Catholic education question

  • Thread starter Thread starter YoungTradCath
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Y

YoungTradCath

Guest
I didn’t really know where else to post this, as I generally limit myself to the Traditional and Liturgy & Sacraments forums.

Anyways, do you think it possible that part of the increasing cost to attend Catholic school is due to lay teachers? In the past, it was common to have sisters and brothers teach at Catholic schools. Of course, they would be paid with food, lodging, etc., and perhaps a small stipend (or perhaps not), but they would not be paid a salary like lay teachers are.

I live in a medium-sized city in South Carolina, and we have two Catholic churches and a Catholic school system (imagine that in a South Carolina county of 100,000). Between the two churches, there are about 1,000 families. Many of them have children, and usually more than one. However, between the two Catholic schools, there are only about fifty-five to sixty students. I can’t help but think that the smallness of the population is due to the fact that tuition costs more than other regional private schools. It’s around $5,000 a year, but that’s very expensive compared to the other private schools, which I’d argue are better in educational quality and curriculum than the Catholic schools.

When I lived in Kentucky, it was a diocesan-wide policy that Catholic schools would charge no less than $12,000 a year, and a maximum of $18,000 a year. You can imagine that most schools charged the maximum. That’s… almost unfathomable to me.
 
I think that is a common assumption, but not entirely true.

In the parish my DH grew up in, they had a Catholic school for years. This is a small rural parish in a farming community. In the late 1960s the order withdrew their sisters because the parish could not pay them the amount they required to provide teachers for the school. While the individual sisters did not receive a wage, their order did receive the money and in this case they apparently wanted more than the parish could provide.
 
I can’t help but think that the smallness of the population is due to the fact that tuition costs more than other regional private schools. It’s around $5,000 a year, but that’s very expensive compared to the other private schools, which I’d argue are better in educational quality and curriculum than the Catholic schools.

When I lived in Kentucky, it was a diocesan-wide policy that Catholic schools would charge no less than $12,000 a year, and a maximum of $18,000 a year. You can imagine that most schools charged the maximum. That’s… almost unfathomable to me.
Between $12 to $18,000 a year! :eek:
 
I would image minimum wage laws might still apply to Catholic school employees, even if it is run by a religious order. The sisters or brothers would of course turn all their wages over to the order, but there is still a cost in this regard.

The order, too, has expenses, that would be equivalent to running a modest household, as well as eduction/formation expenses for its members, etc., so its not unreasonable for the order to request payments that are greater than simply minimum wage.

So I don’t really think it would be the case that merely swapping lay teachers for religious teachers would necessarily raise tuition costs. Catholics school wages for lay teachers are already quite modest, so labor expenses would likely be only slightly greater compared to using a religious order.

The tuition costs are, unfortunately, most likely driven up by the supply and demand cycle. My father grew up in a largely Catholic city, and almost everyone in the 60’s sent their children to the Catholic Schools. As demographics shifted, more students went to public schools. With fewer students, tuition necessarily rose.

Maintaining a quality educational environment is expensive. With few students, Catholic education becomes just a bit of a luxury (though perhaps a worthy luxury :)).
 
I didn’t really know where else to post this, as I generally limit myself to the Traditional and Liturgy & Sacraments forums.

Anyways, do you think it possible that part of the increasing cost to attend Catholic school is due to lay teachers? In the past, it was common to have sisters and brothers teach at Catholic schools. …
Yes, I believe the limited number of vocations contributes to the increasing cost of Catholic school. Salary is only part of that. Fundraising and fiscal management also comes into play. The frugal nature of many who take religious vows of poverty may also contribute to better financial management of schools. Religious orders that are dedicated to educating the poor can find a variety of other ways to keep tuition low. I suspect that beloved nuns who call up former students (who grow into successful adults) and ask for donation for the school raise funds rather well.

It takes a spirit of generosity and sacrifice to vows of poverty, chastity and obedience. Such examples of generosity and sacrifice encourage others to make smaller sacrifices.
 
Well, the religious order would pay for the room and board of the sisters, not the school’s tuition. The religious were often payed peanuts and that was that. I however would say the the expense has increased for a multitude of reasons beyond teachers. We’re talking increased administration costs. The Catholic school I went to as a child had ok tuition. The old parish priest was trying to save up donations from parish members to create scholarships for low income students. Than low and behold, the diocese decided to combine all the Catholic schools in the deanery together, create one giant administration board to oversee these schools (this included Catholic daycare centers) and make the tuition universal for all the schools. With all the administration costs, the price for sending kids to these schools drastically went up.
 
In Wichita, Catholic schools are tuition-free. All parishes support the schools through the diocesan Stewardship efforts.
 
Enrollment in Catholic schools dropped from 6+ million to 2.4 million in 40 years, while the population increased. We need to legalize school vouchers. That will solve the problem immediately. With school vouchers, enrollment in Catholic schools will go up, and tuition fees will drop again.
 
In Wichita, Catholic schools are tuition-free. All parishes support the schools through the diocesan Stewardship efforts.
Yes. Good point. That diocese has made extra efforts to encourage stewardship. It asks Catholics to be more generous. One way or another, Catholic schools require generosity if they are going to be affordable to average Catholic parents. (Slightly off topic, but I wonder if the encouragement of generosity and stewardship in Wichita will result in more vocations coming from that diocese in future years?)
 
I teach in a small Catholic high school in the midwest with a 7-12 enrollment that is less than 100 students. Our tuition is less than $2500 thanks to generous alumni. The ‘blue ribbon’ Catholic high school 20 miles away is one of the top 50 schools in the nation and has tuition under $4,000. All are lay teachers.:rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top