Catholic children at baptist school

  • Thread starter Thread starter ToughQs
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

ToughQs

Guest
My wife and I pulled our children from the local Catholic school because we felt they were not true to the Church. Our best alternative was a baptist school where there is great love of Christ but it’s not Catholic. At the Catholic school we had to deal a general apathy toward Jesus and His Church and it’s moral teachings on sanctity of life, sexuality, etc. The Baptist school is strong on moral issues but undermines Catholic theology (Eucharist, role of Mary, scripture vs. Scriptue, tradition and magisterium (sic). We teach our children the doctrines of our Taiyuan correct what they hear at school but are we doing damage by sending them to the baptist school? Thought comments similar experiences welcome. Btw logs are 11, 8, 6, and 5. If there were only a true Catholic school in our area!
 
Of course each situation is unique and calls for prayerful discernment.

I would have extreme reservations about sending my children to a Baptist school. Especially if they are being pulled from a Catholic school to be put there. In my mind, that could potentially send the unspoken message that the Baptists have it more right than the Catholics do, so why shouldn’t we just be Baptists?

That said, it is definitely a tough call. If you have legitimate concerns that the Catholic school in your area is effectively undermining the faith of your children rather than fostering it, then that is a great danger as well.

Whatever school you send your children to, if it is not a solid Catholic school, as a parent you’ll just have to be that much more aware of and prepared to fill in the gaps with Catholic teaching. Parents are the primary educators of their children, after all.

I’ll pray for you in your discernment.
 
Here in the South, we have very few Catholic schools and many of the children attend Christian schools. It is my feeling that any “unspoken messages” are being received by a scant few “ears”. Do they make the kids wear special insignia to show the Catholicity? Does the school send a notice to the local newspaper? According to the OP, the Baptists that run their school “have it more right” than the Catholics running the Catholic school.

Let me guess, the Catholic school cares more about the raffle ticket sales than morality.
 
I’ve had people in RCIA who were sent to Catholic schools as children even though they were Protestant. Their parents felt that the Catholic schools offered a better education. Something about Catholicism seems to have seeped in along with the spelling and arithmetic.

My guess is that sending children to a religious school is a good way to move them toward that religion as they mature and make their own decisions.
 
My wife and I pulled our children from the local Catholic school because we felt they were not true to the Church. Our best alternative was a baptist school where there is great love of Christ but it’s not Catholic. At the Catholic school we had to deal a general apathy toward Jesus and His Church and it’s moral teachings on sanctity of life, sexuality, etc. The Baptist school is strong on moral issues but undermines Catholic theology (Eucharist, role of Mary, scripture vs. Scriptue, tradition and magisterium (sic). We teach our children the doctrines of our Taiyuan correct what they hear at school but are we doing damage by sending them to the baptist school? Thought comments similar experiences welcome. Btw logs are 11, 8, 6, and 5. If there were only a true Catholic school in our area!
Yes, it is damaging to send them to a baptist school.
 
Ultimately, children will learn what is practiced in the home. You will have to determine which is the better support: a school that is “soft” in teaching faith and morals or a one that is strong in teaching morals and contradictory in teaching faith.

To me, contradictory teaching could potentially be more difficult to overcome. You would be required to not only teach your children correct doctrine but also train them to be apologists simultaneously. Doing so, however, could make them even stronger Catholics but runs the risk they get confused.
 
At what point is a Baptist school, which denies the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist, denies the need to confess to a priest, denies the entire need for a priesthood in fact, and denies the efficacy of the sacraments, including baptism - at what point is this school better than a Catholic school which is “Not true to the Church?”

Living here in the deep south, my daughter’s parish school would have to teach some pretty heretical things before I put them in a Baptist school.

-Tim-
 
My wife and I pulled our children from the local Catholic school because we felt they were not true to the Church. Our best alternative was a baptist school where there is great love of Christ but it’s not Catholic. At the Catholic school we had to deal a general apathy toward Jesus and His Church and it’s moral teachings on sanctity of life, sexuality, etc. The Baptist school is strong on moral issues but undermines Catholic theology (Eucharist, role of Mary, scripture vs. Scriptue, tradition and magisterium (sic). We teach our children the doctrines of our Taiyuan correct what they hear at school but are we doing damage by sending them to the baptist school? Thought comments similar experiences welcome. Btw logs are 11, 8, 6, and 5. If there were only a true Catholic school in our area!
I think that you asked for an opinion. If not, please erase mine.

I think it was a strong mistake to take your child from the Catholic School.

Do you want a Perfect Catholic School? In Heaven, you will get. On Earth? Impossible! Only Jesus, our Lord, is Perfect. Humans are imperfect and you are losing an occasion to teach your children the imperfection of the Catholic Church and how they must improve each day and how in Heaven we will be Perfect and how Our Lord is Perfect and Our Lady is Perfect too. I think to give to the children the idea that “your Church”, the Church that you have in mind is the “true Church” is terribly misleading for them and may lead them away from the Catholic Church.

My opinion. I am not the Pope. My opinion, only.
 
I’m speaking from personal experience here. I went to a Presbyterian school for elementary and middle school here in the South. I had Bible class every day where I was taught to be a good Fundamentalist. I was never specifically taught anything about the Church (other than the dark spots in its history, like the Crusades and how Luther was persecuted), but if it ever came up it wasn’t spoken of nicely. The teachers never said that Catholics aren’t Christians, but they did say that the Church was really corrupt and screwed up theologically, but never went into too much detail. The moral of this is that you REALLY need to look into what your children will be taught at this school before you make your decision.

Now, it might be different where you live, but where I’m from (see location), “Baptist” means anti-Catholic 90% of the time. Also, I get what you are saying about the local Catholic school. The only one in my city is known for being where parents put “bad” kids to straighten them out, and is not a high quality learning environment. Good luck and God bless!
 
If it were me, I wouldn’t put my kids in a Baptist school. Sure, the basic morals might be good there. But chances are that they will be teaching a lot of anti-Catholic theology to your children. It will be difficult for you to sort that out and teach them the truth at the same time. Something like that is just likely to confuse your children. Remember that they are just learning about the faith right now. It is much easier for a parent to be the only source of faith teachings for a child than to have the parent and school teacher be teaching things that sound similar but are in fact very different. Not all of the things the Baptist school teaches are going to be as clear-cut as the Eucharist. You will have many other issues that you will have to “re-instruct” on, and there is a good chance that you will miss a few things here and there.

It’s definitely a difficult situation, when the local Catholic school isn’t teaching things that are true to Catholic doctrine.
 
it depends on the specific Catholic school and the specific denominational school in question, and on the specific family and the children.

In general a bad Catholic school, which does not uphold and transmit Catholic teaching, does more ultimate harm to the faith of the child than does any other educational setting, even when the academic preparation (the main reason for attending school) is superior.

However a specific caveat about a Baptist or other fundamentalist Christian school–the message may be blatantly and overtly anti-Catholic and delivered in a way very hard for children to withstand. In my experience the children who develop the most doubts and problems about the faith are those exposed in their elementary and middle school years to a dual teaching, either because the parents are different faiths, or because the school and parents are at odds in what they believe and teach.
 
My wife and I pulled our children from the local Catholic school because we felt they were not true to the Church. Our best alternative was a baptist school where there is great love of Christ but it’s not Catholic. At the Catholic school we had to deal a general apathy toward Jesus and His Church and it’s moral teachings on sanctity of life, sexuality, etc. The Baptist school is strong on moral issues but undermines Catholic theology (Eucharist, role of Mary, scripture vs. Scriptue, tradition and magisterium (sic). We teach our children the doctrines of our Taiyuan correct what they hear at school but are we doing damage by sending them to the baptist school? Thought comments similar experiences welcome. Btw logs are 11, 8, 6, and 5. If there were only a true Catholic school in our area!
First, using your friends to judge the merits of catholic schools in general is a bad idea… many young adults leave the church and come back later. Prodigal sons abound, and who can say what effect Catholic schools play in THAT dynamic?

Second, sending kids to Catholic schools can only feel like an abrogation of parental duties if you do, in fact, abrogate your other parental duties. You have just as much responsibility to teach them the faith if they attend catholic school as you do if they attend public school.

On that note: why would you send them to a place that is going to actively try to teach them falsehoods about the church and destroy their faith? That can’t POSSIBLY have a better effect than sending them to a catholic shool!
 
My son spent kindergarten and first grade in a Christian school affiliated with the Church of Christ. Sometime in the middle of first grade, the subject of CCD came up on the bus. My son was told by an older child that as a Catholic he is not really a Christian and will go to hell unless he accepts Jesus as his personal savior and is born again. He did not tell me about the conversation, but when it was time to go to CCD, started crying and saying there was no point in going or preparing for the sacraments because they are all fake, and maybe God is fake, too. That was when I decided to send him to Catholic school. This experience led to a real crisis of faith for my son. The school he had been attending wasn’t actively anti-Catholic, but many of the Children who attend come from families that are. In later grades there is pressure to be baptized and your children will likely feel that same pressure.

I had been avoiding our Catholic school because of the large class size (my son has mild autism). But it has worked out. The other option was to homeschool. There is some very good Catholic homeschool materials available. Have you considered this?

From our family’s experience, I think that having your children attend a Baptist school could be harmful, particularly as they get older. Although you are teaching the faith at home, your kids are spending a lot of their time in an environment and with peers whose beliefs are very different. I will pray for you.
 
My son spent kindergarten and first grade in a Christian school affiliated with the Church of Christ. Sometime in the middle of first grade, the subject of CCD came up on the bus. My son was told by an older child that as a Catholic he is not really a Christian and will go to hell unless he accepts Jesus as his personal savior and is born again. He did not tell me about the conversation, but when it was time to go to CCD, started crying and saying there was no point in going or preparing for the sacraments because they are all fake, and maybe God is fake, too. That was when I decided to send him to Catholic school. This experience led to a real crisis of faith for my son. The school he had been attending wasn’t actively anti-Catholic, but many of the Children who attend come from families that are. In later grades there is pressure to be baptized and your children will likely feel that same pressure.

I had been avoiding our Catholic school because of the large class size (my son has mild autism). But it has worked out. The other option was to homeschool. There is some very good Catholic homeschool materials available. Have you considered this?

From our family’s experience, I think that having your children attend a Baptist school could be harmful, particularly as they get older. Although you are teaching the faith at home, your kids are spending a lot of their time in an environment and with peers whose beliefs are very different. I will pray for you.
👍
OP - my children are homeschooled so I know there are plenty of Catholic resources. Homeschooling does essentially require a full-time parent, however.
 
Kids are too young to understand there was a Judas among the 12 apostles. A lot of people look at the sex scandals and use that as a reason to avoid the church. Devouted Catholics understand the difference between the teachings of the church and the responsiblity sinners need to take for going against it. That is something most adults can’t understand. I would NEVER expect a kid to understand that. By putting your kids in a baptist school because there is better morals around sexuality… Well you have just made it harder for them to understand love the sinner hate the sin.

And by the age of your children their hormones have not kick in. Once they hit puberty, the social media will totally outrule any thing the baptist taught them about sex.

I would put them in a public school and sure the home environment teaches the religion is the Catholic school is not an option.

PS you could always do what is really best and pray for them 🙂
 
At the baptist school they will probably learn religion (required religion classes) they won’t be old enough to tell you everything they heard and are at a gullible/impressionable age.

My cousin went to Protestant school he now believes a protestant view of history which lies blantantly about the catholic church and the reformation probably just because of their assurement that they are right ahead of time before they even check all the facts.

They will convey with BOTH their actions and teachings that sin just effects their relationship with God not the salvation of the soul and that it is a choice, even if following God’s commands is very good, it is not deadly serious for the soul to follow the commandments (salvation) a.k.a. the absence of fear of Hell for those who believe in the existance of God.
 
If not a Catholic school, then a public school. Where NO religion is taught, nor allowed to be discussed for that matter.

I’m in agreement with some of the above questioning. WHAT ON EARTH has happened at your Catholic school that undermines the Church, when there is virtually NO WAY a baptist school would support the Church, (or wouldn’t they be Catholic?)

Very confusing logic. Can you elaborate so that it makes sense? There must be more to this story.
 
I would definatly NOT send kids to a Baptist school. Isn’t there a public school? Why not send the kids there and teach them religion at home?
 
Wow! A lot of comments. Most very helpful and respectful. A few need to be more charitable. My wife and I are strong in our catholic faith (although still sinners:)) someone just exploring the faith or struggling might be scared away. I will answer some of the questions that came up…
  1. The specific issue at the catholic school was the “acceptance” of alternative lifestyles as written in the school high/ middle school newspaper. The full page spread article, written by kids and cleared by teacher/advisor and principal and distributed to 7th to 12th graders. This was my most grievous issue. Group of parents went to the bishop but got no action, sadly.
  2. I agree the church starts at home and we do our best to catechize the children.
  3. we are considering homeschooling, but we have some challenges in doing so, which I won’t go into here. 😊
The most helpful posts were ones that related to psychological stress it could put on the kids by being subtlety and not so subtlety under attack for their faith. Obviously it depends on the kid but again posts on those who have had similar experiences are helpful.

Thanks, especially for the prayers!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top