My experiences:
Back in the 1960’s my Catholic Grade School (one of the best in Chicago) had a tuition of $300 per student per year. The second child was $150. Families with three or more students paid $500 per year, total. One family had 13 children, another 11. Funny, they could have easily afforded full retail price. Instead, they donated substantially.Our pastor who would publish the weekly donations in the following week’s bulletin!
We had six priests, but none of them taught any classes. One was the baseball coach in the spring. Other sports had all volunteer coaches, usually alums who were cops or firemen and could make the time after school. We had mass weekly and confession was mandatory each month.
We had 24 nuns when I started kindergarten. When I entered 8th grade, there were only 12 remaining. The others went to other schools, ministries, or retirement. Most of the lay teachers were women. They were typically unmarried, newlyweds, or women whose children were grown. The two ladies who became moms stopped teaching after birth. I am still close to one of them today.
My 1st grade classroom had 46 students and one teacher. Of those 46 children, 43 graduated from college. The teachers taught and we were expected to learn. Plus we had four classes of first graders! Nearly 1500 students on the campus. Sadly, today there are only 600, but that is up from 530 three years ago. But tuition is now up to $4700 per student. I’ll have to check about family discounts, but I cannot think of many families with more than three children. There are plenty of scholarships available–but this is not publicized.

We do have a substantial endowment which certainly underwrites more than 50% of the real cost. Local public schools are in the $15,000 per student range.
Hot lunches were served at a cost of $1.00 per week. Milk was available for $0.02 per pint–I think the government subsidized it. There were a group of grandmothers who cooked and cleaned on a voluntary basis. The food was great, except for fishsticks EVERY Friday.
I took piano lessons from a sweet elderly nun. She charged $5 per hour. She used to nod off over the course of a half hour, but if you hit a wrong note…
My Jesuit high school education started at $1000 per year and ended at $1200 four years later in 1976. (Today it is $16,000/yr). We had 40 priests at one point. The school has only 4 religious now. It was all boys in my time but has been coed for about 20 years.
My daughter graduated near the top of her class and was a National Merit Scholar. My son was not accepted with a “B” average (and many years of donations) and with a double legacy. The school enrollment–even during the last six years of a fragile economy–is at an all time high. They are turning away many qualified candidates, including legacies that should be given some more consideration. The school was 99% Catholic in the 70’s and is about 90% today.
College tuition started at $5200 as a freshman and ended at $6800 in 1980. Room and Board was another $1000. (Today it is $62,400 all inclusive).
