So you think quality Christian art does not exist? THINK AGAIN.
I didn’t say that it doesn’t exist. But it is
rare. And your response shows that I’ve hit the nerve that I was more or less groping for in the dark. I’ve brought this discussion *here *because I haven’t been able to have it anywhere else. And it always gets convoluted. This further broadens the definition of self-censorship. **We censor ourselves to please “the market.” **I was hoping this thread would become an artistic statement in and of itself. How lame to merely debate the use of the f-word, or whether it’s sinful to paint nudes (though these are still matters to be taken seriously, but we’re going deeper now).
There are different kinds of art. Art as a ministry tool, as **jmcrae **points out, is *very effective *and I’ve written songs for retreats myself. I gave up on “Christian music” years ago, as this was the typical paradigm:
**Verse 1: **
There you are–you’re very sad.
X has happened to you.
Wah wah wah.
**Verse 2: **
And you over there!
Y is a struggle for you.
But where will you turn?
Who can help you?
Chorus:
[slow drum crescendo, power chords, women’s choir]
IT’S
JESUS! Yes, Jesus [glittering adjective, glittering adjective]
etc.
Has it changed? And I should say to
Mirdath, post #27, despite the fact that you made me laugh, it’s the Protestant rock acts that were *mostly *guilty for the “hi, I’m *soooo *gay for Jesus!” songs, as you put it (**not **to be combative, but as Nick pointed out, Catholic acts in contemporary Christian music are few).
So the question you posed, like it or not, conveys your own ignorance on this matter. (It’s not your fault).
I’ll take that bloody nose, though I appreciate you pulling the punch a little. I am ignorant to a degree. In terms of my failed participation in Christian music, I used to try to emulate the contemporary scene, and ended up with soppy sentimentalism. That’s not an accusation against anyone; it’s a
confession. What I had been robbed of is a culture of art that the media wouldn’t let me see. I think many live in that vacuum still. And I don’t mean to use the media as a pawn, because
sometimes you just don’t know that you don’t know. If you’ve never heard of the grail, you won’t know to go on a quest.
But then I went to art school and read “the greats.” Dryden, Keats, (more of course). I had already read Tokien, but didn’t really understand him until later. This is just on the writer’s side of things. It was then I realized how bankrupt my soul was by listening to that contemporary drivel. I began to understand artistic expression and craft, which transformed everything I did. I’m not famous. Even if you knew my real name you wouldn’t have heard of me, but if you google search my real name I get a little over a page. I’m still pushing my way in, as it were.
If an absolutely phenomenal Catholic/Christian art were to come down the pike, where would you hear of it?
If conditions
remain as they are, you wouldn’t hear of it.
Christian radio has a very specific set of guidelines as to what they play. In short, they are appealing to a very large niche group, namely, soccor Moms (aka “Becky”). “Safe for the whole family” is their mantra. Out the window are all songs that have anything remotely, poetically challenging, or doctrinally geared towards a single denomination (no Catholic-writ songs on purgatory, Mary, pope, etc, but also no Presbyterian rock songs either).
To be fair, I’m not advocating “doctrinally geared” art. You can’t sit down and say “I’m going to write a poem about the Pope and how wonderful he is.” Soppy, soppy, soppy. But the quote above is exactly what I went through. I let radio programmers dictate to me what “type” of song I should write, rather than write from my perspective
Catholics don’t support their radio stations, and this is what we get
. They don’t owe us anything. If we, as Catholics, aren’t producing groundshaking art, our audience has no duty to us. And I visited your web page. To be able to do “orthodox/parody” songs is actually
new. It sounds like you’re a trailblazer.
I have more…