Catholic Converts/Catechumens: What was your top reason for choosing to become a Catholic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ComeHome2Rome
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

ComeHome2Rome

Guest
To all Catholic Converts & Catholic Catechumens:
  1. What would you consider your top reason for becoming Catholic?
  2. What authentically Catholic source helped you the most? The Bible, the Catechism of the Catholic Church, a Papal Encyclical, a Church Council, a book with a local Catholic Bishop’s Imprimatur?
 
To all Catholic Converts & Catholic Catechumens:
  1. What would you consider your top reason for becoming Catholic?
  2. What authentically Catholic source helped you the most? The Bible, the Catechism of the Catholic Church, a Papal Encyclical, a Church Council, a book with a local Catholic Bishop’s Imprimatur?
I was confirmed during the Easter Vigil of this year, so I can definitely answer this question. I was raised Southern Baptist, but experimented with various denominations before leaving Christianity altogether. If I may, I would like to go into a bit of detail.
  1. prior entering the Church, I was a self-proclaimed atheist (I operated as an atheist, but I was quite angry at God, but still believed he exists, though I worked to try to destroy the faith of those around me as well as denying my own belief). During a visit to a Catholic Church for the first time, an early morning Sunday Mass, when the priest raised the Host, something tugged within myself. While I recognize in retrospect that I recognized second person of the Holy Trinity, I could not find a name for it. I just considered the Mass ‘neat.’ Over the next few months, I spoke with that same priest, as well as coming to Mass each Sunday. I would look at Catholic teaching and see the beautiful harmony between science and faith that I had longed for; an understanding of human pain that transcended even my own personal experience in it. However, it was a long while before my relationship with God was repaired – I am still working on it, but now have the help of not only the Church’s guidance, but also a priest who is an excellent confessor and the help of a spiritual director. I think in a way, the main hurdle was getting over the God is Love, not God Is. All of the Church’s teachings, once that one point was finally accepted, fell into place to create the most beautiful mosaic of thought that the world has seen.
  2. I would have to say the sources I used (I used the main site here as a “jumping board” for information a lot) that helped the most would be the one-on-one conversations with the priest, who is now at another parish (he is not the same one as the notedly skilled confessor).
 
To all Catholic Converts & Catholic Catechumens:
  1. What would you consider your top reason for becoming Catholic?
History, teenage rebillion.
  1. What authentically Catholic source helped you the most? The Bible, the Catechism of the Catholic Church, a Papal Encyclical, a Church Council, a book with a local Catholic Bishop’s Imprimatur?
I would not say the Bible is a Catholic source. However none of those did, it was just my interest and the fact that I thought the Church I went to was beautiful also teenage rebellion help a bit. Many teens try drinking, drugs, etc not me I tried a new religion. Been here for a while but never has it been a great thing
 
  1. I was a Luthern originally but never really practiced it, my family was never really religious and so other then going to church on holidays and we had a bible in the house that was about it. Then when my son was born, I happened to have a conversation with god while waiting to go in the operating room and said that i would look deeper into my faith if this all turned out for the best, which it did so I started to look at the different kinds of christianity and i found the catholic church, started reading about it and figured out “hey this all makes since” so I went to the parish and got in RCIA.
  2. I think that the biggest thing that helped me was the internet, the ability to pull up infomation and put them side by side and really examine the issues helped alot. also from just what your heart tells you, you will know the truth when you hear it.
 
I was confirmed during the Easter Vigil of this year, so I can definitely answer this question. I was raised Southern Baptist, but experimented with various denominations before leaving Christianity altogether. If I may, I would like to go into a bit of detail.
  1. prior entering the Church, I was a self-proclaimed atheist (I operated as an atheist, but I was quite angry at God, but still believed he exists, though I worked to try to destroy the faith of those around me as well as denying my own belief). During a visit to a Catholic Church for the first time, an early morning Sunday Mass, when the priest raised the Host, something tugged within myself. While I recognize in retrospect that I recognized second person of the Holy Trinity, I could not find a name for it. I just considered the Mass ‘neat.’ Over the next few months, I spoke with that same priest, as well as coming to Mass each Sunday. I would look at Catholic teaching and see the beautiful harmony between science and faith that I had longed for; an understanding of human pain that transcended even my own personal experience in it. However, it was a long while before my relationship with God was repaired – I am still working on it, but now have the help of not only the Church’s guidance, but also a priest who is an excellent confessor and the help of a spiritual director. I think in a way, the main hurdle was getting over the God is Love, not God Is. All of the Church’s teachings, once that one point was finally accepted, fell into place to create the most beautiful mosaic of thought that the world has seen.
  2. I would have to say the sources I used (I used the main site here as a “jumping board” for information a lot) that helped the most would be the one-on-one conversations with the priest, who is now at another parish (he is not the same one as the notedly skilled confessor).
That is just amazing! Love the details, thank you for sharing!
  1. “God is Love, not God Is.” 2. a great Priest
 
History, teenage rebillion.

I would not say the Bible is a Catholic source. However none of those did, it was just my interest and the fact that I thought the Church I went to was beautiful also teenage rebellion help a bit. Many teens try drinking, drugs, etc not me I tried a new religion. Been here for a while but never has it been a great thing
teenage rebellion, your parents are probably glad it wasn’t drinking or drugs 😃

I consider the Bible a Catholic source since it was written by Catholics, Catholic Bishops determined what books would & would not be included in it at Catholic Councils headed by the Catholic Pope and because it was preserved and copied over the centuries by Catholic Monks and translated by Catholics into all the various languages in the world.

Why do you not consider the Bible a Catholic source?
 
  1. I was a Luthern originally but never really practiced it, my family was never really religious and so other then going to church on holidays and we had a bible in the house that was about it. Then when my son was born, I happened to have a conversation with god while waiting to go in the operating room and said that i would look deeper into my faith if this all turned out for the best, which it did so I started to look at the different kinds of christianity and i found the catholic church, started reading about it and figured out “hey this all makes since” so I went to the parish and got in RCIA.
  2. I think that the biggest thing that helped me was the internet, the ability to pull up infomation and put them side by side and really examine the issues helped alot. also from just what your heart tells you, you will know the truth when you hear it.
A big Welcome Home to you and your son!
 
To all Catholic Converts & Catholic Catechumens:
  1. What would you consider your top reason for becoming Catholic?
Truth and I don’t say that as an underhanded comment to anyone of another faith. The only reason to really follow any faith is because the person who choose the faith has tested it and found it to be true. A faith could have all the greatest things in the world but if, at the end of the day, you don’t really believe it to be true, what’s the point?
  1. What authentically Catholic source helped you the most? The Bible, the Catechism of the Catholic Church, a Papal Encyclical, a Church Council, a book with a local Catholic Bishop’s Imprimatur?
Well outside the Bible and the Catechism the two biggest influences on me during my conversion was Chesterton and C.S. Lewis and they are still to this day.

God bless
 
teenage rebellion, your parents are probably glad it wasn’t drinking or drugs 😃
They probably wish it was drinking. Joining a new religion strained my relationship with my mom and even though it got better before she passed. I consider it one of my worst mistakes of all time
I consider the Bible a Catholic source since it was written by Catholics, Catholic Bishops determined what books would & would not be included in it at Catholic Councils headed by the Catholic Pope and because it was preserved and copied over the centuries by Catholic Monks and translated by Catholics into all the various languages in the world.

Why do you not consider the Bible a Catholic source?
The Bible was t written by Catholics. The OT was written by Jewish people and the NT was written by Apostles. Long before a Catholic Church existed there was a Bible, all the Catholic Church did was codify into a whole unit it for their followers and then that did not become official for quite sometime.

So no the Bible is not an exclusively Catholic book, I was brainwashed to think that too until I really studied it.
 
I was enjoying the OP’s thread that went the other way…Sorry to see that they closed it…I didn’t think that was right…People were just sharing their own experiences…I thought it was done in a very respectful way…

As for the sacred scriptures, It they came before the schism, I would say the christians as small “c” catholic church when all the sees were together> Today when you say Catholic source people think of the Catholic church as it is today… The catholic church today is a tad different the church catholic with all the sees…
I would not say the Bible is a Catholic source. However none of those did, it was just my interest and the fact that I thought the Church I went to was beautiful also teenage rebellion help a bit. Many teens try drinking, drugs, etc not me I tried a new religion. Been here for a while but never has it been a great thing
 
I was baptized at age 36 at Pentacost into the Catholic Church as a Maronite. I’d been interested in Catholism for years ever since I went to Jordan and stood where Moses was shown Israel. I waded in the dead sea and lived in Italy a few years. However as I had a lax religious upbringing. I didn’t feel the pool of religion until I joined the military. However every church or ecclesial community I went to just didn’t feel right. You know when you feel at home? Thats the feeling I’m talking about here. After getting honorably discharged I found a job.
I met Martha at work. Martha a Roman Catholic took me to Our Lady’s Maronite Catholic parish she thought I’d like to see something unique in catholism. I liked the Divine Liturgy but my girlfriend at the time who went with us, wasn’t interested; she hated the incense and didn’t resonate with the service. So it would be many years and girlfriends before i went back. When I was alone and again looking into religion. I actually like Anglicanism as a form of Catholic Lite, but I couldn’t quite bring myself into accepting the contradictory statements of some of it branches womens ordination and the whole same sex issue would they all commune me I’m sure they would to be anglican they’d have too, but to me atleast it seemed to change too much with public morality. I still like anglicanism but in a different way than I did before, I find its history truly fascinating.
I knew that if you were catholic you could go to any catholic church to receive the sacraments and that even though there are 22 different churches with differing traditions they all affirm the same dogma through the creed and apostolic succession. I started thinking of how hard it must have been for Jesus to walk among his people the jews and yet get such a cold should from them. Only a few would hear him and follow. The jews are the chosen people. Yet they still have to accept his message even today. Some do and some don’t. Why do i mention this? Simple, the same thing applies even among the Christians. If you accept him then follow him. I’m not saying that christian ecclesial communities aren’t saved. We all are through baptism and accepting Jesus’s sacrifice at Calvary for us all. But like I read here at CAF; think of Catholism as being at the mouth of a raging river all the other Christian communities are farther from it but still along its banks. Thus as much as I like Anglicanism I like Catholism just a wee bit more. Can it be strict yes. But perhaps that strictness is what’s needed in today’s loose society where secularism rules. But more than all of that, I feel at home…finally.
 
  1. I have to agree with the person who said “truth.” When I was first introduced to the Church, I was not really searching for anything new. I was happy in my little Southern Baptist world and content with my beliefs at the time. When I met the man who would later become my husband, he was Catholic and I was, naturally, curious about his beliefs. In fact, when we first started having our discussions about religion, I had every intention of convincing him he was wrong! And look where that got me! LOL
  2. Born Fundamentalist, Born Again Catholic by David Currie was by far the most influential book I read at the time, outside of the Bible. That book answered some of the more serious questions I had and I can say beyond a doubt that, without that book, it would have taken me much much longer to become Catholic.
 
My continuing journey to Rome began in Utah. I found “Rome Sweet Home” and “Catholicism and Fundamentalism” and from there went to the Bible to check “those Catholics” and then to the CCC and “Salt of the Earth”

From there it has been reading the Church fathers, reading “REALLY READING” the Bible and the constant help of Our Lady.
 
To all Catholic Converts & Catholic Catechumens:
  1. What would you consider your top reason for becoming Catholic?
  2. What authentically Catholic source helped you the most? The Bible, the Catechism of the Catholic Church, a Papal Encyclical, a Church Council, a book with a local Catholic Bishop’s Imprimatur?
  1. The real presence of Jesus Christ in Holy Eucharist/Blessed Sacrament
  2. Heaviest influences: The Gospel according to John. “The Lamb’s Supper” by Dr. Scott Hahn, The Book or Revelation (Apocalypse), Going to a few masses taking the queue from Dr. Hahn’s aforementioned book, then of course enrolling in RCIA.
 
I was in RCIA. Had put it off for a year. You see, I knew the rule. I knew that if I became Catholic I would have to go to Church every single Sunday. **I wasn’t ready to give God an entire hour a week. **

I think about that now and wonder why he just didn’t strike me. Unbaptized as well. Headed straight for Hell.

And then I went to Mass. I knew that very first time. This is worship.

That’s it, I was done. Now I go to daily mass. And I am co-owner of a Catholic bookstore and visit inmates in prison.

Every single day I thank God that He made me Catholic. Easter vigil 2008.
 
To all Catholic Converts & Catholic Catechumens:
  1. What would you consider your top reason for becoming Catholic?
  2. What authentically Catholic source helped you the most? The Bible, the Catechism of the Catholic Church, a Papal Encyclical, a Church Council, a book with a local Catholic Bishop’s Imprimatur?
Pride, History and Rebellion
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top