It seems that an reoccurring issue here is affordability of the Catholic education.
My husband and I are also wrestling with these issues as well. We recently moved to Massachusetts and have one school aged child, one new kindergartener and a preschooler. I was shocked to find out the the tuition here is about $5000 per child per year not including uniforms, supplies, mandatory fund raising -will cost us another $300, transportation, activities fees and extracurricular fees. For my family the tuition alone next year would be $15000 per year. And we are supposed to be saving for college, too.
Catholic schools have long been the gold standard (at least in places like Philadelphia and Boston), and I have been fortunate to receive a Catholic grade school education, but I think now it is cost-prohibitive. My mother was a single mother raising 4 kids and put us all through Catholic grade school. She made sacrifices to do this and I am thankful.
However, when I did the math, I calculate the percentage of tuition (4 kids in the 1980’s) in the local Catholic school against her income. With 4 kids all attending school at the rate of tuition that at that time, she spent 3% on of her gross income. (She was a police officer, so she wasn’t a high paid executive).
Now I examine our comparison: 3 children in our local Catholic school at today’s price as a percentage of our income. (key income difference…married couple of two professionals, one working full time and one working part time.) Our tuition bill would make up about 14.5% of our annual gross income. It is no longer about making sacrifices. To be able to afford our $15000 tuition bill, we can’t just give up a vacation or put off buying a car this year or next.
Clearly a lot of these Catholic schools have outpaced themselves with the tuition increases. Even with this biased evaluation (4 kids versus 3 and a a single police officer’s salary versus 2 working professionals), one should easily be able to see what is happening to our Catholic education system.
Interestingly, as the tuition becomes less affordable to families, the student enrollment goes down. When the enrollment goes down, the tuition goes up for the remaining families. When the tuition goes up for the remaining families, more families cannot afford it and withdraw from school. It is a vicious cycle and I do not see the archdiocese really addressing this issue. I know that there is financial aid, but seriously, how could those of us subject to the federal Alternative Minimum Tax every year qualify for financial aid!!!
Why are the archdiocese not trying to save our schools? Sometimes I wonder is the local parishes are more concerned about affording the air conditioning for the church than the unavailability of a Catholic education for it’s youngest members.