!” songs, as you put it (**not **to be combative, but as Nick pointed out, Catholic acts in contemporary Christian music are few).
So the question you posed, like it or not, conveys your own ignorance on this matter. (It’s not your fault).
I’ll take that bloody nose, though I appreciate you pulling the punch a little. I am ignorant to a degree. In terms of my failed participation in Christian music, I used to try to emulate the contemporary scene, and ended up with soppy sentimentalism. That’s not an accusation against anyone; it’s a confession. What I had been robbed of is a culture of art that the media wouldn’t let me see. I think many live in that vacuum still. And I don’t mean to use the media as a pawn, because sometimes you just don’t know that you don’t know. If you’ve never heard of the grail, you won’t know to go on a quest.

But then I went to art school and read “the greats.” Dryden, Keats, (more of course). I had already read Tokien, but didn’t really understand him until later. This is just on the writer’s side of things. It was then I realized how bankrupt my soul was by listening to that contemporary drivel. I began to understand artistic expression and craft, which transformed everything I did. I’m not famous. Even if you knew my real name you wouldn’t have heard of me, but if you google search my real name I get a little over a page. I’m still pushing my way in, as it were.
If an absolutely phenomenal Catholic/Christian art were to come down the pike, where would you hear of it?
If conditions remain as they are, you wouldn’t hear of it.
Christian radio has a very specific set of guidelines as to what they play. In short, they are appealing to a very large niche group, namely, soccor Moms (aka “Becky”). “Safe for the whole family” is their mantra. Out the window are all songs that have anything remotely, poetically challenging, or doctrinally geared towards a single denomination (no Catholic-writ songs on purgatory, Mary, pope, etc, but also no Presbyterian rock songs either).
To be fair, I’m not advocating “doctrinally geared” art. You can’t sit down and say “I’m going to write a poem about the Pope and how wonderful he is.” Soppy, soppy, soppy. But the quote above is exactly what I went through. I let radio programmers dictate to me what “type” of song I should write, rather than write from my perspective
Catholics don’t support their radio stations, and this is what we get
. They don’t owe us anything. If we, as Catholics, aren’t producing groundshaking art, our audience has no duty to us. And I visited your web page. To be able to do “orthodox/parody” songs is actually new. It sounds like you’re a trailblazer.

I have more…
 
And I should say to Mirdath, post #27, despite the fact that you made me laugh, it’s the Protestant rock acts that were *mostly *guilty for the “hi, I’m *soooo *gay for Jesus!” songs, as you put it (**not **to be combative, but as Nick pointed out, Catholic acts in contemporary Christian music are few).
I do realize that, or at least that Protestants perform the bulk of sappy turbo-Christian poprock – since I actively try to avoid it, I can’t really speak to the Catholic-Protestant divide in that niche. I was playing for laughs though 😉

I’m not saying Christian music or art in general sucks. I have a huge collection of requiem masses, some Gregorian chant, and I’ve been trying to find a certain disc of Shaker hymns for a while – and I don’t even believe in God! Religion is one of the greatest inspirations for the arts the world has known (along with drugs and death and a few other subjects); it’s just that a particular set of people have forgotten how to use it well.
 
I didn’t say that it doesn’t exist. But it is rare. And your response shows that I’ve hit the nerve that I was more or less groping for in the dark. I’ve brought this discussion *here *because I haven’t been able to have it anywhere else. And it always gets convoluted. This further broadens the definition of self-censorship. **We censor ourselves to please “the market.” **I was hoping this thread would become an artistic statement in and of itself. How lame to merely debate the use of the f-word, or whether it’s sinful to paint nudes (though these are still matters to be taken seriously, but we’re going deeper now).
I think the issue is not that great Christian art is not being produced, but that it can be very difficult to find (especially for those who do not know where to look). That’s what I took Nom’s point to be, anyway. 🤷

There’s probably a variety of factors that play into this. First, the secular arts seem to dominate the Christian arts making it more difficult for Christian artists to get noticed. Judging from the comments of many here, that may be a tide that is soon turning.

Second, even looking at Christian art by itself, one has to sift through good and not so good in a way that’s a bit different from their secular counterparts. Perhaps this is because we Christians can be so starved for anything that is God -centered rather than some of the hedonistic secular art, that we will buy it just because it’s not morally offensive. In a sense, I guess we’ve lowered our standards. I think that goes for secular art, too, though.
 
Here is a kind-of a summary of what’s been happening here, as I see it:

Part of what got me going in this direction at all was an essay in Poetry, September 2006. Here’s a link:

poetrymagazine.org/magazine/0906/comment_178560.html

It’s haunted me ever since. If you read it, John Barr talks about Art/Poetry in this century:
John Barr: For all its schools and experiments, contemporary poetry is still written in the rain shadow thrown by Modernism. It is the engine that drives what is written today. And it is a tired engine.
Now he’s not talking about Catholic/Christian poetry, but the art of poetry overall. His call for “a new poetry” is what made me think about this in reference to the fact that I’m a Catholic poet. I have found myself, as a Catholic, censoring myself. My use of “Catholic material” is often criticized, and when it’s not, often the reader/listener believes I am mocking the church, and like dzenmarek’s example post #2, when it was learned that I wasn’t mocking, I was mocked, or worse, ignored. Or *an entire poem *is labled as worthless by believers because I happened to feel the need to use the f-word, entirely dependent on the context.

If you look at any college art text, they are overwhelmingly filled with Biblical/Christian/Catholic/Orthodox/Byzantine art. The Church once dominated the art field. I wonder if painting and sculpture overall aren’t in the same boat as poetry, as music and cinema have crushed all other mediums beneath their feet. Perhaps Picasso was just the Brittany Spears of his day.
John Barr: Groundbreaking new art comes when artists make a changed assumption about their relationship to their audience, talk to their readers in a new way, and assume they will understand.
I’m quoting this because it speaks to this assumption that artists must “assume [their audience] will understand.” So that means creating art from your spiritual/moral/craftsperson center, rather than “self-censoring” because you fear no one will buy it, soccer moms won’t get it, Protestant radio stations won’t play it, or that the Pope will crosier your cranium.

To paraphrase the movie *Field of Dreams *“If you build it, [they] will come.”
  1. God/inspiration
  2. Artist
  3. medium (paint/sculpture/music/writing)
  4. Art piece
  5. audience (?)
  6. Money (?)
 
Here is a kind-of a summary of what’s been happening here, as I see it:

Part of what got me going in this direction at all was an essay in Poetry, September 2006. Here’s a link:

poetrymagazine.org/magazine/0906/comment_178560.html
Innnteresting that you should mention Poetry magazine. I stopped my subscription when they started including gutter language. If I wanted that garbage I could go to some open-mic poetry slam and save the forty bucks. :rolleyes:
 
I am working on my MFA right now. Fortunately, I am in a figurative painting program at a college which values traditional forms of art. So while my work is not religious in nature, I am not being pressured to go “post-modern”, or to be offensive or controversial just for the sake of it, in the same way that I was when I was working on my undergrad at another art college in the late 80’s and early 90’s.

As for the high-end art world, traditional art is slowly making a comeback, but it is still a tight niche. I am not so concerned with breaking into that; I will very happy if I manage to get gallery representation and reasonably steady sales so that I can contribute to the support of our family.
So where do we find a Catholic Art portal? I would love to buy a few pieces of Catholic Art, and would rather buy directly from the artist. I know ebay has many self-representing artists, but I haven’t seen that much in terms of Catholic art.
 
Innnteresting that you should mention Poetry magazine. I stopped my subscription when they started including gutter language. If I wanted that garbage I could go to some open-mic poetry slam and save the forty bucks. :rolleyes:
Okay, so you mean *any *cuss word is out? Let’s say you bought a book of poetry, and **loved **all the poems but there happened to be a use of the f-word on page 28 and maybe the s-word on page 42. Is the poet and his entire book to be reviled, or do you forgive the use of one or two cuss words, knowing that the poet, in those two instances, felt they were required? And you found out the poet was a Catholic.

This is a *serious *question. I’m taking notes. A couple of my already-published poems contain the f- or s- words, and I can edit cusses out as I submit the manuscript to first book contests. I want Catholics to be proud of me. And you especially, because you read Tolkien.
 
Okay, so you mean *any *cuss word is out? Let’s say you bought a book of poetry, and **loved **all the poems but there happened to be a use of the f-word on page 28 and maybe the s-word on page 42. Is the poet and his entire book to be reviled, or do you forgive the use of one or two cuss words, knowing that the poet, in those two instances, felt they were required? And you found out the poet was a Catholic.

This is a *serious *question. I’m taking notes. A couple of my already-published poems contain the f- or s- words, and I can edit cusses out as I submit the manuscript to first book contests. I want Catholics to be proud of me. And you especially, because you read Tolkien.
I’d have to answer yes. The use of these words offends me.

And another point: I want the widest possible audience for my work. Were there modern-day curse words in Tolkien’s narrative?

The use of such words, in most cases, just indicates the writer has a limited vocabulary and a more limited perspective.
 
I think the issue is not that great Christian art is not being produced, but that it can be very difficult to find (especially for those who do not know where to look). That’s what I took Nom’s point to be, anyway. 🤷
Two word response: google reviews.

There’s enough christian review sites out there that issue objective reviews of great Christian music.

lookingcloser.wordpress.com and lookingcloser.org
artsandfaith.com
tollbooth.org
patrolmag.com
even christianitytoday.com has a good music review section.

If you’re looking for specifically Catholic music, there’s a couple of sites to consider, namely www.gvonline.net and www.topcatholicsongs.com, both of which I work with. spiritandsong.com is trying to find new ways to promote their music, and ucmva.org is going after the Dove Award/Grammy Award approach.

Working with topcatholicsongs.com, one of the things I’ve discovered about Catholic music is that, unlike much of secular music, there is a function to the music. There is an ulterior motive. To some, having an “agenda/message” harms the music… but these same complainers don’t raise a single red flag when they hear Bob Dylan’s “Masters of War” or Tears For Fears’ “Everybody Wants to Rule the World”–similar songs with a message. Not every song has to enter nonsensical Talking Heads/Duran Duran territory (and I write this as a fan of both approaches).

But what separates Catholic music, more than anything else, is that the message has a dominant theme that is specifically geared towards Catholic orthodoxy. Bob Rice’s “I Shall Be Healed” or Mike Harrison/Greg Walton’s “Acclamation” both use Eucharistic texts in powerful new settings (and these settings may or may not be appropriate for liturgy… but the point is the songs stand). At TopCatholicSongs, we have created playlists incorporating Lenten, Holy Week, Easter themes. We just created a playlist incorporating all the themes of “Christ our Hope”–which was the theme of the Pope’s trip to America. We will be creating lists of Top Mary Songs (for May) and Top Holy Spirit Songs (for Pentecost Sunday) to be released in the National Catholic Register. When the “Year of St. Paul” officially begins, we will have lists of top songs dedicated to the person, ministry, and writings of St. Paul.

Do I really think that a continual listen of these thematic-based songs, regardless of musical style, origin, or century, in union with the Church calendar and mission, is going to affect your spiritual walk? Whoo boy, yeah.
 
Do you fear one day your rough drafts will be discovered and your cause for canonization destroyed? Do you feel the f-word is sometimes appropriate? And then someone comes along and says “What if Jesus read that poem? How would you feel then?”
What if Jesus read that poem? So what? He’s read your thoughts, and if your writing isn’t true to your thoughts, then you’re not being true to yourself. How would Jesus be pleased with that?

I’d say the content matters more than the occasional f-word. If your language is clean most of the time, that occasional swear word, when describing the very extremes of human emotion, can have the appropriate power to disturb that it deserves. Profanity is appropriate when something is appropriately profane, but not every other word, and not in front of the children.

The Victorians used to censor Shakespeare, because they thought him too vulgar. Now we have schools scared to teach Mark Twain because he uses the N-word. The fact is, Shakespeare and Twain make their characters real by making them speak the way real people speak, and not flinching from the difficult stuff that happens in human life, like racism, violence and adultery. As long as you’re not promoting those things, I don’t see the problem. By showing vulgarity in all its’ vulgarness, you help to turn people away from it, and allow beauty to be appreciated in contrast.

Mother Teresa’s private correspondence where she talks about her darkest inner thoughts were discovered, and that didn’t seem to destroy her cause for canonization, quite the opposite.

Have you ever heard of the Heralds of the Gospel, these guys have a real passion for art and beauty in the Church. Gotta love those habits too! heralds.ca/
 
I am not sure what you mean by censor. It can mean anything from writing for particular audience (which is more akin to editing) to sanitizing a piece
even to the point of mutilating it to make it meet some arbitrary standard. The first I think is legitimate, the second is a kind of prostitution.

**Gregory Wolfe **is Editor of “Image”, a quarterly journal that deals with Faith and Religion in the arts (writing and visual). Greg and his wife, Suzanne, also a writer, are very traditional Roman Catholic. I have found Image, and the yearly Glen Workshop (Santa Fe, NM) unique in that while it brings together artists whose Traditional Christian Faith and Art are inseparable. I don’t think you can label art “Christian”, “non-Christian”, “Catholic”, etc."
Art is a kind of incarnation of that which you value and struggle and strive towards. Tolkien would be horrified to have his writing l labeled as “Christian” or Catholic". Greg says it much better than I can, using Eliot’s Four Quartets as a theme…

"The Humiliation of the Word" by Gregory Wolfe given as part of a commencement address for first graduating class of the Seattle Pacific University Master of Fine Arts degree in creative writing, August 4, 2007.
"…Nonetheless, Eliot holds that literature can serve as a countervailing force to the shrill voices that are too much with us. Literature is language shaped in such a way that readers are drawn inward toward a still point, the place where mystery and beauty re-saturate words with meaning. As a ghost-poet says to Eliot late in the poem, the mission of literature is to “purify the dialect of the tribe.”…
Eliot understands these fears, but he has wrested a modicum of hope from his own long vocation as a writer:
“What we call the beginning is often the end /And to make an end is to make a beginning. /The end is where we start from.” By repeating the word “end” Eliot is up to his old linguistic tricks, piling various meanings on top of one another. “End” is not only a cessation, conclusion, mortality but also a goal, fulfillment, destiny—what a thing is made for…
As writers, then, we can gain some confidence that our words may contain their end in their beginning.
Everything we write is a “raid on the inarticulate,” at once utterly insufficient and utterly necessary. And unless our words are firmly grounded in the flesh and suffer the passion of our fallen condition, they will become lifeless abstractions and join the shrieking voices that dominate our culture—and our churches. This is the challenge you have faced. The difficulty of the task remains. "
Here is a link to some more of his editorials. Hope you find them more helpful than my poorly expressed ideas.

imagejournal.org/page/journal/editorial-statements/
 
Two word response: google reviews.

There’s enough christian review sites out there that issue objective reviews of great Christian music.
Thanks for all those links, Nick! I know where to look on the net for info on Catholic teaching, but not Catholic art. Those sites should help me a great deal! 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top