Catholic choosing non-Catholic wedding

  • Thread starter Thread starter milkbar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

milkbar

Guest
I don’t know that I actually have a question. I’m just sad and disappointed. My best friend is marrying a Catholic man. But his family fell away from the Church a while back over what I gather were issues of a social nature; he is now a staunch liberal, politically, so I can guess which issues were at stake (I don’t know him, the fiance, well enough to have asked the tough questions yet).

Now they’re having some sort of non-denominational ceremony for the wedding. It is at least in “a” church, but it’s not Catholic. He plans on having the marriage convalidated later if he decides to come back to the Church.

I know this is not going to make or break him, so to speak, sin-wise; he does not attend Mass even on holidays, etc., so he already likely has problems, but still I hoped he would choose to do the right thing at least for his wedding. Now all I can think is that he’ll have one more obstacle, a big one, and I can’t understand why he doesn’t care. And I can’t understand his Catholic parents not caring. And I can’t understand any Catholics not caring!

I was so happy when my friend met and eventually became engaged to a Christian. Her family is just not religious at all. I was initially a little put off by the fact that he was Catholic, being a Protestant myself, and then I converted, and then I hoped my friend would eventually become Catholic as well.

I realize all hope is not lost, and I am praying. But I had set so many hopes on their wedding ceremony and the preparations and on him, at least, possibly coming back to the Church through it all, if not leading my best friend to the Church with him. It’s so very sad to witness another Catholic just letting themselves go.

I’ve started to post about this several times as I’ve been in the midst of helping my friend look at Catholic churches, which was apparently the catalyst for her fiance waking up and taking a more active role in helping choose the wedding location… now it’s all over, so to speak, and I’m confused. I want to be happy for my friend, and I am her maid of honor, and I AM happy for her, but then in the middle of the wedding I don’t know how I’m going to be able to stand there and watch someone in the very act of committing a mortal sin, and watch his parents watch him and say nothing, and so on. I feel a ridiculously irrational obligation to DO something but there wasn’t much I could do beyond hand my friend as much information as I could find on a silver platter (I did a whole lot of learning because I’m a convert with no Catholic wedding experience whatsoever), and that wasn’t enough. I feel helpless.

I think some people may say not to go to the wedding or at least not be involved in it, but this is my very best friend, and she isn’t the one making the disobedient mistake here… and if I abandon her over this, it’s not going to make them change the wedding plans, but it would cause a terrible rift and I would not be able to be an example over the years and help gently encourage them to do other things like register at a parish and have their children baptized and have their marriage convalidated and so on.

I’m just so disappointed and frustrated. I’m hoping someone will have words of wisdom for me.
 
It’s a challenging situation.

But some of us put God to the test, try to negotiate, choose how, when, or even if they can carry their cross.

Being your best friend, it may be advisable to attend but decline formal participation (being a bridesmaid or other member).

Keep on your friend to see that rules are there for a reason–and not to be so presumptuous in their faith. And, yes, keep praying. God bless.
 
Here are a few of threads on CAF that I’ve participated in that are relevant here as well. Perhaps you will find them helpful to read. Also, if you do a search, I’m sure you will find many other threads on the topic to read too. Still, my best advice to you is to pray as you discern what to do.

Would you attend an invalid wedding?
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=6518026

My uncle wont go to my wedding
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=368570

Is it a sin to attend an invalid wedding of a Catholic?
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=385694

Civilly Divorced Brother-in-Law Dating Without Annulment - Advice Please
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=281047

Can I participate in a Non Valid Marriage?
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=253754
 
Sometimes the best you can do is just stand by and be the very best Catholic you can be. It sounds like the gentleman left the Church a while back and no longer considers himself Catholic but at least he recognizes that he should be married in front of God in a church. Sometimes the birth of a child causes one to stop and reflect on where they stand spiritually, hopefully he will mature by then and have the child baptized. Be as supportive as you can be and pray, pray, pray. Leave the rest to the Holy Spirit!
 
I don’t know that I actually have a question. I’m just sad and disappointed. My best friend is marrying a Catholic man. But his family fell away from the Church a while back over what I gather were issues of a social nature; he is now a staunch liberal, politically, so I can guess which issues were at stake (I don’t know him, the fiance, well enough to have asked the tough questions yet).

Now they’re having some sort of non-denominational ceremony for the wedding. It is at least in “a” church, but it’s not Catholic. He plans on having the marriage convalidated later if he decides to come back to the Church.

I know this is not going to make or break him, so to speak, sin-wise; he does not attend Mass even on holidays, etc., so he already likely has problems, but still I hoped he would choose to do the right thing at least for his wedding. Now all I can think is that he’ll have one more obstacle, a big one, and I can’t understand why he doesn’t care. And I can’t understand his Catholic parents not caring. And I can’t understand any Catholics not caring!

I was so happy when my friend met and eventually became engaged to a Christian. Her family is just not religious at all. I was initially a little put off by the fact that he was Catholic, being a Protestant myself, and then I converted, and then I hoped my friend would eventually become Catholic as well.

I realize all hope is not lost, and I am praying. But I had set so many hopes on their wedding ceremony and the preparations and on him, at least, possibly coming back to the Church through it all, if not leading my best friend to the Church with him. It’s so very sad to witness another Catholic just letting themselves go.

I’ve started to post about this several times as I’ve been in the midst of helping my friend look at Catholic churches, which was apparently the catalyst for her fiance waking up and taking a more active role in helping choose the wedding location… now it’s all over, so to speak, and I’m confused. I want to be happy for my friend, and I am her maid of honor, and I AM happy for her, but then in the middle of the wedding I don’t know how I’m going to be able to stand there and watch someone in the very act of committing a mortal sin, and watch his parents watch him and say nothing, and so on. I feel a ridiculously irrational obligation to DO something but there wasn’t much I could do beyond hand my friend as much information as I could find on a silver platter (I did a whole lot of learning because I’m a convert with no Catholic wedding experience whatsoever), and that wasn’t enough. I feel helpless.

I think some people may say not to go to the wedding or at least not be involved in it, but this is my very best friend, and she isn’t the one making the disobedient mistake here… and if I abandon her over this, it’s not going to make them change the wedding plans, but it would cause a terrible rift and I would not be able to be an example over the years and help gently encourage them to do other things like register at a parish and have their children baptized and have their marriage convalidated and so on.

I’m just so disappointed and frustrated. I’m hoping someone will have words of wisdom for me.
If a Catholic marries outside the Church without a special dispensation from the Church then the marriage will be considered invalid.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top